8 ms·
Microsoft keeps it old-school with a pricey text adventure game
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- soofaloofa 15y agoIt's not meant to be taken seriously.
- nluqo 15y agoWhen did ars technica become The Onion?
- Yhippa 15y agoLOLcats have replaced good old-fashioned parody. I eat this stuff up!
- Zirro 15y agoDownvote me if you feel like it, but I'm honest when I say I enjoyed this article, and the way it was written. Sometimes, it just doesn't have to be fully serious to make a point.
- gbog 15y agoBeing honest is not enough, you should try to add something interesting to the discussion. (It is hard: I, also, sinned)
- arethuza 15y agoIt's no laughing matter, Microsoft takes humour very seriously: http://www.microsoft.com/education/en-us/Training/Competencies/Pages/humor.aspx http://www.microsoft.com/education/en-us/Training/Competenci...
- raganwald 15y agoDownvote me if you feel like it, but... Whatever you want to say, please just say it: http://raganwald.posterous.com/youre-probably-going-to-downvote-this-but http://raganwald.posterous.com/youre-probably-going-to-downv...
- Zirro 15y agoFair point. I didn't see it that way, but yes, I promise never to use it again. (Heh, promises over the Internet, you rarely see those. I intend to keep mine, though.)
- phzbOx 15y agoThat's wrong. Sometime, you know you have a valid point and will get down voted because people won't spend the time to understand correctly your meaning. By saying it before hand, people will understand that you know it's a bit of a controversial subject but still spent the time to make your point.. and thus, won't just down-vote you because they thought you were wrong at first glance.
- tikhonj 15y agoHeh, I know how true that is, but I think it's healthier to look at it in a different way: if I have a valid point but people don't understand it, it's my fault--I did not write clearly enough. I take it as a signal that I need to sit down with that idea and work out exactly what I mean as opposed to what I say. Of course, there are always exceptions: missed allusions, overlooked subtleties and well-reasoned but unconventional points can be downvoted incorrectly. However, most of the time, it's healthier to think of it as your fault.
- jerf 15y agoStraight-up humor isn't actually banned by HN community standards, it's just the bar is quite high. It should be something that took some effort, not a one-line meme reference or something equally trivial or obvious.
- mcantor 15y agoI know I'm going to get downvoted for this, but, I wasn't going to upvote you, and then I saw you wrote 'downvote me if you feel like it' so I knee-jerk upvoted you to counteract someone else's knee-jerk downvote without reading the rest of your comment. I'd read it now, but a vegetarian friend of mine just texted me about the salad he's eating, so I have to go get a burger to make up for it.
- Hominem 15y agoThe reaction to VS achievements is kind of interesting, people seem to be taking it seriously, at least as some sort of symbol. Who knows, maybe it is the thin edge of the knife that will lead to the "gamification" of programming. At any rate,anyone who uses VS and C# with any frequency probably understands it to be tongue in cheek. I don't think I will change my coding practices to get achievements... Well maybe I will, I've just got to get those last two!
- brudgers 15y agoYour comment made me see a parallel between VS achievements and sites like StackOverflow which offer a system of rewards which incentivize increasing one's programming knowledge.
- Hominem 15y agoExpecially since potential employers look for StackOverflow accounts now.
- rquantz 15y agoIsn't software development already kind of gamified? It's full of little bursts of dopamines and adrenaline -- from that first little "Hello World" to finally tracking down a bug, to seeing your code in production. Its addictive and it already comes with distinct achievements.
- Hominem 15y agoI think in a sense it is. Not strictly quantified yet. I was thinking about the adulation or sense of defeat you can get from code reviews. Code is a spectator sport with arbitrary rules that keep changing. Just like Calvinball!
- dpritchett 15y agoHence the ascendance of dynamic languages! The compressed feedback loops keep you munching those power pellets: Action RPGs (Ruby, PHP, Javascript, Python, anything with a REPL) vs. PBEM chess (C, Java, C++, your favorite statically typed & compiled language). Different genres with widely divergent playstyles and reward structures.
- jgw 15y agoAs someone who thinks "Photopia" is one of the greatest pieces of fiction I've ever read, I got a kick out of this article. Nicely done.
- lazugod 15y agoCan I ask, why Photopia?
- jgw 15y agoThe story really deeply affected me, and I think it was an amazingly effective use of the medium. I can't really think of any other way that it could have been presented in any medium that would have established our concern for Alison (by "being" her parents, the kid with a crush on her, Wendy). It's agonizing to realize what's going to happen, and to be powerless to do anything about it. The final act of turning off the light is so, so sad.
- bad_user 15y agoI sometimes love Microsoft. This is one of those cases. Software development tools, especially those meant for the enterprise, are sometimes too serious, boring and soul-sucking. Turning it into an RPG game is genius if you do it right: not only do you have some innocent fun, but it might make you learn some good practices in the process.
- whamill 15y agoI hope you're not referring to the Visual Studio achievements. Rewarding people for single-letter class names, having 10 levels of inheritance or using GOTOs is neither innocent fun nor something that's going to teach good practices...
- phren0logy 15y agoIt's a pleasure to see such straight-faced parody. Bravo to Ars, although I was kind of sad to see them include the disclaimer at the end for those who don't get the joke. As someone who prefers to develop on Mac and Linux, I'm still a bit jealous of F# and the IDE integration it enjoys. And yes, I know about MonoDevelop.
- DrPizza 15y agoRe: the last paragraph: Sadly I lost that battle. I didn't want to include it, but sometimes we writers do not get to make those decisions.
- troymc 15y agoAfter reading the piece, I think a good case could be made that Visual Studio 2010 is, in fact, a game. I'm already imagining two lawyers presenting their cases to a jury. (If you think such things never happen, consider the case of Nix v. Hedden, which concerned the question, "Is the tomato a fruit or a vegetable?" That case went all the way to the US Supreme Court! Botanists argued that they're fruit because they're the part of the plant that contains the seeds. Reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nix_v._Hedden http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nix_v._Hedden )
- madewulf 15y agoIn fact, you could even more broadly make the case that programming is the ultimate video game...
- whatusername 15y agoOr the Radiolab short recently about how Marvel Comics went to the Supreme Court to prove that X-Men are not human.
- whatusername 15y agoOr the Radiolab short recently about how Marvel Comics went to the Supreme Court to prove that X-Men are not human. http://www.radiolab.org/blogs/radiolab-blog/2011/dec/22/mutant-rights/ http://www.radiolab.org/blogs/radiolab-blog/2011/dec/22/muta...
- JadeNB 15y agoI wonder if whatever censor approved the final headline didn't notice the URL, or just thought it wouldn't offend anyone?
- freehunter 15y agoI can't imagine an Ars reader being offended by the word "pimp", considering they occasionally use quite strong profanity in the meat of their posts.
- charlieok 15y agoEven if they redirect to a new url, there are still links everywhere using the original url which they probably wouldn't want to break.
- mjwalshe 15y agoDo you get a bonus achievement for unwinding your loops gwbasic style to avoid the memory leak.
- kermitthehermit 15y agoThey should add this for the base OS. Seriously, they should make it possible for people to debug their OSes and provide them with rewards and financial rewards as well. At least this way some old bugs would actually go away.
- itsameta4 15y agoThis is actually completely brilliant. Sure, it's hollow and somewhat manipulative, but by the nine, it will teach some people what their computer can actually do. As someone who works in tech support, and therefore routinely has to waste my time doing utterly basic things for people, I would absolutely love if Microsoft/Apple/Ubuntu/some beginner-friendly OS did something like that.
- angelbob 15y agoProbably not, alas. Obviously we need user-supplied achievements in plugin packs :-)
- hiccup 15y agoPretty sure a Social Gaming plugin is part of TextMate 2 also.
- jmilloy 15y agoOf course, one reason this works so well is that programming really can be like a game. Growing up, I didn't play console/pc games, I wrote code!
- a9 15y agoText-based. That's why they call it "Visual". Perhaps it would be nicer to have a text-free touchscreen with big buttons?
- nsxwolf 15y agoI found this article to be so abstract it could apply to any IDE. XCode, Eclipse, whatever. It didn't specifically address any of VS 2010's actual shortcomings.
- waldes 15y agoHaha. I am embarrassed how long it took me to catch on.
- spdegabrielle 15y agoHumor aside, is MS trying to shoot themselves in the foot. Why drive potential devs away with a crippled free version, and outrageously expensive full version.