3 ms·
When it comes to formal instruction, an important element is tutoring. Some do all of their formal learning this way (such as John Stuart Mill), others have it
by paulpauper 4y ago
When it comes to formal instruction, an important element is tutoring. Some do all of their formal learning this way (such as John Stuart Mill), others have it as a complement to schooling (such as Albert Einstein, who had a number of math-focused tutors outside of school). Erik Hoel, who has written a series of great essays about why we stopped making Einsteins (here, here, and here), singled out “aristocratic tutoring” as the most important factor. (In this term, Erik includes not only tutoring, in its classical sense, but also more casual interactions between children and competent adults.)
If I had to guess, the reason is much of the low hanging fruit has been picked. Progress is much more incremental and hard, building on a huge body of technical existing literature. Being the next Einstein means you have to learn everything Einstein knew, plus another 100 years on top of that. Tons of papers on arXiv to go through. Lots of dense math.
- readthenotes1 4y agoDid not Einstein win his Nobel prize for explaining Brownian motion in classical Newtonian physics? That is, did he not also have to master the existing material of the day using the woeful tools of the late 19th and earliest 20th century? He had neither the internet nor Anki cards to help him learn anything. I do not think the problem is one of low-hanging fruit
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Kranar 4y agoTechnically, Einstein won the Nobel prize for "his services to theoretical physics and especially the photoelectric effect", but in actuality he won it for his work on relativity. The reason the Nobel committee did not just give him the award for relativity was because until 1919, there was no way to experimentally verify relativity theory, and then in 1919 when it was experimentally verified, there was a significant increase in anti-semitism following the end of the first World War and a great deal of hesitation to award it to Einstein for what was considered an incredibly complex theory that few people could understand. Because of that, a compromise was reached, and Einstein would receive a deferred award for the photoelectric effect, which was much less contentious. But everyone understood that Einstein had won the award for his work on relativity.
- physPop 4y agoI've never heard this before -- do you have a reputable source?
- adastra22 4y agoHe does not because it is not true. Einstein won his Nobel for his explanation of the photoelectric effect, which experimentally confirmed quantum theory. Quantum theory has been waaaaay more impactful than relativity, then and now.
- ip26 4y agoIt is pretty interesting to theorize whether a new personality might rise in an age where new discoveries require ever more learning and perhaps more collaboration. A shift from the blindingly brilliant recluse to the equal-parts diligent-and-brilliant team player, perhaps? More Manhattan Project, less Walden. This would of course be uneven, depending on the maturity of the field.
- DoingIsLearning 4y ago> Erik Hoel, who has written a series of great essays about why we stopped making Einsteins Have we stopped though? Not to put living people on a pedestal but people like Terence Tao come to mind.