2 ms·
Yes, the idea is more complex. "Vastly?" I think not. Nor are your attempts at analogy there at all persuasive. You are vigorously handwaving and arguing by
by pfdietz 4y ago
Yes, the idea is more complex. "Vastly?" I think not. Nor are your attempts at analogy there at all persuasive. You are vigorously handwaving and arguing by bald assertion.
Your objection to ME handwaving is obtuse. I am not the one claiming it is impossible. I don't have to show all possible ways it might be done don't work. Don't resort to the usual crank attempt of defending your initial claim by insisting I disprove it. You are obligated to explain in detail why the idea can't work. I don't think you can, your huffing and puffing notwithstanding.
I think you could become more persuasive if you retreated to a time limited claim, say the next 30 years. The best argument would not be complexity, but rather the cost of the orbital lasers.
- _hypx 4y agoAnd what are you doing, but vigorous handwaving about how it is actually possible? Make a working version of it, or point to someone making it work. So far it is nothing but a paper concept. Again, no one is saying it is impossible. It is merely incredibly implausible and won't happen. You can pretty much pick an arbitrary timeframe on this. If you want 30 years, I'll give 30 years. It won't happen in that timeframe.