3 ms·
Not a chance. Unless you want to live in a place without facilities and a functioning economy. Inflation alone will take care of your million quite handily. Of
by jacquesm 4y ago
Not a chance. Unless you want to live in a place without facilities and a functioning economy. Inflation alone will take care of your million quite handily. Of course if you're 85 already then you'll manage but if you're in your 20's or 30's I can pretty much guarantee you that this is too little.
Also: taxes, setbacks, health, children, divorces, stuff breaking that needs to be replaced and so on. A million all at once is a lot of money, but spread out over the course of a lifetime in the developed world it isn't all that much.
- nighthawk454 4y agoIt's a common misconception that inflation drags you down with these methods. The real question is will $40k/yr work (or the inflated equivalent) cover your lifestyle. That's where major lifestyle adjustments you mentioned could matter. > ... If you have $1 million saved for retirement ... you could spend $40,000 in the first year of retirement following the 4% rule. > Beginning in year two of retirement, you adjust this amount by the rate of inflation. ... In year three, you’d take the prior year’s allowed withdrawal, and then adjust that amount for inflation. > One common misconception is that the 4% rule dictates that retirees withdraw 4% of their portfolio’s value each year during retirement. The 4% applies only in year one of retirement. After that inflation dictates the amount withdrawn. The goal is to maintain the purchasing power of the 4% withdrawn in the first year of retirement. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/retirement/four-percent-rule-retirement https://www.forbes.com/advisor/retirement/four-percent-rule-...
- jacquesm 4y agoInflation reduces the purchasing power of your remaining savings with the same degree that it reduces the purchasing power of what you've already withdrawn. In other words: you'll be withdrawing more and more over time to keep up with the compound effect of inflation on your savings. And there is no law that says inflation should be between 0 and 3%, as the last couple of years have amply demonstrated.
- bushbaba 4y agoThe idea is that if broader stock market returns 7% on average per year. Your 4% withdrawals include compounding inflationary adjustment without dipping into the capital (over many decades)
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's effectively 'timing the market' though. Because the broader stockmarket may well not realize those returns when you need them most. But sure, if you see having your funds in the stockmarket as risk free and guaranteeing you that 7% then you can base your retirement strategy on that. Savings = Cash in the bank Stocks = an asset class, so an investment, which has an ROI but also a risk (the ROI is effectively a risk premium) The bulk of the people that have this kind of money will have the majority of it in the form of home equity, not in the form of savings in the bank or stocks. Depending on where you live your first healthcare crisis can wipe out that million easily.
- nighthawk454 4y agoGP is also not quite right. The point of the 4% rule is it's the historically maximum safe withdrawal rate. You're not assuming a 7% return here. You're assuming that there's not been a time ever where 4% wasn't indefinitely sustainable. https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/05/29/how-much-do-i-need-for-retirement/ https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/05/29/how-much-do-i-nee...
- nl 4y agohttps://moneysmart.gov.au/retirement-income/retirement-planner https://moneysmart.gov.au/retirement-income/retirement-plann... suggests around $800,000 to live on an average comfortable income ($61,062) if I retire at 67 and live to 92.
- jacquesm 4y agoper person. assuming no setbacks. assuming a rate of inflation that is not in line with the present day numbers. assuming that you have all of that liquid rather than invested, where it is exposed to risk. If you manage to make it work then more power to you but I like to have a generous safety margin around these things and the remainder can go to my kids.
- jay_kyburz 4y agoYou raised the most important point, I'm not really worried about my retirement savings, but I would like buy both my kids a house before I retire. I've got another 20 years, but I need another 2 million or so. I'm working hard to make sure my next product is "the big one" :)
- jacquesm 4y agoSincerely: Best of luck with that next product. It's a tricky market at the moment, there are plenty of opportunities because of that but a lot of traditional modeling is not going to survive the next five years.
- readthenotes1 4y agoNot a chance? There are quite a few retirement simulators that you can look at to see what chance you have with the money you have. Cfiresim, firecalc, etc. I retired on less than 1 million about a decade ago and I'm doing more than fine. -- The trouble with anyone giving anyone else an amount they need to save before they can retire is that you have to ask first how little you can live on.
- jacquesm 4y agoGood for you. But: that means that you likely had your house paid off and that you retired at an 'appropriate' age. If you're still young then there is a fair chance that life will interfere with your plans.
- asdff 4y agoI think the article is considering retiring at a normal age, no? It still feels odd. My relatives certainly got by without 3 million dollars. I can't imagine their yearly expenses cracked 15k if even anywhere near that. Paid off house, no extra mouths to feed and they eat like a bird at this age, cheap boring old person car lease or they are driving something they bought 15 years ago and is only at 40k miles today, medicare and medicaid coverage, too old to travel and spend a ton. Factor in social security and you aren't really drawing on that wad too much if at all. Then consider this pile of cash you have isn't just sitting there deflating. Chances are its in some sort of structure that generates a return for you.
- jacquesm 4y agoThe paid off house is a very important milestone and one that only a fraction of society can aspire to. The rest will be paying rent until they die. And if they end up in a managed care facility they'll be fleeced for every last penny. No extra mouths to feed is also something you can't take for granted, both 'up', 'down' and 'sideways' in your family tree. Cars are technically speaking optional but not having one immediately shrinks your world considerably unless you have excellent public transport. Social security may be available, or it may not be available by the time you reach your pensionable age. If you count on it you may end up with a serious shortfall if for whatever reason there are cuts. And no returns without risks...
- asdff 4y agoThe paid off house is not as much of an anomaly where they live in the midwest compared to on the coasts, to be honest. In the area homes range from $50-120k today, and in the wider region even the palatial guilded era estates in the rich gentry suburb are going for about $125 a sq foot or so. Of course, they ended up on good circumstances to make all of this possible, but imo these circumstances they ended up with aren't all that rare especially in the area they live. The returns could backfire, sure, but there are investment strategies that are pretty safe too. I think robinhood is offering 4.15% on cash currently, for example.
- 4y ago