3 ms·
> deflation, and that's really bad for an economy That fits in with the government wanting to downplay inflation. That alone should make you suspicious of such
by WalterBright 4y ago
> deflation, and that's really bad for an economy
That fits in with the government wanting to downplay inflation. That alone should make you suspicious of such theories.
> it encourages people to not-spend, as it'll be cheaper tomorrow. And our word "economy" can loosely be translated as "amount of spending".)
Economies are not driven by spending. They are driven by the creation of value. Being driven by creating money and spending it implies one is getting something for nothing, which is a giant red flag for a mistake in reasoning.
- piva00 4y agoThe creation of value is derived from consumption of that value, no? If something is created and has value then someone will be a consumer of such, increasing spending. If something of value is created and no one consumes that it's an oxymoron. Creation of value only exists through spending. If money is more valuable later I will hold onto my money for longer instead of spending, velocity of money goes down, less money being traded hands mean more people are less willing to part with their money to invest in some value-creation as that's riskier than holding onto cash that will be more valuable in the future. Rinse and repeat.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Creation of value only exists through spending. Nope. If I grow carrots, I create value. No spending required.
- piva00 4y agoSure, you created value, for whom? In the case there's no spending: if it's for you and immediate neighbours there's a limit to that value, you can just feed so many carrots to people, over that threshold you are just creating waste, not value. You can donate them but that requires transportation and incurs costs, someone has to take those costs, which will cause spending. So it's tied to spending, if you can't sell carrots then what value do you have for the rotting ones you can't eat? Value does not exist in a vacuum.
- WalterBright 4y agoI trade my extra carrots with the shoemaker for fixing my shoes. We both create value.
- bruce511 4y agoThat is fundamentally spending. He is spending his time to get your value. In practice we can basically ignore this from "economy" calculations though. While it happens, it's such a tiny part of the economy as to be irrelevant. Equally growing carrots in itself requires spending. Certainly your time, but also input costs with fuel, fertiliser, water and so on. Of course it is possible to live "off grid" and be totally, or mostly, self sufficient. Effectively to live "outside the economy". Again, while this happens, it's vanishingly rare (and those folks don't care about inflation)
- WalterBright 4y ago> He is spending his time Now you're shifting meanings of "spending".