5 ms·
They were already a publicly traded corporation. Their interests have never been aligned with yours fundamentally, they've been aligned with a fiduciary duty to
by crazygringo 4y ago
They were already a publicly traded corporation. Their interests have never been aligned with yours fundamentally, they've been aligned with a fiduciary duty to make profit for shareholders. Literally nothing about the profit motive has changed.
But fortunately their business model has been about providing a superior level of care for a small extra fee, and presumably Amazon is buying them for that strength. Otherwise it would be a pretty pointless acquisition.
But who knows, maybe now there'll be a discount if you have a Prime membership or something. :P
- eli 4y agoAmazon has a reputation for ruthless efficiency. Seems speculative to assume that they bought One Medical because of its high level of care and that they are able to manage the company in a way that it continues. There are plenty of Amazon acquisitions where the service got worse post-acquisition, was relaunched as something else, or was simply shuttered.
- crazygringo 4y agoBut Amazon already did the same with Whole Foods. It continues to be premium. There were some temporary hiccups at one point with a new backend system but that was all. So I don't see why they wouldn't be doing the same they've done with Whole Foods, which is maintaining the high level of service, because that's the proven successful business model.
- slantedview 4y agoWhole Foods workers were impacted by the acquisition. Since healthcare depends on high skill workers, any impact to them will harm customers.
- j0hnyl 4y agoWhole Foods is absolute TRASH after Amazon bought it. The food used to be good and now it's absolute crap, less options, utter rubbish no better than keyfood. At least in NYC anyway. (multiple locations)
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> in NYC anyway True in Wyoming and the Bay Area, too. Produce and fish aren’t as fresh as competitors. It’s cheaper. But not premium.
- sgc 4y agoI don't find this true at all in my bay area location. Their fish is still the freshest in the area, including when comparing to the local fishmonger. Their produce is well above the quality and freshness of other stores except one, which they can match. Their bakery is still quite good. Variety is roughly the same. It's the same old overpriced-but-reliable Whole Foods.
- crazygringo 4y agoI'm in NYC and I have no idea what you're talking about. The food is the same. Nothing has changed that I can tell. Same hot/cold bar. Same produce. Same meat and fish. Same in house brands. Same pizza. Same bakery. Main differences are just a lot more self checkout and areas for Amazon returns. And Prime discounts of course. What food do you think got worse?
- rcme 4y agoThe produce has changed a lot. Now, the fruits and vegetables leave a lot to be desired. If you compare the best from Whole Foods and the best from Fresh Direct, you'll see that Fresh Direct is a clear winner in most categories, but especially in produce and meat. The two used to be a lot closer in terms of quality.
- j0hnyl 4y agoEven the prepared food has changed. It's feels cheap and tastes like shit, but carries the same price. Gowanus whole foods had a whole section of moldy cold cuts not too long. If people haven't noticed what I'm talking about, its probably that they just don't remember how nice it used to be before.
- 4y ago
- dml2135 4y agoWhole foods has absolutely gone downhill after Amazon bought it.
- anon7725 4y agoYour prior should be that after Amazon acquires a company and Amazon "leaders" make their way into the corporate structure, that company will go downhill in terms of any customer-service differentiator. cf Zappos, Whole Foods, etc. The differentiators - usually reflected in motivated staff with the freedom to solve customer problems, but also in the case of WF a focus on quality fresh food, etc - will be relentlessly driven down. WF continues to be "premium" but it's definitely not the same chain that it was a decade ago.
- adolph 4y agoDisagree. I had reasonable hopes Mackey had struck a business preserving deal. Recently discussed the homogenous thin sponge they still market at "ciabatta" with folks who go more often. They said the all bread is now outsourced and terrible. My reasonable hopes stemmed from what HEB has done with sub-brand Central Market. While CM isn't quite as awesome as its high point, more CM goodness has rolled into regular HEB than bean-counting into CM.
- JohnFen 4y ago> It continues to be premium. It does? Not in my area. I've never been a Whole Foods customer, but my friends who were have universally said that it has become much worse.
- kortilla 4y ago> They were already a publicly traded corporation. Their interests have never been aligned with yours fundamentally, they've been aligned with a fiduciary duty to make profit for shareholders. Literally nothing about the profit motive has changed. This is a trope that needs to stop. Public companies are not alike and the fiduciary duty is only a very high level one that can be used to justify both squeezing every customer as much as possible to losing money to support growth. What the shareholders want matters and an acquisition changes that completely.
- loeg 4y ago> a fiduciary duty to make profit for shareholders. This is a fake rule that people love to repeat. It isn't true. E.g., but feel free to google it yourself -- there are a multitude of articles on the subject: https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/04/16/what-are-corporations-obligations-to-shareholders/corporations-dont-have-to-maximize-profits https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/04/16/what-are-co...
- crazygringo 4y agoI didn't say it was the sole/only objective that must be pursued without any regard to anything else, which seems to be the straw man that that NYT article is arguing against. But yes, a board of a for-profit corporation must pursue profits to their full reasonable capability. If they neglect that duty, they will be sued and replaced. This is, for example, why Twitter had no choice but to sell to Elon. Because that was most profitable to shareholders. Otherwise the board would have been taken to court and lost. That is fiduciary duty to profits. The idea that it's a "fake rule" is also something people love to repeat. But that isn't true. A publicly traded corporation simply cannot choose to forgo profits for all time and invest in customer service instead, for example. There absolutely is a fiduciary duty to make decisions that are ultimately profitable. (But that obviously goes along with flexibility to e.g. invest more to defer profits, invest in nice offices to attract better employees, etc.)
- mrguyorama 4y ago>But yes, a board of a for-profit corporation must pursue profits to their full reasonable capability. No this has been explicitly rejected by the court. The fiduciary duty a company has to it's board is to not screw them over. A company has the freedom to leave money on the table in order to do the right thing. Your shareholders have no grounds to sue you if you are doing something that doesn't produce 100% profit but still produces reasonable profit.
- yunwal 4y agoAmazon's likely buying One Medical for the same reason as most of it's acquisitions: to have an in-house team to dogfood AWS solutions. They'll care about customer experience enough to maintain a reasonable customer base, but improving the state of primary care won't be the priority.
- JohnFen 4y agoI assume they just want all the juicy data.
- yunwal 4y agoMedical data, despite seeming like a juicy target, isn't really all that valuable atm. It requires a lot of infrastructure to move it around, and you can't do all that much with it without breaking the law. HIPAA/PHI fines can rack up really quickly and are still enforced relatively strictly. Although maybe Amazon's lobbyists are working on "fixing" that. My guess is Amazon sees hospitals/practices starting to use more "cloud-y" services and wants to set themselves up to capture as much of that revenue as possible. The old hospital IT-fortress model leaves a lot of efficiency gains on the table and I'm sure AWS would love to be able to capture all of that. source: I work at a "cloud-y" medical tech company
- JohnFen 4y ago> you can't do all that much with it without breaking the law. That all depends. There are serious limits to where HIPAA applies. Not everyone who who handles medical data is bound by it, for starters.
- yunwal 4y ago> Not everyone who who handles medical data is bound by it This is true, but not true of anyone working at One Medical, since health care providers are bound by HIPAA. If you tell your friend you have cancer, sure, they can legally share that info. If you tell your faith healer, or your employer, they can as well. If you tell your PCP (or your PCPs app, or their secretary), and they share that with Andy Jassy without him being cleared to handle PHI, they're in for a mountain of fines. As much as I like being cynical about surveillance capitalism, I don't think Amazon's primary motivation here is patient data, at least in the short-to-medium term. If they wanted the data, they'd buy, like, a vitamin company or something.