3 ms·
Most commentators seem to be reading way to much into this, although NBC news bears some of the blame for that. This is a case of the Supreme Court declining t
by tzs 4y ago
Most commentators seem to be reading way to much into this, although NBC news bears some of the blame for that.
This is a case of the Supreme Court declining to hear a case, not a case of the Supreme Court hearing a case and then making a decision.
You can't really infer anything about the Court's opinion on the merits of the case in these situations, because there are a variety of common reasons for them to decline to hear a case that have nothing to do with the merits.
∙ They often don't want to take a case on some issue unless there has been conflicting rulings on that issue in different circuits.
∙ They often don't want to take a case unless the issue has been dealt with enough times in the lower courts to have hashed out the major arguments for both sides.
∙ Even when it is an issue that they think the Court should be taking up, they often like to wait until they get a case that presents the issue cleanly.
∙ If they think that the issue could be addressed adequately by legislation they will often decline to take a case.
∙ There are more cases submitted than the Court has time to handle. The case may simply have been pushed aside by more important cases.
- jfengel 4y agoAnd that is why I refuse to use the titles accorded to members of the Supreme Court. It is obviously an issue in which they take no interest. Whatever it is they dole out at the Supreme Court, it's not "justice".
- ajross 4y agoThis is all true, but those points don't apply well here. This was a Qualified Immunity case[1], and one of the clearest abuses of that broken paradigm. There was genuine hope that this, finally, would be the case SCOTUS would take to clear up this mess. But I guess we have to keep waiting. [1] Essentially, as interpreted: you can't sue a cop unless some other court found another cop liable for exactly the same abuse. And since other courts are bound by the same principle, there aren't any such rulings. Obviously wikipedia will explain this more dryly, but the actual principle as applied really is this circular. It's a disaster.
- anticensor 4y agoThen the US congress should make a statute to better delineate the limits of the qualified immunity.
- ajross 4y agoQI isn't a law, though, that's the thing. SCOTUS just made it up in 1967. I mean, actually there already is a law. A common sense reading of "No State shall [...] deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws" would be interpreted to mean that cops and non-cops can be liable for the same things in the same ways. But no, cops are special, and not because congress legislated a particular regulation regime, but just because the civil rights era court thought it was unfair to cops to hold them liable for arresting black protesters without cause. [1] Too lazy to cite the actual law. Finding it is left as an exercise for the reader.