4 ms·
I don't think fraud is a good analogy - the whole point with fraud is that you are getting something different after you agreed to it, when it's too late to bac
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I don't think fraud is a good analogy - the whole point with fraud is that you are getting something different after you agreed to it, when it's too late to back out.
Going back to the airline example, most people say they hate getting nickel and dimed on things like paying to pick a seat up front or paying even for the first carry-on, but they will still pick one flight over another if the base rate is $5 cheaper. And in that case there is nothing untoward, fraudulent or "dark pattern" about what the airline is doing, as they are just allowing people to only pay for the services they want. But it's still a clear case of consumers saying they want one thing, but by their actions they are incentivizing airlines to do something else.
But regardless of the underlying reason, I still agree that the best solution is for government to provide "ground rules" that most people agree are better. After all, most consumers would probably prefer cheaper products even if manufacturers used child labor or had no pollution controls, but it's the government's role to ensure these longer term societal goals aren't completely ignored in pursuit of the cheapest price.
- californical 4y agoI know I’m not an outlier, but this is why I’ve historically stuck with Delta as an airline. They’re not perfect either, but they give you the main things you’d need for a flight in the base price, and are generally pretty flexible and reasonable with things like bag size. Unless they’re way more expensive, I’ll still pick them for a slightly higher price over the others, because I know that I’ll get a good experience and it’ll be way less stressful. They also always have staff available in the airport when things go wrong. Frontier has been doing this thing where they make everyone put their backpack into the little measuring box so they have a chance to charge you $100 for being an inch oversized. They haven’t gotten me on that personally, but I’ve sworn off of flying with them entirely because it’s like they want you to suffer. I have 40 other complaints about them but I’ll save it for now
- novok 4y agoWhy stick with delta vs other majors, like united, southwest or american airlines? Frontier acting like that just seems consummate with their low price tier like spirit.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoHonestly that backpack measurement sound pretty good to me. I’m sick of subsidizing people with oversized bags while I travel super light. I don’t support hidden fees but I think price discrimination based on usage is totally reasonable. Just make the costs up front.
- jameshart 4y agoThe problem is when the customer chooses the lowest price only to find it stacked with fees before checkout, they don’t think ‘wait a minute, this is more expensive than some of the other flights I saw on the original search page. I’d be better off going back and trying one of them’ The customer assumes that all those other prices would also be lowballing them and that if they went back and chose one they’d end up with an even higher final bill. Starting with the lowest base price seems like a good strategy to get the lowest total price when all the prices are up charged the same.
- novok 4y agoThis only happens in non competitive markets, or markets where fraudy behavior becomes the norm because profit margins are too low and they can't innovate their way into better profit margins. It's an act of desperation essentially.
- ncallaway 4y ago> I don't think fraud is a good analogy - the whole point with fraud is that you are getting something different after you agreed to it, when it's too late to back out. Nah, it’s fraud. It’s a minor, lightweight fraud, but it’s still fraud. These companies are just lying to customers to get what they want, that’s fraud. There’s a veneer of legality to it, because they tell you the price before the “contract” is legally complete, but only after making the customer jump through a few hurdles. The entire point is to make the customer do enough work before you show them the actual price, that they just give up and deal with it. It’s a moral fraud, even if not legally fraud. Even if not on the dotted line, they’re forcing the customer to spend their time on it under false pretenses, in the hope that the sunk cost is enough to trap the customer.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoYou have a very odd definition of "fraud" in my opinion. But I'll just leave it at that, because this feels like the perfect example of the oft-quoted "99% of all Internet arguments are over semantics" line.
- ncallaway 4y agoSure, I’ll agree that my definition doesn’t line up 100% with the legal definition. My definition of fraud is: “lying to someone to induce them to do something they wouldn’t have done without the lie”. I think the hidden pricing lines up neatly with my definition. What’s your definition? (We don’t need to come to an agreement, just curious how you think about it)
- saurik 4y agoFWIW, I don't even really feel like the "legal definition" is relevant: a lot of people on Hacker News seem to think the only thing that matters is the law, and then attempt to move every conversation into whether the law says one thing or the other, and yet fraud is a concept that no one has ever questioned exists even when the law isn't in question or involved. The definition from Oxford Languages (the one Google pulls from) has an "or criminal", but that's clearly elidable, so "wrongful deception intended to result in financial or personal gain" is what we are left with, and the question is then just whether or not it is "wrongful"... and frankly, you're going to end up there also, because I'm pretty sure the person you are arguing with is going to say "this isn't lying". I guess what I mean to say is: you are actually trying to have an ethical argument, but are being drawn into a silly semantic argument over the definition and source of a word you used not really because the definition matters but because it has a bad connotation and since they disagree that this is unethical behavior they want a happy word there, when the real problem is the ethical disagreement.
- eastbound 4y ago> but they will still pick one flight over another if the base rate is $5 cheaper The other flight also tricks you with in-flight purchase of air, so, might as well choose the lowest base price.