5 ms·
You don't have to go to that extreme. The Myth also says that with less profit motive, less would happen. But, is that really true? If a profitable corporation
by ryandrake 4y ago
You don't have to go to that extreme. The Myth also says that with less profit motive, less would happen. But, is that really true? If a profitable corporation has to pay a little more in taxes, and thus becomes slightly less profitable, will shareholders simply decide to "Go Galt," close the business, and stop making that delicious profit? I don't think so. If I was a business owner, and I had to go from making "great profit" to "good profit" I'm still thrilled because I'm profiting. I'm not going to take my ball and go home.
Businesses close when they make no profit, or when there's not a market fit, or for many other non-tax-related reasons. I've never heard of a business failing simply because their taxes were too darn high.
- Kalium 4y agoTo be clear, shareholders do routinely pull their money from companies they believe are underperforming. This is what's happening when a stock price drops or bond rate climbs after a company's earnings fall short of expectations. Investors are generally not equally thrilled with a mediocre profit instead of a great profit because any profit is delicious. Do they "Go Galt"? No, but their money often goes somewhere else. A different company, a hedge fund, or even a different country are all options used quite regularly. Taking their ball and going to play somewhere else with some other people is always an option. Tax policy can and does influence this.
- jandrewrogers 4y agoYou are ignoring that the net profit has to be sufficiently high to offset risk in the financial calculation. Expected ROI calculations are always net of taxes, inflation, and risk. Many businesses that look "profitable" on paper are uninvestable due to inflation and risk, so reducing realized net profits pushes more businesses into this category. There absolutely is a level of positive profit below which it makes more financial sense for investors to sit on their money. Governments are aware of this and set their taxation policies accordingly. That is why long-term capital gains usually have a relatively low tax rates. There is a high drag on expected ROI due to inflation and risk that makes many of those investments unattractive ceteris paribus.