4 ms·
That depends. People are in poverty for many different reasons. I know people in poverty where the root cause is downs syndrome: they mentally don't have the a
by bluGill 4y ago
That depends. People are in poverty for many different reasons.
I know people in poverty where the root cause is downs syndrome: they mentally don't have the ability to be any more than assistant usher at the movie theater. They can handle most usher tasks, but when there is someone difficult they need the head usher: some 16 year old kid who has been on the job for at least 2 weeks.
I know people in poverty because they despite getting straight A's in school they dropped out at 16 and started having kids (I'm not sure if they dropped out before are after the kids started coming, it doesn't matter: both dropping out and having kids were intentional decisions). 10 years latter it finally occurred to them how much their bad life choices has hurt them.
There is nothing a coach can do to help the first person, no matter what they will still be in poverty as they are not capable of doing better. The second just needs a bit of help to turn life around - this help will work now, but at 21 this person would have refused all help as they didn't see that they were doing anything wrong in the first place. Most people in poverty are somewhere in the middle of these two.
The above is based on real people (though I'm hiding a lot of details for privacy reasons). These are not strawman examples, but they should feel like it. I intentionally picked people who are on the two far ends of the extremes.
- sofixa 4y agoPerson 1 doesn't have to be in poverty, in most developed countries there would be disability help/insurance/payments/etc. to help them live a non-impoverished life because they cannot realistically work a job.
- retrac 4y agoIn most developed countries, disability payments mean living in significant, often crippling poverty. Here in Canada, a single disabled person that is expected to live independently receives about 800 USD per month from the government. Out of that, they're expected to pay all their expenses. Canada is relatively typical as such things go. In France or Germany it's about 1000 USD a month. It's about 900 USD in the United States. It's only some 300 - 500 USD in the UK. Depending on jurisdiction, there may or may not be subsidized housing which can make a big difference; but either way, many are paying market rate for housing. There are also other benefits, etc., that may alter the picture. But the overall picture is very very poor. The Scandinavian countries are the only major exception I can think of, where the disabled living only on a government pension might not actually be in poverty.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoYeah people Canada have been wondering where this explosion of homelessness has come from, well, when you look at the amounts that minimum income provides, in an environment of exploding rents, it's state sanctioned poverty.
- bluGill 4y agoPayments just mean someone will defraud the person in question. Even if we assume no fraud, this person is still the bottom of society.