2 ms·
> 1) US practice is that TV showrunners are writers Is that different in any other countries? I'm having a hard time imagining what other background a showrunn
by crazygringo 4y ago
> 1) US practice is that TV showrunners are writers
Is that different in any other countries? I'm having a hard time imagining what other background a showrunner would come from. E.g. the directing skillset is somewhat related but ultimately very different.
> 2) that all the writing for the season isn't done before starting production.
Well you certainly can't do that for a 22-episode season, especially as writers very much adapt in real time to what's "working" in the show. It's quite common for a character intended only for a single episode to turn out to be unexpectedly extremely charistmatic and quickly turn into a main character, because of the actor's performance.
But for an hourlong 8-episode prestige drama for HBO, it's not uncommon for all of the writing to be done ahead of time. Or at the very least, the entire story is "broken" (outlined) in detail, even if the dialog isn't written out.
- ghaff 4y ago>E.g. the directing skillset is somewhat related but ultimately very different. Certainly. That's why the showrunner mostly doesn't direct episodes and film directors mostly didn't write the script (though they probably influenced it). The difference is that films can go through a multi-year development process with things hopefully largely nailed down before production starts--because that's when the bills really start mounting fast. TV, on the other hand, historically had a lot more writing and production values were often a lot lower. So writing was important (and had to happen relatively quickly) while a solid journeyman director was probably fine. Certainly their name was mostly not a draw for audiences. (Obviously something like Rings of Power is a lot different from a season of Law and Order.)
- labster 4y agoLaw and Order’s writing quality and direction is only a little bit better than Rings of Power so I don’t quite understand your point.
- ghaff 4y agoYou probably think you're being clever but I won't take the bait. While good procedurals require talented writing as well, they operate under constraints and are both low risk and relatively low reward compared to something in less charted territory. Writing even good formula is hard to screw up too badly given some level of talent (and clearly communicated and guardrailed formula).
- labster 4y agoYou think you didn’t take the bait, but Dr. Devereaux wrote a four-part blog series on why Rings of Power is bad. The thesis was essentially that it was they ignored enough historical guardrails as to lack verisimilitude, earning the dreaded “I don’t care about these people.” After reading the OP, I can’t shake the feeling that the showrunners flubbed handling the writers room enough to make glaring continuity errors (traveling 1000+ km in two days), and instead spent time in post designing sails that wouldn’t work. Law and Order folks are smart enough to rip from the headlines. Anyway, here’s 10k words from orc logistics guy you can read so you can prove me wrong: https://acoup.blog/tag/rings-of-power/ https://acoup.blog/tag/rings-of-power/
- tptacek 4y agoSeries director is just a different role than feature director. A feature director is usually the ultimate creative authority for the whole enterprise, but not on a series, where they report to the showrunning writer.