7 ms·
‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: TikTok Is a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation
- yieldcrv 4y ago> What troubles those who track child exploitation is that TikTok’s algorithm is designed to learn what type of content users like, then feed them a string of it. That keeps youngsters glued to the site and makes it easier for pedophiles to seek them out. It keeps adults glued to the site too. Predators and people that didn't plan to be alike.
- scottshea 4y agoFollowing on to your comment, is this, "TikTok’s algorithm is designed to learn what type of content users like", what almost all social media does to a certain extent?
- yieldcrv 4y agoat this point yes, TikTok's has been better at it and others have been playing catch up trying to replicate it and its interface. For example, Instagram's Reels are like TikTok's, except Instagram's users are split doing a dozen other things, while TikTok's users are only doing the "reels" like feature and associate TikTok with that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jgilias 4y agohttps://archive.is/s3047 https://archive.is/s3047
- superkuh 4y agoParent's non-rational responses to ideas of threats to their children is definitely the #1 go-to for any sort of attack on information services.
- ulizzle 4y agoLol. Non-rational? Obviously not, if only from the first paragraphs of this article.
- eloisius 4y agoNon-rational because the most likely person to sexually abuse a child is a neighbor, creepy uncle, someone at church, etc. not boogie men from the dark web stalking TikTok, yet parents will still be more afraid Of the TikTok angle when reading an article like this.
- ulizzle 4y agoThe most likely person to molest a minor is an internet friend. This has been proven to be true over and over again, so much so, that “to catch a predator” was a mainstream hit show.
- moate 4y agohttps://www.rainn.org/statistics/perpetrators-sexual-violence https://www.rainn.org/statistics/perpetrators-sexual-violenc... I think it's time for a good think and a lie down.
- ulizzle 4y ago“33% Are committed by an acquaintance” which is more likely to be an internet friend, especially nowadays It is a false narrative to pretend that automagically means “oh it was the creepy” uncle
- eloisius 4y agoC’mon, do you really think the researchers here would say “well, he did send her a few DMs over TikTok before he got predatory so that makes him an acquaintance, not a stranger”? No, the entire exchange from the first time he saw one of her videos and followed her would be part of the predation, ergo a stranger predator.
- anigbrowl 4y agoWoah - just like Fortnite, Omegle, Roblox, Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr, Snapchat, AIM, IRC, Compuserve and BBS's? Who could have seen that coming
- jvm___ 4y agoDisco, Arcades, rock and roll, sockhops, radio...
- moate 4y agoI mean, if we're being honest about where most sexual assaults/molestations happen: A school, a church, a trusted adult's home, a relative's summer cabin. Everyone wants to talk about creeps in vans, it's the creep you know that's going to diddle your kid, statistically speaking, about 9 out of 10 times. IDK that TikTok is making the problem worse, parents just have a lot of nightmares about how badly everyone wants to fuck their babies.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoThe things I saw connected to a BBS using a 286 computer with a 2400 baud modem on monochrome orange monitor.. It changed me...
- njovin 4y agoThese things are not all equal. Of those, Fortnite and Roblox specifically target children. IMO as a parent, Fortnite is relatively safe. There's only so much interaction you have during a game and it's easy for kids to avoid problematic players. Roblox is a nightmare. I've seen community-created sex games that start off as "dating" and progress toward simulated sex complete with ridiculous-looking naked models. There are absolutely no age controls and the content moderation seems nonexistent. Something as simple as the ability to flag a game/server as NSFW and then age-gate it would be a huge improvement. The lack of such makes it clear that the company has no intention of protecting minors. Obviously education is the best defense for any of these, but some are clearly and knowingly profiting from the sexual exploitation of minors.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DaveExeter 4y agoI wonder who paid for this story.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoFacebook/Meta has been very aggressive in trying to get the US to ban Tiktok from Trump's time in office (also was the subject of secret dinners b/w Zuck and Trump). Although the story itself is pretty reasonable... the problem here seems to be that these services are public by default for minors.
- pflenker 4y agoThat was already a major problem when the platform was still called musical.ly and not even remotely as big as it is right now. So this is a problem which is relevant enough to report upon without the need of someone paying for it.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoEvery interaction is a potential venue for exploitation. It's not the platform, it's teaching children right, wrong, and the skills to protect themselves. Not defending TikTok, but I think focusing on a platform, or medium, is the wrong way to go...
- option 4y agoAllegedly, TikTok’s recommendations to kids in China (who owns and controls TikTok) are very different to the recommendations kids in the West get. Something Western governments must look into ASAP.
- jvm___ 4y agoTiktok China is supposed to be educational and informative. Tiktok America is entertainment only. The theory is that China is poisoning the minds of young Americans by not developing interests in educational things.
- belltaco 4y agoOr it's a commercial company looking to make money by whatever legal means possible in the country it operates in. China does not respect freedom for their citizens and even has laws against kids gaming for long hours. > The theory is that China is poisoning the minds of young Americans by not developing interests in educational things It makes as much sense as saying that the US is trying to make Chinese people fat by serving high calorie empty nutrient foods in McDonalds and Starbucks stores in China.
- pancrufty 4y agoYes super educational and informative like all those mukbang videos and unique content created by those famous live-streaming factories. [1] Chinese users are interested in junk just as much as westerners, if not more, so they will be fed exactly what keeps them glued to their phones. I don’t believe for a second that every Chinese kid is on Douyin watching science videos for hours. [1]: https://www.vice.com/en/article/pgzamm/chinas-live-streaming-factory https://www.vice.com/en/article/pgzamm/chinas-live-streaming...
- newswasboring 4y agoI'm in Europe so I'm not sure which TikTok I access, but my TikTok is fairly educational. A running joke in my friends group is 'ways to get thirst traps on <my name>'s fyp'. I see this kind of comment all the time, but would like to see any source on it. Otherwise it's just a random conspiracy theory.
- EGreg 4y agoIt used to be that Gangsta Rap and Drill music was the worst influence on black kids. Then came Instagram with its influence on young girls. And now this. Incredible how the capitalist industries really don't care about externalities, and will do anything to make a buck. And government works hand in hand with them, whether it's the US government or the Chinese government. In this case given the disparity of what is shown on TikTok in China and here, I think it's on purpose to weaken the West. Whether it's factory farms leading to superbugs, high fructose corn syrup causing diabetes, overfishing, insects dying, fossil fuels, water waste, plastic pollution everywhere, the corporations get away with putting metric tons of this out ...but they will keep the individuals distracted and fighting each other... they'll tell you that you can't use a straw or bag, you should recycle the plastic (a scam), diet and exercise, and go vegan, to save the planet ... meanwhile no one seriously can rein in the corporations, instead they work with them. Both Greta Thurnberg and George Carlin were right: https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=362 https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=362
- kerpotgh 4y ago[dead]
- robertlagrant 4y ago> In this case given the disparity of what is shown on TikTok in China and here, I think it's on purpose to weaken the West. This undermines your theory that it's all capitalism.
- EGreg 4y agoIt's capitalism + government working together. The assumption of many anarcho-capitalists is that government is the antithesis of capitalism, that it's somehow encroaching on a pure version of it ('laissez-faire capitalism'). But I'm saying the opposite, if you click the link. Government ENABLES capitalism. Government protects property rights, and passes laws, and enforces them with force. It is the one that enforces victimless intellectual property violations with force. It is the one that chooses to evict a tenant, or have an eviction moratorium. It is the one who chooses to bail out the markets and the big corporations. It's the one who prevents regular people from filming the horrors on factory farms. It is the one which gives Big Ag or farmers water, but regular people have very little. It is the one which lets corporations put high fructose corn syrup into everything. And it is the one which does nothing while Coca Cola and Snapple switch to putting out metric tons of non-bioldegradeable plastic. But the individuals are told they can somehow recycle and vegan their way out of it. It's all a scam, they shipped it to China. They don't want you to wake up and hold the corporations to account, so they'll tell you that the real problem is plastic straws and bags. For every socialist government failure (like Holodomor or Great Chinese Famine) there is a capitalist government failure (Irish Potato Famine or Bengal Famines).
- belltaco 4y ago> What troubles those who track child exploitation is that TikTok’s algorithm is designed to learn what type of content users like, then feed them a string of it. That keeps youngsters glued to the site and makes it easier for pedophiles to seek them out. I don't get that paragraph. It's like saying playgrounds are designed to attract kids, making it easier for pedophiles to know where kids are and seek them out. Or ice cream vans, or toy stores, or malls. Or even schools. Removing fun things from playgrounds will result in fewer incidents, but is that what we want.
- arka2147483647 4y agoA playground is easily observable by a parent. Mobile apps usually arent.
- jxf 4y agoChildren go with their parents to those locations and/or have trusted adult supervision. TikTok has and encourages neither.
- Sakos 4y agoI used TikTok extensively for a month. I thought it was disturbing how often it would show me videos from people who'd turn out to be under-age girls and I'd only find out by checking the comments. I definitely see how TikTok facilitates the risk of sexual exploitation of minors. Trying to treat TikTok's algorithm as anything like a playground is just ridiculous.
- luckylion 4y agoI'm not sure I understand, you mean someone would randomly stumble upon minors and then accidentally exploit them sexually? Or that TikTok makes it easy to find them because it'll just present minors to you after you've swiped right on some meme dance once? I'd imagine that predators don't really need a recommendation engine to stumble upon them since they're actively looking for them. Are you suggesting they're becoming predators by accident because Tiktok showed them videos of minors?
- pjc50 4y agoDoesn't seem to be anything specific to TikTok in this; any service which allows strangers to find each other and chat will have a grooming problem. It may be more or less successful at mitigating that depending on how much surveillance and moderation effort it puts in. This problem dates back to AIM and beyond.
- rjsw 4y agoThe strangers might meet up in person as well. We should ban shoes.
- lordfrito 4y agoMany were increasingly of the opinion that they'd all made a big mistake in coming down from the trees in the first place. And some said that even the trees had been a bad move, and that no one should ever have left the oceans.
- jxf 4y agoThe scale, reach, and attraction of TikTok place it on a different level, though.
- itake 4y agoHow so? Facebook has almost 3x more users.
- shalmanese 4y agoThere are 8 remaining children who still use Facebook and Mark has a dedicated team of a dozen PMs intensively following each one trying to crack the code.
- itake 4y agoDo you have a source? I thought Instagram has a large base of young users. IG is 8.5% under 18 and 30% 18-24. https://blog.hootsuite.com/instagram-demographics/ https://blog.hootsuite.com/instagram-demographics/
- daveslash 4y agoThis is off topic of a serious conversation, so I'll take the downvotes... But at first glance, that photo of Grady Moffett Sr. looked to me like Robert Picardo, the Emergency Medical Hologram. More seriously, one of the issues with these online platforms (all, although some more than others) is that they're allowing for the mixing of adults and children in a "peer" environment in an unsupervised manner. In a traditional offline world, adults and kids don't mingle too often, let alone in a 1-on-1 manner, especially not as "peers". There's definitely some very legitimate criticism of a segment of the adults to be had, but you'll never be able to correct virtues in all individuals. I think this mixing of adults and children in a peer setting at such scale is a new thing for human society.
- tabtab 4y agoHanging out at the corner or mall also has risks. It's diminishing returns to try to rid every risk to minors, and they'll probably rebel anyhow and sneak off; it's what adolescents do. That being said, I do expect reasonable inspections by TikTok staff.
- wnevets 4y agoOk. Now do Facebook, Twitter, Reddit and Instagram.
- newswasboring 4y agoPretty sure I have read those articles. I feel like journalist are missing the forest for the trees on this one. It's all the same problem, any public forum anyone can access will eventually reach this problem. It's not even about scale anymore, scale just makes it all apparent.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoWe need clear guidance from community leaders that giving social-media-enabled-phones to kids is a “bad idea” Those not in my tech-circle know-how are unaware of all the research showing it’s a huge net negative to give a 13 year old girl these devices. I feel like our culture of not telling other people what they should probably do even when it is in their best interest is going to backfire…
- hgsgm 4y agoWhat kind of guidance? The parents who let kids use this stuff are the same parents who don't pay attention to anything else about the well-being of their kids. Most people are lazy, distracted, or stupid, in some mix.
- thepasswordis 4y agoFor instance: https://twitter.com/hatpinwoman/status/1627307254650134528?s=20 https://twitter.com/hatpinwoman/status/1627307254650134528?s... This is somebody doing a breakdown of a tik tok influencer's videos, and how it matches perfectly to rainn.org child sexual abuse patterns.
- hulitu 4y ago> ‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: TikTok Is a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation ‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: Instagram Is a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation ‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: Youtube Is a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation ‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: Facebook Is a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- babypuncher 4y ago‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: Myspace Is a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation ‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: Friendster Is a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation ‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: AOL Instant Messenger Is a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation ‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: Chat rooms are a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation ‘Every Parent’s Nightmare’: Bulletin board systems are a Venue for Child Sexual Exploitation
- w1nk 4y agoSo can we at least take a second to appreciate the orders of magnitude of growth between BBS' and tiktok? With data structures and algorithms we're very willing to accept that orders of magnitudes shifting can change our basic assumptions about things. The point isn't that these things haven't existed in some form forever, it's that they're scaling to points where these effects are becoming increasingly dangerous, proportional to the growth of these systems.
- LatteLazy 4y agoEvery thing/place is a venue for CSE if it has more than a few 1000 people.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoThe thing about nightmares is that they aren't real.