5 ms·
I think a lot of comments here are missing the reason as to why these hidden fees have become so much more prevalent in the past 20 or so years. The short of it
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I think a lot of comments here are missing the reason as to why these hidden fees have become so much more prevalent in the past 20 or so years. The short of it is that comparison pricing is now much easier to do because of the Internet, and many, if not a majority, of shoppers will just sort by price ascending and pick the first result (or, only pick from the first couple results).
Thus, there is a huge incentive for companies to lower the base price and then get it back with these types of fees. Even if they didn't add BS fees, this ease of price comparison has resulted in unbundling of services in a number of industries - e.g. airlines where the base price is akin to "we let you hang on to the wing", and everything else is an upcharge.
This is also a case where consumers say they want one thing, but their behavior is a different matter. For example, pretty much everyone says they prefer the full price to be shown up front in search result pages. But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion, where there is a lower up-front price and fees are only tacked on during checkout.
To be clear, I'm 100% in favor of this regulation because I think it's the perfect example of where what is good for any individual company leads to a dysfunctional market, and so government can provide a level playing field. Heck, I think many businesses would support this change, because they no longer need to try to one-up their competitors by overcomplicating their pricing structure.
- pydry 4y ago>But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion, where there is a lower up-front price and fees are only tacked on during checkout. That is evidence that bait and switch works, not that people want it.
- 93po 4y agoI think OP recognizes that, but is simply stating that product decisions are based on user behavior, which rewards bait and switch
- vkou 4y agoWell, of course bait-and-switch is going to result in a higher conversion rate than showing the price up front. I'd like to not be swindled, but if the marketplace is half-swindlers and half-honest people, it's highly likely I'll be taken in by the former. What the kind of heuristic am I expected to use to avoid getting swindled?
- AussieWog93 4y ago>What the kind of heuristic am I expected to use to avoid getting swindled? Giant, bold text that says "price is all-inclusive. No additional fees!"
- IncRnd 4y agoAt checkout, when there are no additional fees: Customer: What is this extra fee on my bill? Business: There is no extra fee. Customer: It's this number right here. That's a fee. Why is it there? Business: No no no. That's not a fee. It's for your benefit. Consumer: What does that even mean? Business: That's a final emolument that is used to keep costs for consumers low and fee-free. Everybody pays it, since it is for your safety and benefit. Final emoluments like this are mandated, since we are completely free of hidden fees.
- slg 4y ago>This is also a case where consumers say they want one thing, but their behavior is a different matter. For example, pretty much everyone says they prefer the full price to be shown up front in search result pages. But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion, where there is a lower up-front price and fees are only tacked on during checkout. This seems to be very misguided logic to me. I can also trick people with fraud but that doesn't mean the victims are indifferent to the fraud. It being effective doesn't mean people like it. Consumers can still hate this hidden fee approach even, and perhaps especially, because it is effective.
- spiffytech 4y agoIt doesn't need to be fraud. A common trick in designing restaurant menus is to make it harder to scan the price list, because people buy the food they prefer when price is one of many considerations rather than prominently highlighted. > Centred Justification > When prices are printed in neat, right-justified columns, everyone glances down the line to compare prices. Menu consultants recommend a centred justification that leaves the prices scattered. This gently encourages the diner to order what she wants, not pick the cheapest price. Another way of minimising attention to cost? Omit the pound signs. https://www.wired.co.uk/article/the-hidden-psychology-of-menu-design https://www.wired.co.uk/article/the-hidden-psychology-of-men...
- yamtaddle 4y agoWhat's weird, at least in the US, is that the higher-end the joint, the easier it is to shop by price, generally. Tax-inclusive, whole-dollar-value (no "$7.99" crap, it's just "8"), all-prices-aligned menus are more common as one heads up-scale.
- daniel-cussen 4y ago[dead]
- meltedcapacitor 4y ago
- foobarian 4y ago> Heck, I think many businesses would support this change Also being privy to A/B testing in this area, I can tell you that we developers would looooove this kind of regulation so we don't have to build these kinds of dark patterns while holding our noses and telling ourselves that at least the pay is good.
- logifail 4y ago> this ease of price comparison has resulted in unbundling of services in a number of industries - e.g. airlines where the base price is akin to "we let you hang on to the wing" <cough> I'm literally just booking a trip with Ryanair, Vienna to London, in just less than a month's time. It's costing me a shade less than $20 for a 770 mile flight, no hidden fees during my purchase... No, it doesn't include a large carry-on bag, never mind a checked bag. No, it doesn't include priority boarding. No, it doesn't include reserved seating. No, I won't earn any frequent-flyer miles/elite status. Also, the in-flight F+B will be overpriced, so it's safer not to waste money there either. However, for a two-hour flight and a short trip, I don't need any of those things! I just want to get from A to B, safely, and preferably on-time. FR is at least as likely to do those two things as any of the 'legacy' carriers I could pick instead.
- bradleyjg 4y agoFor legitimately separable things—-like a carry-on bag or assigned seats—-I think unbundling is a good thing. Sure it feels a bit annoying to see the price go up and up, but sometimes you don’t need those things and the search engines should be able to get you an apples to apples price with a bit of elbow grease. It’s the non-optional fees—- resort, regulatory compliance, or living wage—-that are truly pernicious.
- diebeforei485 4y agoThese are all optional - you don't have to pay them if you don't use those services. They wouldn't be affected by this bill. "Resort fees" or "amenity fees" are not optional. Even if you don't use the services in those fees, you still have to pay them. Those are what are being clamped down on.
- logifail 4y ago> These are all optional - you don't have to pay them if you don't use those services. They wouldn't be affected by this bill I was responding to the comment about what the airlines' base price includes - at least here on this side of the pond, the base price is for safe travel (with a small carry-on bag) from A to B, and if that's all you want, it's all you need to pay.
- binoct 4y ago> This is also a case where consumers say they want one thing, but their behavior is a different matter. For example, pretty much everyone says they prefer the full price to be shown up front in search result pages. But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion, where there is a lower up-front price and fees are only tacked on during checkout. Consumers are very consistent here. You are comparing what consumers want: clear, upfront pricing so they can pick the lowest cost option, with what companies want: more sales. The fact that putting your pricing upfront causes you to lose customers because your competition is hiding costs is as you point out a dysfunctional market problem. But the consumers involved are not being hypocritical.
- mattficke 4y agoAirlines are an interesting an example because the FAA required them to advertise all-inclusive pricing a decade ago. The extras they charge for now (checked bags, bigger seats, nonstop flights) really are optional —- I routinely pack light and pass on any upgrades. People who need to check a bag can include that in their price comparison. For hotels, it’s fine to charge extra for access to the pool or whatever as long as it’s possible to decline.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoIn my experience hotels are free to add daily “resort fees” that cover whatever they want, no option to decline.
- bradleyjg 4y agoOne interesting wrinkle is sitting next to another person on your ticket. By all rights it should be optional but person after person books the no assigned seat option and then is outraged that they are not seated next to their companions.
- mattficke 4y agoThere was an interesting article on United’s new family seating policy, allows families traveling with children under 12 to sit together automatically with no added fees by default. Sounded like a decent way of identifying when sitting together actually would be optional for most people. https://viewfromthewing.com/uniteds-new-family-seating-policy-helps-customers-hurts-competitors-and-curries-political-favor/ https://viewfromthewing.com/uniteds-new-family-seating-polic...
- bradleyjg 4y agoI’m fine with this solution, families can use a break in modern America. But if airlines had said from the beginning that bookings with a child under 12 are not eligible for basic economy, it’d hard to see what’s unfair about that.
- AussieWog93 4y ago>But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion I suspect this might be the case initially, but eventually consumers will get fed up with being tricked again and again and refuse to deal with that particular industry (and A/B testing won't predict that). I know this is the case for myself and local services (e.g. cleaning, lawn mowing, appliance repair). I literally will not search for any of those things because I don't want to have to sort through bullshit. Same thing for restaurants that expect a tip. I might uncomfortably pay it, but would never go back there. (note: tipping culture is very different in Australia compared to the US, as are minimum wage laws. Your local barrista is probably getting $35+ an hour on a weekend.)
- lumb63 4y agoHeh, or they’ll democratically decide to ban you from operating in their society if you use hidden fees. A/B testing won’t predict that, either.
- IncRnd 4y ago> This is also a case where consumers say they want one thing, but their behavior is a different matter. For example, pretty much everyone says they prefer the full price to be shown up front in search result pages. But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion, where there is a lower up-front price and fees are only tacked on during checkout. That's completely wrong. People don't want hidden fees. They chose those options that have hidden fees, because the fees are hidden and the total cost appears lower. Your AB tests don't compare what consumers want but what consumers are tricked into accepting.
- xbar 4y agoAgreed. It seems that the A/B testing proves that humans are easily tricked, not that they like hidden fees.
- stillsleepy 4y ago[flagged]
- stillsleepy 4y ago[flagged]
- yamtaddle 4y agoIt's because nobody actually has trouble understanding what "free" means in these contexts except the same small percentage of morons one can get to say any dumb thing one wishes to find someone saying, and people pretending not to understand it on Internet forums to passive-aggressively make a very stupid point. Everyone else gets it. You're not preaching some great message to the sheeple, you're just making noise.
- II2II 4y agoIn my neck of the woods, it is called public health care or public health insurance. Oddly enough, neither the government nor the media feel compelled to make it sound like you're getting extra value by calling it free. Of course, this applies to a broad range of public services such as education and libraries. (As for why these services should be offered at no cost to the users, it has to do with accessibility to people regardless of their income. No one pretends that no cost to users means that it is free. Everyone understands that it is wrapped into their taxes and that taxes are tied to their income.)
- dheera 4y agoYes please. Also kill tipping on food delivery apps. It's a mandatory fee, effectively. They ask for tips before service is even rendered. WTF? Just increase the displayed prices by 15%.
- jstarfish 4y ago> This is also a case where consumers say they want one thing, but their behavior is a different matter. For example, pretty much everyone says they prefer the full price to be shown up front in search result pages. But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion, where there is a lower up-front price and fees are only tacked on during checkout. You think your customers don't know what they're talking about...because the data you gleaned from abusing them says otherwise? Dictator logic: "My approval rate is 100%! People clearly love what I'm doing!"
- novok 4y agoExtra fees later on is exploiting people who have invested time into the buying process and now have a higher price for saying no vs. whatever the extra fee is. It's rational consumer behavior, but it is not what you actually think it is. Vast majority of A/B testing schemes that do gotcha pricing cannot measure the 'credit rating' that your essentially burning by doing this, and it's only sustainable if they don't have any other choice of place that doesn't do this. It's classic short term PM metrics hacking in exchange for hurting the business or industry overall.
- account42 4y ago> and it's only sustainable if they don't have any other choice of place that doesn't do this. Unfortunately in many cases "short term" here is long enough to force/encourage the competition to follow suit so you get entire sectors where there is no choice.
- diebeforei485 4y agoIt's not just comparison pricing. The online booking portals take a percent of the revenue. The Expedia tax is not very different than App Store taxes. By requiring part of the fee to be paid directly to the hotel at check-in, it means the hotel gets to keep more of their revenue.
- SnowingXIV 4y agoIt's become rampant in travel. Booked a simple vacation to Vegas recently. Between flights with their multiple fees you mentioned, hotels that almost are always charging a per day resort fee, and then ticket sales to any event that has multiple processing fees. I don't know how this happened but it's horrible.
- twawaaay 4y ago> this ease of price comparison has resulted in unbundling of services in a number of industries - e.g. airlines where the base price is akin to "we let you hang on to the wing", and everything else is an upcharge. The issue isn't that everything is an upcharge. I have no problem with having options. I actually like being able to pay less when I don't need the added options. With airlines, (at least here in EU) you pretty much know what the base price buys you and that everything is an option on top of it. And as long as the options are reasonable (like paying for additional luggage) and the UI isn't trying to mislead you to buying something you don't intend, I think this is very defensible from the standpoint of making product better and more affordable to people (who don't necessarily need additional luggage, for example). The issue is in many cases there is not even a possibility to buy the product/service for the advertised price and they will make difficult for you to find out what you are going to pay until it is too late or you have invested time/effort. It is a restaurant where the charges are added to your bill (the tip no longer being voluntary) or a shop where they try to recoup some of their losses with an exaggerated shipment fees. Or when you suddenly find out a critical part of your product is sold separately. Or you buy a printer and then they try to scam you by selling the ink/toner for more than the price of the printer. Or the website UI makes every effort to hide from you the fact you are buying something you don't need.
- nottorp 4y ago> But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion, where there is a lower up-front price and fees are only tacked on during checkout. This just shows how much of a bubble sales people are in. Just because your sales data shows a better profit it doesn't mean it's not fraudulent.
- bcrosby95 4y agoBasically, bait and switch is an effective tactic, especially after factoring in the sunk cost fallacy.
- nostromo 4y ago> airlines where the base price is akin to "we let you hang on to the wing", and everything else is an upcharge This legislation wouldn't stop that, nor resort fees, because they're not required. It would however effect Airbnb, one of the worst offenders, because their fees are mandatory and not shown until checkout. It's funny the government has exempted its own taxes and fees (the largest last minute fees we all pay everyday) from this requirement.
- kyrra 4y agoWhile i agree with you on the taxes front, one hard thing is that not everyone pays it. Depending on what's being sold and who the buyer is, the buyer may have tax exempt status, which may not be known until checkout.
- lumb63 4y agoI have lived in areas with sales tax all my life, and with the exception of gasoline, prices being shown with tax is exceedingly rare. At least these could be covered!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoFor folks taking issue with my "consumers say one thing but act a different way" line, here is a perfect example: https://money.com/stubhub-fees-all-in-ticket-prices/ https://money.com/stubhub-fees-all-in-ticket-prices/ StubHub tried to do the right thing here, even touting their all-in pricing as an advantage over competitors - and customers still preferred their competitors' more opaque pricing practices anyway. Point being, no company can afford to "do the right thing" if their competitors can do the "wrong thing" and be rewarded for that wrong thing. This is when government should step in.
- jasmer 4y agoThe other reason is continued civic moral debasement. We used to live in communities, whereing social mores were at least nominally respected or accepted. Even if they were broken, at minimum 'wrong was wrong' and in particular, reputation mattered. We later moved into larger corporate entities wherein mores could be sidelined, and now we've flipped the game entirely and there are few civic questions to contemplate. It's just "The Funnel" and that's it. Even if most people don't fully buy Milton Friedman's Chicago School 'the motive is only profit' stuff, the ideal set it. VC-land and the Valley never even talk bother about civic good, consumer surplus etc. other than maybe in some situations a kind of DEI/Climate specific kind of ideological way. The baseline assumption is 'the product must be doing some kind of 'good' and if not who cares'. Commerce is generally positive but it's pretty easy to see where the frayed edeges are. Dark Patterns abound, even by supposedly reputable companies. I don't think people realize how perverse this is and how it strongly degrades civil life. It's not good that we have to be worried about how we are being ripped off / misled by major companies we are supposed to trust. Paradoxically, in the long run, most of it is not worth it. A small optimization in the funnel is not going to change anything.
- gdprrrr 4y agoI read it as "customers would prefer if everyone showed prices upfront", ehich makes sense to me.
- pessimizer 4y ago> airlines where the base price is akin to "we let you hang on to the wing", and everything else is an upcharge. This would actually be a better situation. Instead the base price is "this would be what we would theoretically charge you to hang onto the wing, but since that's not legally allowed there's no possible way anyone could buy a ticket for this price." If they were selling food like that, there would be a "state-inspected and legal to sell quality upcharge."
- balderdash 4y agoThe other thing is that, take airline pricing for example, 80% of consumers fly 0-2 round trips a year, and half of Americans don’t fly in a given year…which means that many consumers don’t do the repeat buying to get screwed and change their behavior, or want to spend several hours researching how to save $35…
- keenmaster 4y agoThe most consumer-friendly outcome would be if all market participants used transparent pricing at each tier of product/service. This maximizes what the consumer receives per dollar spent, because they can easily compare apples to apples and oranges to oranges across many competitors. How about this for an A/B test (rhetorical): show consumers one universe where perfect competition is enforced like I describe above, and one universe where most market participants bait and switch customers, forcing them to shop for hours and then ending up paying more for less. Or compare shopping at the grocery store vs shopping even the most fungible medical procedures between 2 hospitals :) (if you can even manage to shop the latter) If you think consumers like to be tricked, you either need to zoom out of the narrow context where that seems to be true, or you’re financially incentivized to swindle the plebs.
- MathMonkeyMan 4y ago> This is also a case where consumers say they want one thing, but their behavior is a different matter. For example, pretty much everyone says they prefer the full price to be shown up front in search result pages. But, as someone who is privy to a ton of A/B testing in this area, the opposite nearly always results in higher conversion, where there is a lower up-front price and fees are only tacked on during checkout. I'll restate what at least one other commenter pointed out. If I, a consumer, say "I want transparent pricing," and then given transparent pricing I'm less likely to buy your product, that doesn't mean I was mistaken. It means the truth is that I don't want to buy your product, and you would have to lie to me in order to make a purchase more likely.
- CMCDragonkai 4y agoAustralian ACCC just basically regulates how prices are displayed for everything. It makes it simple. GST inclusive everything is fair.