3 ms·
I don't understand the (for want of a better name) anti-vaxxer logic here. If masks don't work, then future lockdowns will be stricter. If things work a little
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I don't understand the (for want of a better name) anti-vaxxer logic here.
If masks don't work, then future lockdowns will be stricter. If things work a little, but most people ignore the advice, then future lockdowns will be stricter.
They seem to be claiming some kind of moral victory, that they knew that masks weren't going to be effective, while at the same time refusing to wear them in a self fulfilling prophecy but I don't recall that ever being the core argument.
I also don't understand the lead author of the study's position. He seems really annoyed, but I'm not sure what by. What specifically did he think should have been done differently? People on twitter shouldn't have said masks work as a broad population intervention because there wasn't sufficient evidence of that? That doesn't seem worth being that angry about.
Is he doing the bioscience equivalent of people who get angry when a journalist calls some bit of military equipment a "tank" which doesn't meet their personal definition of the term.
- VagueMag 4y ago> If masks don't work, then future lockdowns will be stricter This only follows by granting certain huge assumptions which have never been well defended, first and foremost that lockdowns are effective over the long term in preventing eventual infection by respiratory viruses (the total failure of China's Zero COVID policies should have caused some reevaluations here, but alas). > He seems really annoyed, but I'm not sure what by. What specifically did he think should have been done differently? I personally know more than a few people who probably owe some apologies for calling anti-maskers "idiots," "selfish," "anti-social," and other grossly misinformed terms. Not making my young children wear useless scraps of cloth over their faces to attend preschool would have been good, too. And we should immediately end the ongoing mandates for masks in "healthcare settings" like doctors'/dentists' offices, hospitals, and the like.