3 ms·
This is obviously highly specific to one economy, and expectations of what comfort means.[edit: I was wrong about that] In my economy, the figure is held to be
by ggm 4y ago
This is obviously highly specific to one economy, and expectations of what comfort means.[edit: I was wrong about that]
In my economy, the figure is held to be more like half or less than this, and thats including not necessarily spending all of the capital before you die (which is highly contentious, because the superannuation system wasn't designed to be a revenue stream forever, it was designed to be spent)
Here in australia, $70,000 p.a. is the defined "comfortable" annual spend for a couple who own their own home. Some find that a bit low. If you're still hang-gliding in your 90s then you may need more. Most of us will be playing parcheesi and arguing if the stones or the beatles were better. With a government mandated 4% drawdown, you can do the sums. Once you hit somewhere around $800k in assets (as a couple) you get discounted health services, and below that start to get income support from the state as a pension.
The actuarial conversations become quite focussed when you're within 5 years of retirement/vesting age: How long do you plan on living? Thats going to define your draw-down rate.
Bloomberg clearly plan on us all living forever. The annuity returns on $3m (about the worst return you can plan for) would be north of the australian "comfortable" income stream.
- yieldcrv 4y agoIn the Bloomberg article, 16.7% of people agreed with you regarding Australia, 50% said 3 million. Read the article if you have access, it is an interactive graphic for lots of regions around the world.
- ggm 4y agoThe $3m is really fascinating because no financial advisor I speak to promotes this figure to me nor has done. It must be highly contextually defined to the future cohort, and subject to inflation. $1m to $1.7m (which is the maximum holdings in super before special tax comes into play) is much more normal and in fact $400,000 in holdings is "good" I guess I'm not a HNW individual with low expectations of comfort. I am btw speaking regularly to my superannuation people, with plans to retire in the next 2-5 years and I certainly don't have $3m nor an expectation I will therefore NOT be living comfortably. I read the article. I think it must be the cohort who are vested, or read bloomberg responding. this is completely adrift from Australian Industry Superannuation fund models. (and I am sure it IS what people said: I don't mean Bloomberg made it up, I mean they're talking to batshit crazy people who aren't living in the real world)
- jacquesm 4y agoI've run the numbers on this often enough to believe Bloomberg on this one. If I were to start today by retiring on the spot at age 57 the first thing I would have to do is move out of this house, cut our expenses to the bone and hope that I would die before my 70th birthday. Otherwise there isn't enough to make it last. Also, I really wonder if they meant for a couple or an individual and whether or not there was some misinterpretation there.
- yieldcrv 4y ago> The $3m is really fascinating because no financial advisor I speak to promotes this figure to me nor has done They say achievable things for a broader population, not the most accurate things.
- zmmmmm 4y agoI wonder how many of the giant middle slice were comfortable in the 1-1.5 million range. I myself would not be comfortable with $1 million but probably $1.5m would do it. It seems a very odd choice of banding given that it probably skews dramatically to contain what is probably the median of the distribution at the low end while tailing off very far towards the high end.
- twelve40 4y ago> This is obviously highly specific to one economy they list the numbers from all continents in their survey graph, and for what it's worth, the numbers for Australia seem higher than the US
- ggm 4y agoYep. bizarre. So disconnected from reality. I mean sure: if you want to buy a beach house in Byron and drink fancy french champagne every night, go for it. Thats not comfortable retirement as I understand it. I totally believe people responded like this btw.
- nl 4y agoNote that they surveyed "investors" about what they needed to retire comfortably via the MLIV Pulse survey (I think Bloomberg "Markets Live"?). I don't have the data, but I would speculate the the socio-economic expectations of investors that Bloomberg could reach may not reflect the actual economics of what is required to live normally in retirement.
- jacquesm 4y ago> How long do you plan on living? That is in the most literal sense the million dollar question and the answer is most likely 'you don't know'. People routinely live to their mid 80's and even early 90's now, which used to be quite rare. But the quality of life isn't all that great for the majority of them and if you end up misjudging your longevity by a year it isn't going to be all that hard to make ends meet. But if you misjudge it by a decade or even more you are going to be utterly miserable near the end.
- HyperSane 4y agoMy grandparents outlived their savings.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's good! So did mine, but my parents definitely did not. My dad died penniless (I paid for his funeral) my mom is fortunately still alive but not well off financially. I hope to leave my kids enough that they will at least be able to afford a house. But at the rate house prices have increased and the cost of living has increased I am not 100% sure that that will happen.
- jay_kyburz 4y agoI live in Australia and I'm very comfortable spending a lot less that $70k now. I think the gov and media like to inflate the numbers to try and scare people making sure they have a massive war chest. I know plenty of people living pretty good lives on the age pension which is less than $30K. If you have your own house, in good health, don't drink, smoke or play the pokies, you could enjoy your retirement on $30k easily.