5 ms·
Sci-fi was that AI would be able to write great stories. Reality is that people flood submissions low-effort boring crap. You probably can use AI tools/ChatGP
by arp242 4y ago
Sci-fi was that AI would be able to write great stories.
Reality is that people flood submissions low-effort boring crap.
You probably can use AI tools/ChatGPT to write interesting stories, or use its output as a starting point (I'm not sure if it would be less effort than just writing a story from scratch though). But that's of course not what's happening.
First rule of designing anything is what I would call Tucker's Second Law[1]: "if some cunt can make a buck by completely fucking over your system then that cunt will completely fuck over your system because that cunt is a cunt."
This is a huge problem with a lot of different things, ranging from email spam to how the "make a quick buck" type of hucksters have taken over cryptocurrencies to how nations design things like their tax and benefits systems.
[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mss7ZNIEhfo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mss7ZNIEhfo
- humanrebar 4y agoSounds like you need to (re)read Snow Crash and (re)watch Idiocracy.
- arp242 4y agoWell, not all sci-fi obviously. In many ways even the more depressive/dystopian sci-fi "got it wrong", as in the stories the reasons AI (and technology in general) is abused is often by some big powerful entity or entities (government, corporations, mob bosses, etc.) as part of its design. In reality it's abused by "the little people" who don't have any power or aspirations for it, and they do so for reasons that are banal and boring: to make a quick buck.
- gfody 4y agoso far things are playing out exactly according to Fall; or, Dodge in Hell
- lagniappe 4y agoThere's a little Egdod in all of us ;)
- somenameforme 4y agoI think it's a given that governments, PR/brand management firms, and other large actors are racing to weaponize chat generators. The only reason they're likely not already being deployed at scale is because the current stuff isn't really fit for purpose. Being able to say some "appropriate" things most of the time doesn't matter when you spaz out against unsophisticated adversarial actors, even to the point of spitting out your own classified training prompts. They need to be able to vary their writing style, vernacular, content, subtly (and consistently) reflect an imaginary backstory, following invisible/unspoken standards, and more. All on top of not spazzing out. So we're still somewhat safe from our robot overlords, but they're probably coming soon. And it's only then that we'll get to measure their impact.
- version_five 4y agoWhat's the connection to Snow Crash?
- a_bonobo 4y agoI stumbled over this quote in a different context but I feel like it applies everywhere: the optimal amount of fraud is not zero [1]. Now that Pandora's box is open, we will always have some AI-generated content. If we try to stamp it out we will exclude real voices, just like stamping out welfare-fraud makes it harder for 'legitimate' welfare recipients, of which there are way more than fraudsters. We need to be careful not to cut the nose off to spite the face. [1] https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/optimal-amount-of-fraud/ https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/optimal-amount-of-fra...
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoThe problem isn't that AI fraud is hard to deal with when they're found. The problem is that there's so much of it that the AI fraud itself is acting to exclude real voices by drowning them.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoHmm. Restricting AI would restrict real voices. But unfettered AI also restricts real voices. There is no path that does not restrict real voices. The best we can do (analogous to the welfare fraud case) is maximize the real voices, which in practice is probably going to mean a brutal crackdown on AI content. (It's easier to do AI fraud in volume than it is to do welfare fraud in volume.) Some real, human voices, with valuable things to say, are going to get blocked, and that's bad. But more would be unheard without the crackdown, so we kind of have to do it.
- wussboy 4y agoThe solution is as obvious as it is effective: take our voices off of the internet. Only face to face can possibly matter or be trusted. Yes, it will slow down the pace at which we hurl ourselves into technological nihilism. But that’s a good thing.
- a_bonobo 4y agoIsn't that the solution they came up with in Dune? The Butlerian Jihad?
- LanceH 4y agoWe need an AI to read the low effort crap to find the gem. That's what someone needs to work on -- then they could sign all these "authors" and clean up.
- robbiep 4y agoIf AI could do that, it wouldn’t be AI - it would be capital I.
- dsq 4y agoNew job category for humans: Detecting and flagging AI-generated content.
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoThen we can use those results for training an AI-generated-content-flagging AI, and ouch my head I think I need to go lie down for a while now.
- batch12 4y agoSomeone will need to create a certification body for organic content. Similar to organic produce, content will be certified human.