6 ms·

A whole generation is going to start relying on AI and never do any actual writing or critical thinking for themselves. This is a problem when the average readi

by ecf 4y ago

A whole generation is going to start relying on AI and never do any actual writing or critical thinking for themselves. This is a problem when the average reading level for half of American adults is already below that of an 8th grader.

cjbgkagh 4y ago
I figure learning the utility of AI might be more important than critical thinking about why some stories character might be female. Don’t we have more interesting questions for these children to ponder? Plus editing requires critical thinking in a way that is less mechanical than essay writing.
pixl97 4y ago
What is the long term historical trend of the average 8th grade reading level when taking in all currently measured groups and taking in considerations in measurement changes?
- criddell 4y ago
  From looking at the reading assignments my kids were given throughout middle and high school, it seems like the goal of the education system is to eliminate any joy a kid finds in reading. When they were in elementary school, they learned that any book with a silver or gold medallion on the cover was the book equivalent of vegetables. You read it because some adults think it will be good for you. When I was in high school (late 1980’s), there was a time each week for what they called USSR - undisturbed, sustained, silent reading (in retrospect, USSR is a strange acronym). They didn’t care what we read and there were no assignments associated with the reading material. The goal was to choose something you want to read and read it, 45 minutes at a time. Edit: I just looked it up and it turns out it wasn’t a local thing. I had the acronym wrong though - it’s uninterrupted sustained silent reading. http://ejournal.unp.ac.id/index.php/jelt/article/view/101466 http://ejournal.unp.ac.id/index.php/jelt/article/view/101466
  - Izkata 4y ago
    We had "silent reading" in elementary school (I remember it for sure in 6th grade, and I think earlier as well) and I remember most kids finding something they liked (at the very least they weren't goofing around), then middle school and high school is when the required reading started killing interest for everyone.
lambdaba 4y ago
I know this is a bit of a shortcut but have pocket calculators rendered mental math extinct? I see language models as calculators for text. True, the analogy isn't perfect, as you don't need to double-check your calculator's output.
- lambdaba 4y ago
  Adding to this idea: perhaps learning how to "calculate" with text, or treating human semantic output as a programmable medium is the entire point of LLMs, as an evolution of our communication capabilities. For instance, I think the dramatic depreciation of low-quality text, various summarization techniques, etc. will act as a filter / evolutionary pressure on improving the quality and value of intellectual output.
- lm28469 4y ago
  > I know this is a bit of a shortcut but have pocket calculators rendered mental math extinct? I've witness several cashiers getting their phone out to calculate basic change. Things like 1 euros - 20ct So yes definitely
  - lambdaba 4y ago
    Well, I said extinct, but I wouldn't bet that on average mental arithmetic skills went down, perhaps they have, on the other hand it freed people up for learning about more complex operations and allowing them to perform those operations where otherwise they would be too costly.
    - lm28469 4y ago
      Why not mitigate both, force people to learn the basics, allow them to use the tools later. It isn't mutually esclusive
    - dorchadas 4y ago
      At least in math they didn't learn those operations though, because they don't have a strong foundation in the basics to understand how it works. Mental arithmetic is often indicative of at least a somewhat stronger number sense, and this shows at upper level math courses. Even at the high school level, where I had to struggle with kids who were way too reliant on a calculator and couldn't do basic math because of it, and thus struggled to do anything more advanced or abstract.
65 4y ago
School curriculums need to adjust how they are creating assignments. I had a great assignment in college where the professor gave you all the materials required. You could only use the various articles/essays/news clippings he gave you, and you wrote an essay based on that. Assignments that don't rely on the internet for research would do a much better job teaching the material and forcing students to read the material. Students wouldn't be able to SparkNote or ChatGPT an essay.
- lm28469 4y ago
  In my country most exams are in person with no phone/internet. You can cheat all year if you want for homework &co, they're just here to help you get good for the monthly/yearly exams
- deleted 4y ago
  [deleted]
deleted 4y ago
[deleted]

by ecf 4y ago

cjbgkagh 4y ago

I figure learning the utility of AI might be more important than critical thinking about why some stories character might be female. Don’t we have more interesting questions for these children to ponder? Plus editing requires critical thinking in a way that is less mechanical than essay writing.

pixl97 4y ago

What is the long term historical trend of the average 8th grade reading level when taking in all currently measured groups and taking in considerations in measurement changes?

criddell 4y ago
From looking at the reading assignments my kids were given throughout middle and high school, it seems like the goal of the education system is to eliminate any joy a kid finds in reading. When they were in elementary school, they learned that any book with a silver or gold medallion on the cover was the book equivalent of vegetables. You read it because some adults think it will be good for you. When I was in high school (late 1980’s), there was a time each week for what they called USSR - undisturbed, sustained, silent reading (in retrospect, USSR is a strange acronym). They didn’t care what we read and there were no assignments associated with the reading material. The goal was to choose something you want to read and read it, 45 minutes at a time. Edit: I just looked it up and it turns out it wasn’t a local thing. I had the acronym wrong though - it’s uninterrupted sustained silent reading. http://ejournal.unp.ac.id/index.php/jelt/article/view/101466 http://ejournal.unp.ac.id/index.php/jelt/article/view/101466
- Izkata 4y ago
  We had "silent reading" in elementary school (I remember it for sure in 6th grade, and I think earlier as well) and I remember most kids finding something they liked (at the very least they weren't goofing around), then middle school and high school is when the required reading started killing interest for everyone.

lambdaba 4y ago

I know this is a bit of a shortcut but have pocket calculators rendered mental math extinct? I see language models as calculators for text. True, the analogy isn't perfect, as you don't need to double-check your calculator's output.

lambdaba 4y ago
Adding to this idea: perhaps learning how to "calculate" with text, or treating human semantic output as a programmable medium is the entire point of LLMs, as an evolution of our communication capabilities. For instance, I think the dramatic depreciation of low-quality text, various summarization techniques, etc. will act as a filter / evolutionary pressure on improving the quality and value of intellectual output.
lm28469 4y ago
> I know this is a bit of a shortcut but have pocket calculators rendered mental math extinct? I've witness several cashiers getting their phone out to calculate basic change. Things like 1 euros - 20ct So yes definitely
- lambdaba 4y ago
  Well, I said extinct, but I wouldn't bet that on average mental arithmetic skills went down, perhaps they have, on the other hand it freed people up for learning about more complex operations and allowing them to perform those operations where otherwise they would be too costly.
  - lm28469 4y ago
    Why not mitigate both, force people to learn the basics, allow them to use the tools later. It isn't mutually esclusive
  - dorchadas 4y ago
    At least in math they didn't learn those operations though, because they don't have a strong foundation in the basics to understand how it works. Mental arithmetic is often indicative of at least a somewhat stronger number sense, and this shows at upper level math courses. Even at the high school level, where I had to struggle with kids who were way too reliant on a calculator and couldn't do basic math because of it, and thus struggled to do anything more advanced or abstract.

65 4y ago

School curriculums need to adjust how they are creating assignments. I had a great assignment in college where the professor gave you all the materials required. You could only use the various articles/essays/news clippings he gave you, and you wrote an essay based on that. Assignments that don't rely on the internet for research would do a much better job teaching the material and forcing students to read the material. Students wouldn't be able to SparkNote or ChatGPT an essay.

lm28469 4y ago
In my country most exams are in person with no phone/internet. You can cheat all year if you want for homework &co, they're just here to help you get good for the monthly/yearly exams
deleted 4y ago
[deleted]

deleted 4y ago

[deleted]