3 ms·
It's true that somehow C++ programmers rationalise completely new programming languages with incompatible syntax every three years as "stable" and Rust's stabil
by tialaramex 4y ago
It's true that somehow C++ programmers rationalise completely new programming languages with incompatible syntax every three years as "stable" and Rust's stability as "unstable" but turns out that the people actually developing it don't agree with you that just changing everything would somehow make it "settle".
- pjmlp 4y agoThat stability comes in a dead trees tome that everyone should certify their compilers against.
- iknowstuff 4y agoNah, this is not a universal truth.
- tialaramex 4y ago> That stability comes in a dead trees tome No such "dead trees tome" exists. ISO will explicitly point out that what you're spending an eye-watering sum of money on is just a PDF. Some of the National Bodies will tell you that you can buy this document on paper, but what they're actually doing is contracting out to a local Print On Demand service which either didn't tell them it has a document size limit or they didn't listen. If you splash out anyway eventually what you'll get in the post, instead of your imaginary tome is a CD with the PDF on it. > that everyone should certify their compilers against. Try for a moment to imagine that all the GCC and Clang volunteers own legal copies of the actual ISO document. Now, stop laughing and read. Nobody cares about the actual document, in 1998 there really were academic libraries who bought C++ 98, and they might still have C++ 98, but that's a 25 year old document. Today those libraries would tell an interested user, "I'm pretty sure this is online, go away and search" and they'd be correct. Because it's a PDF not a paper document, ISO C++ is a moving target, what's stable about that? One of the few things about C++ that I unambiguously admire is std::format() introduced in C++ 20 -- but actually the most important feature of std::format() wasn't in the published C++ 20 ISO document, it's an erratum, pasted in much later because it's obviously needed.
- pjmlp 4y agoPlenty of industries care, that is why Ferroceone wants to make it possible for such industries to also care for Rust. ISO C++ is only a moving target if one ignores that there is an industry that certifies compilers for specific standard versions. I imagine a few people at Red-Hat, or the dozens of compiler vendors that take advantage of upstream work in clang can afford a couple of copies of the standard. After all, they have circa 40 years of experience doing so since ISO/ANSI C89 was released.
- tialaramex 4y ago> ISO C++ is only a moving target if one ignores that there is an industry that certifies compilers for specific standard versions. That's what is so funny. You can indeed get the rubber stamp, and it's worthless. Have you watched that scene in "The Big Short" where FrontPoint goes to the ratings agency and basically gets told the agency knows these products are bullshit, but they don't make money unless they say it's good so that's what they do ? Turns out a "ratings agency" wasn't legally promising anything at all, they existed solely because people felt like if someone else says it's good, even if they were paid to say so, well it must be good. Hilarious. But that doesn't matter because nobody wants a C++ 20 compiler which does what the ISO Document published in 2020 says anyway, because that's bad you want a compiler which does what the current document now says about C++ 20. It's a moving target. And I doubt very much that the "dozens of vendors" have even stayed awake long enough to read much of the readily available and up-to-date "draft" document, much less that they insisted their employer spend actual money on the useless and perpetually out of date official ISO document. It's not a great piece of technical writing.
- pjmlp 4y agoSee, this is the kind of atittude that puts off many C++ devs out of hearing about Rust. A reply quite fitting of the whole RIIR folks.