3 ms·
> As a result, Apple's ecosystem is shaping social decision-making, with particular emphasis on the importance of iMessage as a social signal, necessitated by i
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> As a result, Apple's ecosystem is shaping social decision-making, with particular emphasis on the importance of iMessage as a social signal, necessitated by inferior experiences messaging and using group chats via SMS.
This really hits the nail on the head and is the absolute key factor in the US. And it's not because of the "blue/green" bubble that the media often likes to play up. It's because if you're in a group chat, everything works great for everyone if all the participants are on iOS in iMessage. The minute you get an Android user (and I'm speaking as the Android user in this situation), it sucks for everyone, NOT just the Android user: photos and videos get degraded, messages randomly get dropped, emoji reactions don't work as well, etc. I'm well into middle age and have been told by friends "Just get an iPhone" when I join group chats on vacation.
iMessage really is the moat that is impossible to breach without government regulation. Folks in other countries don't notice it as much because they tend to use other platforms like WhatsApp or something else for group chats.
- colpabar 4y agocolpabar liked a message.
- asdff 4y agoHonestly complaining about groupchats is such a nitpick. I'd rather get this message in the chat log like that, versus what happens on the iphone where your phone buzzes all day from people liking some message way up in the chatlog, that you'd have no sense of that activity until you scrolled back and counted up the hearts.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoLol, took me a minute, bravo!
- drewbeck 4y agoI hate this part of cross platform messaging sooo much. Apple has “improved” it somewhat by making it so iOS users now don’t see the “[x] had liked a message” text, but of course this doesn’t happen on the android side, making iOS users equally annoying participants in the chat without visibility into how annoying it is!! They’ve made iOS users worse citizens. And I say this as an iOS user! I want it to be very clear when reacting to a text is going to pollute the chat. Grr.
- gunshai 4y ago>WhatsApp or something else for group chats. People can say what they want about facebook. WhatsApp as a messenger is just 10000% better than the stock SMS apps on iphone and android. The number of annoying conversations I've had about converting people to using it make 0 sense. Group SMS as a problem is just SOLVED by using whatsapp. There are some minor sticking points when traveling and having multiple sims with multiple numbers, but those problems are even worse when using stock SMS anyway. Whatsapp even has POLLS ... POLLS PEOPLE what an incredible feature for group messaging. Edit: I am not oblivious to network effects. I am bemoaning the consequences of them really. Just like I f*cking hate venmo as a user experience, yet I have to use this POS app because everyone else does. I've given up on that fight though.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoIt's the definition of network effects and the power of defaults. I've had this same discussion before a few times, and when you're the lone one out of a large group, people just roll their eyes. And I don't really blame them, as iMessage does work great for the most part, so switching is primarily added hassle. If it's this painful as an old guy, I can't imagine what it's like for teenagers.
- crazygringo 4y ago> The number of annoying conversations I've had about converting people to using it make 0 sense. It's network effects. It's not about convincing one person, it's that they need to convince all their friends. Who need to convince all their friends. Who need to convince the entire country. Because what's even more annoying than missing the features from WhatsApp, is having to remember which app to use with which person and with which groups of people. Hopefully that makes more than 0 sense. :)
- crossroadsguy 4y ago> to remember which app to use with which person and with which groups of people It should be a cross platform app. Simple :)
- trinix912 4y ago> Folks in other countries don't notice it as much because they tend to use other platforms like WhatsApp or something else for group chats. It's the same in many European countries - I'd assume it also is in every other country where people can afford iPhones. Few people nowadays want to use 3+ different apps for messaging when iMessage "just works".