3 ms·
> Suppose that the parents have two children who need child care. That is $540 per week. The parent salary has to be at least $540 per week to make the choice o
by kube-system 4y ago
> Suppose that the parents have two children who need child care. That is $540 per week. The parent salary has to be at least $540 per week to make the choice of child care economical. But that does not take into account taxes.
Even worse than that, it doesn’t take into account commutes, and the opportunity cost of not spending time with your own kids. If you make just enough money at work to pay for childcare, what the heck are you doing?
- texaslonghorn5 4y ago> If you make just enough money at work to pay for childcare, what the heck are you doing? $540/40hrs = $13.5/hr. Any number of jobs pay this little.
- protonbob 4y agoThat's take home pay. With taxes it's much higher.
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoso based on empirical observations I am sure there are a number of people who are making barely enough to support the child care cost quoted in the post I quoted. maybe I misinterpreted the post I responded to
- evan_ 4y agothen you also need to factor in tax rebates for childcare, which won't cover 100% but it will lessen the impact
- kube-system 4y agoLOL. I meant that rhetorically, not literally. I am suggesting that it is a bad life choice to work a job and then spend every penny paying someone else to take care of your kids for you.
- alocasia-1 4y agoI know you're being rhetorical, but often, just trying to avoid a gap in your resume. It sucks but there can be a greater long-term cost to trying to reenter the workforce after taking years off to raise kids.
- xyzelement 4y agoI am just curious, is this a hypothetical or do you know of many people who actually made the explicit choice to break even working, just to have continuity of resume? It smells a little like BS to me, both because it seems to be often repeated (so sounds like a talking point) but I can't imagine any parents I know to actually decide this way
- alocasia-1 4y agoI've worked with a couple of folks that have said this exact thing, yes. One was a lab tech and I'm pretty sure she was less-than-breaking-even with putting her two kids in daycare. So yeah, it's definitely a real thing.
- ljf 4y agoI agree - but have seen many families have to make this choice, as having too big a gap in your CV (to look after their kids) will impact there employability down the line. It is also hard to stay current and to retain confidence in your ability when you are out of the working world. Don't get me wrong - stay at home parents have amazing skills and learn loads, but few employers see that as a benefit when you are looking to return to work. In the UK there is a movement called 'Pregnant then Screwed' which is trying to address this.
- notahacker 4y ago> I agree - but have seen many families have to make this choice, as having too big a gap in your CV (to look after their kids) will impact there employability down the line. This is true, but does raise a couple of obvious points. First, if there are implied future earnings returns from working with young child, those ought to be factored into the calculations for returns to work in the OP (with appropriate caveats about possible cashflow problems). Secondly, should it be affecting future employability? The few career paths where absolute commitment to work and track record of continuous improvement and networking seem absolutely necessary signals (like trying to make partner at an accountancy or law firm) tend to pay pretty well anyway. Other career paths should - in theory at least - be less contingent on continuity, or even offer realistic opportunities to continue to work or use work related skills part time and remotely.
- ljf 4y agoVery true - but even in 'low pressure' creative fields that I've worked in in the past, people would rather take a researcher who has just come off a job, than one who has spent 4 years looking after children. The assumption is that the 'current' person will be 'better'. I think there is also a covert feeling that those with children (in particular women) will be less wedded to their role. People have been shocked when I've stayed home to look after our sick children, and my wife went into work. This remains a gendered issue.
- hrunt 4y agoChildren are not in daycare for their parents' entire lives. Once children reach kindergarten, many public school systems provide after-school care for working parents that is significantly cheaper than private daycare. Some provide before-school care as well, but usually schools time their starts to community work schedules. If you make just enough to pay for childcare now and decide to, instead, leave your job to spend time with your children, you are giving up some number of years of professional job growth. When you return to the market, you will likely not have grown your skills and will most likely enter around the same pay level as when you left. If you stay in the market, you will have spent that money on childcare, but you will now most likely have grown your salary through wage increases and job transitions. In addition, while you may be giving up some time with your children during their early years, they also gain substantial growth with their peers and outside influences which may help them as they grow older. My wife and I made this choice with our children, and that was what the heck we were doing. Childcare was expensive, but we knew it had a time limit, and when our children finally entered public school, we were substantially better off than if one of us had left our jobs. We feel the experience for our children was great as well, considering they still speak fondly of their pre-K experiences.
- falcolas 4y ago> If you make just enough money at work to pay for childcare, what the heck are you doing? Probably mitigating the cost of family health care between two earners (US centric, of course).
- Balgair 4y ago$540/week for 2 kids is a steal where I am. Local costs are >$600/wk for two kids near us, and I have friends in other metros that are closer to $800/wk. Nannies are more like $1k/wk no matter the family size.
- hd95489 4y agoHa I misread that as 540 a week for 1 kid which is right in line with Seattle rates