4 ms·
Spam is cancer. Spam has always been cancer. It pretty much destroyed Usenet (I know, it still exists, but spam broke the trust network it relied upon), and it
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Spam is cancer.
Spam has always been cancer. It pretty much destroyed Usenet (I know, it still exists, but spam broke the trust network it relied upon), and it wrecks everything it touches.
Fundamentally the problem is that spammers see nothing wrong with lying and information pollution as long as they make some money out of it. To some this is merely a cultural more about trying your luck, being persistent, taking advantage of obvious opportunities etc, to others it's a grave moral affront. It's partly due to phenomena like this that we've seen the move to ward a 'zero trust society' with endless security arms races.
It's hard to even adequately describe the problem. Large tech firms say they're doing a lot of fight spam on their platforms but basically just put out reports that make themselves look good, rather than being audited to any objective standard. The last economic study I've seen on the market for spam was a decade ago. I don't think we have good data on what % of internet content/traffic is real vs garbage.
To my mind, a big part of the problem is that we just try to filter it away and pretend it doesn't exist, while we constantly get more of it. Perhaps we should track it better, and more aggressively target the sources. Even just looking at the HN submission page, I'm struck by how every day around the same time new accounts show up to promote keto or CBD gummies - I presume that's because it's midnight or morning in a timezone and either a script or some slave laborer is tasked with putting out that day's wave of spam across tens of thousands of submission forms. Thanks to VPNs etc we have no idea where, and even though there's more hacking/security talent clustered here than most of the internet, as a community nobody can do anything about it. Most of these submissions are auto-deleted, making it hard to even identify their origin point in order to counter-target it.
Information pollution is a real and increasingly critical problem, and I think the passive acceptance of spam and unwillingness to engage with it in favor of mediocre technical workarounds is doing real damage to internet society.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoI agree, but I don't think it's just as simple as us becoming "willing to engage with it". It's a hard problem, and a solution may be literally impossible. I remember reading Cory Doctorow saying why DRM could never succeed. For an attacker to decrypt your content, they need the encrypted content, the decryption device, and the key. For a legitimate user to see your content, they also need the encrypted content, the decryption device, and the key. If it turns out that one of your users is also an attacker (it only takes one), then it's game over. In the same way, the internet as we know it takes the ability for any source IP address to be able to send packets to any destination IP address, plus protocols for mail, web, and so on. This lets anyone create content for anyone. But if one of the "anyones" turns out to be a spammer, it's not quite game over, but the information pollution begins and poisons everything. But the point is, I don't think you can fix it while also keeping what made the internet wonderful.
- lmm 4y agoWhat made the early internet wonderful was that it was a high trust community, at least on certain axes. Part of that was barriers to entry, part of it was social norms. Maybe it's time to undo the Eternal September and start pruning those who break the norms of the internet.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI think we could have more accountability. Things like domain anonymity badly diminish accountability, for example. I still think anonymity for internet users is important, but volume delivery + anonymity are a bad combination.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoHmm. So the more volume, the less anonymity you get? If you push out a little bit of traffic, then you can be anonymous, but after a certain amount then the upstream carriers start demanding more specifics as to who you are? I like it... But you'd also have to do something about address spoofing. And laundering content through a known entity (though if it were spam, that known entity would then suffer the consequences of the laundering, so maybe that one solves itself).
- anigbrowl 4y agoYeah, something like that. Also that if you serially abuse a service, you lose your privacy protections, for example your IP gets exposed/ I'm also a big fan of community-driven responses, but these require platform owners to give up some control in favor of being more custodians than barons. Since many of them are selling every bit of data on their users that's not likely to happen under current arrangements. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.03697.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.03697.pdf
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lordfrito 4y agoI'm increasingly of the opinion that anonymity is the root cause of the problem. In the real world we have reputations that follow us. Bad actors are identified, their reputations proceed them. It seems to me the problem is that there is no reputation that follows you in the online world. Barrier to entry is low, consequences for bad behavior are low. When a bad actor is caught, they simply create a new account and start over again. I don't see any way to solve this problem online without non-anonymous "hard to get" accounts that are traceable to real people, and whose digital reputation follows you. Digital bad actors can be quickly identified, and ignored. I think we can support a mixed anonymous / non-anonymous internet. Dealing with anonymous users would be no different than dealing with a person in a back alley -- caveat emptor. Most of us would choose only to do business with "non anonymous" accounts. In a short amount of time commercial internet use would quickly move over to the non-anonymous side of the internet.
- oehpr 4y agoHere is my opinion regarding how to fight this. Spam is exploiting a broken trust model. If I make a brand new account on hacker news, tell me why you should trust it? Because I'll tell you right now how much you DO trust it, it's completely. You will see what is written. Why are you even seeing this post right now?! Do you know me? Do you know that I make good submissions? Am I waste of your time? I'm some random jerk with a random name. We pile all our content onto a single point, and we aggregate our opinions on a single point, and let all comers join that single point with all the privileges therein. First principles this is vulnerable to a Sybil attack. We should actually recognize what trust IS. It is something PERSONAL. NOT CENTRALIZED!!. We need to wake up to the fact that the moment you try to pile trust into a central point, the system will break. Trust. must. be. distributed.