4 ms·
The headline doesn't reflect an aspect of this that the article calls out: it being used as a tool by upper classes, to keep lower classes in their place. With
by neilv 4y ago
The headline doesn't reflect an aspect of this that the article calls out: it being used as a tool by upper classes, to keep lower classes in their place.
With that in mind, a "gossip" might be someone who speaks an unflattering truth about an upper class person. A "narcissist" might be someone who presumes to affect some symbol of an upper class, or otherwise disrespects an upper class person.
- moremetadata 4y agoIronically the DSM suggests a narcissist is "A preoccupation with fantasies of unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty, or ideal love. A belief that he or she is special and unique and can only be understood by, or should associate with, other special or high-status people or institutions. A need for excessive admiration" How times have changed, or rather should that be definitions? Now where does royalty and politicians fit into all of this?
- PeterisP 4y ago> Now where does royalty and politicians fit into all of this? That's simple - the admiration that royalty gets is appropriate admiration for their status; but when someone who isn't royalty wants the same level of admiration, that's a need for excessive admiration.
- hutzlibu 4y agoI cannot tell if that was sarcasm, but in case not: so if a king declares, he has "unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty" and is basically a god and wants to worshiped as such, than this is demanding appropriate admiration and not getting laughed at as narcism?
- etherael 4y agoThey make a profession out of what is typically only a hobby.
- schandmasked 4y ago[dead]
- scns 4y agoMaybe that definition is flawed or better incomplete. In my experience narcissistic people react highly allergic to having their flaws shown to them/their flawless self image scratched. They'll do everything do everything to gain a sense of superiority again, when i continued with logically correct argumentation they got enraged and in the end responded with violence. I learned my lesson though, me wanting to be right/winning the argument was an attempt to dominate the other person. Life is way more fun if i get along with others.
- moremetadata 4y ago>I learned my lesson though, me wanting to be right/winning the argument was an attempt to dominate the other person. This isnt a Rorschach test. >Life is way more fun if i get along with others Not in my experience it hasnt, but maybe thats the people I attract and forced to work with.
- arthurofbabylon 4y agoA crucial distinction. The contemporary shame mask in the US is declaring former signifiers of prestige "trashy" as soon as lower-class or less-cultured people gain access.
- IIAOPSW 4y agoThat's more of a supply and demand law in action than any sort of systematic top down enforcement of "class". People aren't ever going to be impressed with the things they can easily have too.
- rob74 4y agoOr, otherwise said, back then, bullying someone who "didn't know his (or her) place" or "didn't fit in" was not only normal, but encouraged.
- hulitu 4y agoNot only back then. Today is also common. Especially in politics.
- scns 4y agoThe pecking order/dominance hierarchy is everywhere. Even if you don't believe it. Lobsters get their status signalled by serotonin, humans with depression have low serotonin levels.
- gladiatr72 4y agoWow. Really? I dumped social media in 2017. Please let me know what rock you've been living under. It sounds nice.
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoIs this really true? On stuff like this I'm kinda torn on whether this is our modern interpretation on stuff like this or genuinely their intention. These kind of traditions and laws were often implemented even in place where nobles / the upper class had little presence. Why? Is it because the peasants had internalized oppression? Or could it alternatively be because working together as a community was important to their very survival then, and so punishing subversive members creating discord was a matter of community survival? Which seems more reasonable: that the peasants had so much time and mindspace to focus on trivialities like making sure poor people didn't dress like rich people, or that they dedicated time to it because a raging narcissist actually posed a real threat? I guess I'm trying to say: maybe the people of the past weren't just all assholes preoccupied with making sure poor people knew their place and were instead much like us in that they focused on getting through the day (and their intentions aligned with that). That they spent inordinate amounts of time making fancy garbs just to humiliate random people in their village because "they're too poor to dress that way" just sounds like a fantasy we place on them because to take them seriously would run against a lot of cultural vogues (like that shame could have any possible value in society).