Here's what I'd do: Ask them. Say something non-confrontational like "hey I saw this on this website, it made me feel a bit hesitant. can you offer me any reas

Here's what I'd do: Ask them. Say something non-confrontational like "hey I saw this on this website, it made me feel a bit hesitant. can you offer me any reassurance?" Then hear their response, and then sleep on it for a few days, and then trust your gut. If their response was great and made you feel reassured without any second guesses, great. If you still have pause, trust your gut.