4 ms·
> subscription service that lets you verify your account with a government ID In this scenario, government ID is like a taxpayer-funded "Layer 1" network that
by walterbell 4y ago
> subscription service that lets you verify your account with a government ID
In this scenario, government ID is like a taxpayer-funded "Layer 1" network that does all the heavy lifting, so that a "Layer 2" network can extract rent for storing a single bit that never changes between initial verification and kill switch/glitch invocation.
Should governments impose a tax or monetization limits on corporate citation of government ID?
Should governments compete with corporate ID verification services?
In blockchain context, https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1626299802156769280.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1626299802156769280.html
Centralizing power always has predictable outcomes
Corporate x2
1. Rent-seeking (aka they will capture some of the networks effects $$$$)
2. Less innovation (they will block competitors)
Political x1
1. Power. Raw unlimited power. The person in control of those databases is a God
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoWait what? Why? The purpose of having governments isn't to extract money from private activity. The purpose is to enable privacy activity to be efficient by providing a baseline level of services that would be difficult or inefficient to produce privately. Having reliable ID provides benefits to many private individuals and corporations, and their economic activity results in taxes that fund the government (likely far in excess of the costs of providing such an ID service).
- cormacrelf 4y agoI pay the equivalent of USD $420 every ten years to have government-issued ID. Facebook wants to charge me $12 a month, for them to look at this ID once. That is $1440 over 10 years. The two services offered are pretty similar: check it once, issue a stamp of approval, then administer that system over time. Why is Facebook's service 3.5x the price?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> two services offered are pretty similar: check it once, issue a stamp of approval, then administer that system over time One, Facebook is obviously providing you with a service. Two, your solution to not liking the price of something is to tax it? What?
- cormacrelf 4y agoDid you read what I said? I said both of them provided similar services.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> both of them provided similar services Last I checked, the DMV doesn't have a social media arm. You're thinking of identity verification as product. That's obviously not what Facebook is selling.
- saurik 4y agoFacebook isn't charging for their various social media services, they are charging for the ID verification service.
- remus 4y ago> Facebook wants to charge me $12 a month, for them to look at this ID once. Your $12/month also covers access to a support service. I guess that's what you're actually paying for.
- rcoveson 4y agoThis is a joke, right? Sure the DMV/DLD sucks, but is a Facebook support line to some minimum wage call center really going to suck less?
- Fernicia 4y agoWhy all this catastrophising over verifying with a government ID? It works well for flying places, collecting post, registering visitors, so why not this. The rent extraction argument sounds preposterous. Should a bouncer have to pay compensation to the government if he uses a driving license to make sure his clientele are of age?
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoThe government works for us (the people, as well as businesses owned by people). We already pay for government services in the form of taxes. If anything, government services should generally be free (we do make some exceptions for use fees to avoid free rider problems and general waste, but we would balk at very high fees).
- walterbell 4y ago> Should a bouncer have to pay compensation to the government if he uses a driving license to make sure his clientele are of age? Is the bouncer selling $12/month Bouncer-Verified ID that can be read by a computer instead of the bouncer? Should every online and offline establishment sell "Verified ID" subscription/membership services? https://twitter.com/cryptolawrev/status/1627399591313264641 https://twitter.com/cryptolawrev/status/1627399591313264641 Step 1: charge for govID (premiumfi it) Step 2: make govID freemium Step 3: drop the pretense & de facto req govID Bonus Step: blame the govID req on Ey Ay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Strategy_for_Trusted_Identities_in_Cyberspace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Strategy_for_Trusted_... > The National Strategy for Trusted Identities in Cyberspace (NSTIC) is a US government initiative announced in April 2011 to improve the privacy, security and convenience of sensitive online transactions through collaborative efforts with the private sector, advocacy groups, government agencies, and other organizations. The strategy imagined an online environment where individuals and organizations can trust each other because they identify and authenticate their digital identities and the digital identities of organizations and devices. With programmable money (CBDC) proposed by multiple countries and draft EU/UK/US regulations to impose criminal liability and mandatory audits on developers of "critical software" like operating systems, there aren't many hurdles remaining for dystopian unification of offline and online identity, e.g. after a hypothetical "cyber" crisis.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoYou aren't using the term 'rent seeking' correctly. Rent seeking is manipulating government policy to extract profit, in the absence of any actual benefit. For example, paying lobbyists to convince the government to give your industry a subsidy. Rent seeking doesn't mean 'capturing profit', that's just normal economic activity.
- bugbuddy 4y agoSo you mean everything that was in the “Inflation “Reduction” Act”