3 ms·
They keep testing the wrong thing: It helped people with tapeworms. They didn't know they had tapeworms. They would never know they had tapeworms. They have a
by yieldcrv 4y ago
They keep testing the wrong thing:
It helped people with tapeworms. They didn't know they had tapeworms. They would never know they had tapeworms. They have a symbiotic relationship with tapeworms until their immune system is distracted with something else, such as Covid, then the tapeworm becomes a hostile host unchecked. Ivermectin treatment subdued the tapeworm and the immune system was not distracted anymore, avoiding death during severe covid.
If nobody does the study that way, then there won't be anything to cite. Here's your extremely probable hypothesis. Good luck finding the people with tapeworms given the state of US healthcare.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoI find this highly likely the reason (making truth, again, much more nuanced than it seems). Also it's disturbing to look up the statistics and realize that a surprising percentage of the US has undiagnosed parasites. It changes depending on definition used but it's quite substantial... https://www.vice.com/en/article/a3m88j/millions-of-americans-have-a-parasite-and-dont-realize-it https://www.vice.com/en/article/a3m88j/millions-of-americans... It doesn't even need to be tapeworm. There are a ton of parasites that can be reactivated...
- yieldcrv 4y agoIts really dismaying to me that this is "political". It distracts the credentialed people and respected institutions from considering this hypothesis. All the studies are reactionary like "I told you so!" while testing the wrong thing and exacerbating why this is political at all. Its simple geography. Suburban and rural areas are living in greater squalor than anyone would care to admit. Hence the tapeworms. The people in those areas are not considered or serviced well by Democrats and happen to be Republican. The people there made an incorrect conclusion due to a correlation, the people elsewhere called them dumb and eventually did study after study on the incorrect conclusion just to say "you're dumb". The causation in those areas are not considered or well serviced.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoI completely agree. It's amazing because, arguably, both sides are correct! Science: It does nothing against COVID! (True, in isolation.) Lived Experience: It sure helped me! (And it actually probably did!) Also, your comments about squalor - most of the test subjects probably don't live in rural areas where they would be more likely to get the parasites... And if you do live in such an area, ivermectin may actually be a completely reasonable treatment strategy (for the same reasons that "lots of rest," "stay hydrated," etc. are beneficial). Yikes.
- tdeck 4y ago> Its simple geography. Suburban and rural areas are living in greater squalor than anyone would care to admit. Hence the tapeworms. Would be nice to present any evidence at all for this claim. The vice article that parent post linked to doesn't talk about tapeworms or about area geography. Why would people in suburban areas be so much more at risk for tapeworms than people in urban areas? This feels like the height of motivated reasoning.
- baseballdork 4y agoAlso, wouldn't we expect to see this in these studies?
- yieldcrv 4y agobecause that only appears if that's what was studied. which it wasn't. this study and many others aren't checking patients to see if Ivermectin is by coincidence being used for what it was approved for - tapeworm treatment. they are doing studies on people with covid.
- baseballdork 4y ago> because that only appears if that's what was studied. Why would that be the case? If there's a statistically significant portion of the population suffering from parasites and this treatment improves outcomes for those people in a statistically significant way, then why isn't that going to show up in a study looking for improvement of outcomes?
- giardini 4y agoThe article has a few errors/omissions about the so-called "kissing bug": There is a family of insects, "assassin bugs", having a hypodermic proboscis, that manifest the "kissing bug" behavior. They land and pierce the skin with the proboscis. At 14 I was bitten on the arm. A burning sensation alerted me, whereupon I noted a young red-and-black assassin bug on my arm and brushed it off. In contrast my 8-year-old cousin was bitten by a large (1-1/2" long) assassin bug and screamed for an hour. There is no such thing as a "mild bite" and I fail to see how one could sleep through it. As well, the burning and pain is caused b/c the insect injects digestive enzymes into its prey to kill and eat it (like a spider). The larger the bug, the more enzymes. The "kissing-bug" moniker dates from at least the early part of the previous century: a North American infestation of assassin bugs occurred (near Chicago IIRC) and it was indeed a newsworthy event: I once saw a copy of an old newspaper article about the outbreak. The astonishing thing is how far north this was reported decades ago. It is only within the last 30 years that medical authorities have even begun to admit that Chagas Disease could be present in the continental USA and there was much debate about its presence in Texas, one of the southernmost states.
- BirdieNZ 4y agoThat's a similar conclusion Scott Alexander came to: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-than-you-wanted https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-t...
- krackers 4y ago>They have a symbiotic relationship Isn't symbiotic the wrong word if there's no benefit to the host?
- giardini 4y agoNot tapeworm. Ivermectin works on other types of worms and is used esp. for roundworm (Ascariasis). And ivermectin kills lice, bedbugs et al. In any case, anyone living in the southern USA likely carries some parasite that ivermectin kills off. E.g., children often pick up head lice and other parasites at day care or school. Ivermectin is well-tolerated and easily applied, really a "wonder drug" that we're lucky to have (but aren't they all?).