3 ms·
A major foundational idea of this piece seems to be that population leveling and/or decline is a bad thing. But, I'm not sure it really is. Where does this id
by mixmastamyk 4y ago
A major foundational idea of this piece seems to be that population leveling and/or decline is a bad thing. But, I'm not sure it really is. Where does this idea come from?
I know that some allowances need to be planned for regarding the economy, but it is obvious that indefinite/infinite population growth is not desirable nor tenable.
- mistrial9 4y agobecause not everyone is affected the same way. Some populations have no trouble making as many babies as can be fed, to this day. Other populations are living the "Idiocracy" parody in real life.. The plants in the garden compete, and you bet fauna does, too. Reproductive failure due to social and psychological pressures is not "better" it is illness.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThere are certain social structures[1] which were created or evolved with the assumption of population growth in mind. When the assumption no longer holds, the structure degenerates. The current structure of economic growth, social security, housing, education &c all made structural choices based on population growth assumptions. That's not to say these are categorically existential problems, but more that absent mutandis mutatis(in varying degrees), they have that potential. 1. In the broadest possible sense. ie: economic structures are social structures
- midoridensha 4y agoBasically, if people all started dropping dead at age 65, population decline would be such a big problem (though it would still be a problem with the low birthrate). As it is, we're going to have a very large portion of the population that's elderly and not working, while drawing from pensions or social assistance funds, and many of them also needing a lot of medical and/or hospice care too.
- ianai 4y agoThe US truly is the land of plenty. It’s some of the most fertile land on earth across a significant portion of the northern American continent. It produces food for billions of people every year. Most of the land mass is void of people, for that matter. There is no scarcity for the logistics of a larger US population outside the ones the US creates for itself.
- Ancalagon 4y agoThat doesn’t mean we should fill it with people and agriculture
- mixmastamyk 4y agoLand of plenty meet exponential population growth, add several decades to taste. Sustainability is important, just ask the Lorax.
- midoridensha 4y agoExactly, and there won't be any problem if we build expansive subdivisions with all houses having huge lawns on all the fertile land in the US. America can just import its food from somewhere else.