6 ms·

It's somewhat troubling to me due to the `real name' requirement of Google+. Seems I can't create a semi-anonymous email at gmail anymore?

by dexen 15y ago

vladd 15y ago
There are implications for business accounts too: if you need a real name you'll no longer be able to sign up in Adwords with something like admin@<company-domain> (and changing the company's Adwords to another person becomes a headache).
- yanw 15y ago
  For Google Apps G+ is an opt-in service.
joshuahedlund 15y ago
I can see why Google would want to clamp down on semi-anonymous gmail accounts. I'm sure many of us have used them for convenient purposes with no ill intent, myself included, but we all know that they are often used for spamming. Overall I'm OK with this as long as they don't remove the lesser-known feature of creating infinite aliases with a plus sign (myemail@gmail.com -> mymail+whatever@gmail.com). It doesn't work everywhere, and it doesn't solve all of the needs for using semi-anonymous emails, but it often solves a lot of them. Still, I won't be surprised if demand starts rising for other free anonymous mail services. Google's UI presents a nice barrier to entry, though (of course, others exist but none are as popular right now).
- nolok 15y ago
  Use punctuation, it works pretty much everywhere mymail@gmail.com my.mail@gmail.com m.y.m.a.i.l@gmail.com These all redirect to the same mailbox on gmail
  - balac 15y ago
    True, but its a lot harder to remember once you have a few variations.
  - icebraining 15y ago
    Or get your own domain and enable catch-all. Then you can use whatever you want.
eternalban 15y ago
"What do you have to hide?" http://www.zerohedge.com/about http://www.zerohedge.com/about
yanw 15y ago
There is no more a "real name" requirement for G+.
- nknight 15y ago
  Please cite some evidence for this. I can't find any. The policies are still in place, and the last statement I can find from Google dates to October and says they'd be supporting pseudonyms in some vague form in a "future update".
limeblack 15y ago
> Seems I can't create a semi-anonymous email at gmail anymore? Correct me if I misunderstood, but I believe you can just use the old gmail sign up url http://mail.google.com/mail/signup http://mail.google.com/mail/signup As mentioned in the article, you can also still use the old google account sign up to url https://accounts.google.com/NewAccount https://accounts.google.com/NewAccount .
tonfa 15y ago
> Seems I can't create a semi-anonymous email at gmail anymore? Since using a non "real name" only disables the G+ part of the Google account, you are still able to create a semi anonymous gmail.
- Kadrith 15y ago
  That could be one way for anyone concerned with the integration to get around this. Create a fake name, Google will disable the G+ profile and you can still use Gmail.
nitrogen 15y ago
I wanted to raise a similar concern for YouTube accounts. If you have to provide your Real Name to post to YouTube, a lot of people will self-censor, and some important or valuable videos may never get posted.

It's somewhat troubling to me due to the `real name' requirement of Google+. Seems I can't create a semi-anonymous email at gmail anymore?

by dexen 15y ago

It's somewhat troubling to me due to the `real name' requirement of Google+. Seems I can't create a semi-anonymous email at gmail anymore?

vladd 15y ago

There are implications for business accounts too: if you need a real name you'll no longer be able to sign up in Adwords with something like admin@<company-domain> (and changing the company's Adwords to another person becomes a headache).

yanw 15y ago
For Google Apps G+ is an opt-in service.

joshuahedlund 15y ago

I can see why Google would want to clamp down on semi-anonymous gmail accounts. I'm sure many of us have used them for convenient purposes with no ill intent, myself included, but we all know that they are often used for spamming. Overall I'm OK with this as long as they don't remove the lesser-known feature of creating infinite aliases with a plus sign (myemail@gmail.com -> mymail+whatever@gmail.com). It doesn't work everywhere, and it doesn't solve all of the needs for using semi-anonymous emails, but it often solves a lot of them. Still, I won't be surprised if demand starts rising for other free anonymous mail services. Google's UI presents a nice barrier to entry, though (of course, others exist but none are as popular right now).

nolok 15y ago
Use punctuation, it works pretty much everywhere mymail@gmail.com my.mail@gmail.com m.y.m.a.i.l@gmail.com These all redirect to the same mailbox on gmail
- balac 15y ago
  True, but its a lot harder to remember once you have a few variations.
- icebraining 15y ago
  Or get your own domain and enable catch-all. Then you can use whatever you want.

eternalban 15y ago

"What do you have to hide?" http://www.zerohedge.com/about http://www.zerohedge.com/about

yanw 15y ago

There is no more a "real name" requirement for G+.

nknight 15y ago
Please cite some evidence for this. I can't find any. The policies are still in place, and the last statement I can find from Google dates to October and says they'd be supporting pseudonyms in some vague form in a "future update".

limeblack 15y ago

> Seems I can't create a semi-anonymous email at gmail anymore? Correct me if I misunderstood, but I believe you can just use the old gmail sign up url http://mail.google.com/mail/signup http://mail.google.com/mail/signup As mentioned in the article, you can also still use the old google account sign up to url https://accounts.google.com/NewAccount https://accounts.google.com/NewAccount .

tonfa 15y ago

> Seems I can't create a semi-anonymous email at gmail anymore? Since using a non "real name" only disables the G+ part of the Google account, you are still able to create a semi anonymous gmail.

Kadrith 15y ago
That could be one way for anyone concerned with the integration to get around this. Create a fake name, Google will disable the G+ profile and you can still use Gmail.

nitrogen 15y ago

I wanted to raise a similar concern for YouTube accounts. If you have to provide your Real Name to post to YouTube, a lot of people will self-censor, and some important or valuable videos may never get posted.