7 ms·
I don’t get this argument. Government scales with population size just fine.
by Retric 4y ago
I don’t get this argument. Government scales with population size just fine.
- ryandrake 4y agoExactly. Pennsylvania has 13M people. Why can’t Pennsylvania do this?
- kortilla 4y agoThe freedom of movement between states in the US makes this a challenge. States with better social safety nets end up attracting the low-income residents from other states.
- l33t233372 4y agoThere is free movement between countries in Europe. I suppose there are generally some language barriers, but to me the situation seems fundamentally the same.
- dmoy 4y agoBut is there freedom of access to social systems? https://ind.nl/en/consequences-for-right-of-residence-when-applying-for-public-funds#benefits-for-eu-eea-and-swiss-citizens-and-their-family-members https://ind.nl/en/consequences-for-right-of-residence-when-a...
- kortilla 4y agoNope, the countries put up significant barriers to access social safety nets (permanent residency durations, proof of working during time before that, etc). In the US you can generally establish residency in a different state in the amount of time it takes to get a USPS change of address notice and a billing statement of some sort showing that you’re able to receive mail there.
- AdrianB1 4y agoNo, there is only a limited the freedom of travel between countries in EU (not Europe), but not of movement. For many years people from the newly admitted countries in EU had no right to work in the rest of EU. Most of the diplomas are not automatically valid in other countries and in some cases, not at all - example: pilot license for light planes, I have a Romanian license and I can fly in Greece a plane registered in Romania, but not a plane registered in Greece. If I switch to a Greek license, with training and exams, I am not allowed to fly Romanian planes :(
- red-iron-pine 4y agoVery different systems, very different safety nets, and non-trivial language barriers. Yeah you can move wherever but you're not eligible for benefits, and the hiring managers want to know you speak fluent $LANGUAGE and have the right certifications from whatever credentialing system exists there. Common currency and regulatory standards, but it's not like you're just moving from Spain to Poland, at least not without serious hurdles.
- nukeman 4y agoIn fact, bureaucracy benefits from economies of scale. You can only get so small (population wise) before you can’t shrink the number of bureaucrats any further.
- sokoloff 4y agoGovernment might scale, but people's willingness to give up their own resources to help someone else does not scale indefinitely. As an extreme example, I'm much more willing to help my immediate family than my extended family and I suspect the same is true for most people. That same property extends to being more willing to pay for my local schools than for struggling schools 1300 miles away in Mississippi or being more willing to pay for support for a homeless person that I can see and interact with than to pay that same amount for one hundreds or thousands of miles away.
- pipodeclown 4y agoYou could easily solve that by having social/redistributions measure on a municipality/state level... The Netherlands is also part of the EU, very little social welfare measures are effectuated through the EU, most of that happens on a state level.
- dml2135 4y agoIf it's so easy to solve for, why hasn't it happened already?
- Zaiberia 4y agoBecause the US is no longer a full democracy, and the government mainly represents corporations rather than its citizens?
- themaninthedark 4y agoThe Us has never been a democracy, it has always been a (democratic)republic.
- Retric 4y agoIt started as a democratic republic but it isn’t currently a democratic republic.
- coredog64 4y agoDiseconomy of scale is a thing.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI am not buying the assertion at face value. The bigger the government is, the harder it is to scale it. Like any bureaucracy, it quickly gains its own life, customs and belief systems. If anything, the reason small d democracy works is because the government is local, everyone is participating and invested in outcome.
- Retric 4y agoThe absolute worst case is you break it into independent entities the way US cities operate, larger scales can help solve problems but you don’t need to operate on them.
- chmod600 4y agoDoes it? People complain a lot about Congress, and a lot of those problems are reasonably connected to size. More likely, there are a benefits and costs to a large government. I doubt it's scale-free.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoNo. Leadership very much does not scale linearly. It gets more expensive the bigger you get. Look at all the process at BigCo vs the lean startup. Government also has to deal with all those tradeoffs inherent to people managing.
- jimbob45 4y agoThis is the kind of response that makes back-end devs fume. "Why is our website going down with 100x the users we had last week? You guys must have built it incorrectly.".