3 ms·
I think that's a fair point and question with regard to how we handle collateral damage from police action. The most important piece is probably how we handle B
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
I think that's a fair point and question with regard to how we handle collateral damage from police action. The most important piece is probably how we handle Bond and people under investigation as well as their arrest records after the fact. I don't think that arrest records that do not lead to conviction should be able to be used by Third parties, although I understand that their retention is valuable for police themselves.
Ideally, holistic police oversight would take into account the damage they do and make sure that they take reasonable care to mitigate the damage. Ultimately the taxpayers should be on the hook one way or another for the full cost of police protection that they want
- mindslight 4y agoI'd say oversight and bail/bond issues are ultimately part of the poor incentives created by blanket sovereign immunity. If it were to cost $1k/day [0] to keep someone in jail awaiting trial, then those running the system have an actual tradeoff to make. Same thing if states have to start reimbursing the costs of bail bondsmen for those found innocent. I'm not arguing against considering the qualitative issues on their own. I just think attempts to address them directly without addressing the underlying poor incentives are somewhat doomed. Additionally, plea bargains have to be massively reformed for the incentives to be significant. Arrest records are an orthogonal topic squarely in the realm of commercial surveillance / data protection, which the US is sorely lacking. We need less narrow-scoped red tape like HIPAA and more general right to control all records about us ala GDPR. [0] direct incremental costs paid out in cash if they're acquitted, as opposed to the large fixed costs of staffing the jail which come out of someone else's budget.