4 ms·
(I've done a lot of Lisp, for money, and for open source platform&community buildout.) HN articles about exotic things, not just Lisp, do seem to get upvoted d
by neilv 4y ago
(I've done a lot of Lisp, for money, and for open source platform&community buildout.)
HN articles about exotic things, not just Lisp, do seem to get upvoted disproportionately.
Also, PG declared Lisp as something you're supposed to think is important or a superpower, and I've wondered whether that also contributes to some upvotes on HN.
But I'm not aware that a single one of the bajillion YC startups used Lisp.
Maybe it's like an admirable religious dogma that a congregation affirms each weekend, and then promptly forgets about for the rest of the week.
- jfoutz 4y agoreddit. they switched to python for various reasons.
- thebigspacefuck 4y agoThey’re switching to golang now for other various reasons
- lispnut 4y agoAny links to stories about them switching to golang I can follow?
- justcool393 4y agoso as far as i can tell it's not like a full switch per se but reddit has services written in both python and go. r2 (old reddit, the reddit API, some parts of new reddit, some of their ML stuff), their monolith, is still written in python. some services they have in go include some real time services (like the reddit talk stuff seems to be primarily written in go) reddit kinda seems to have a SOA (not microservices). while there are some codepaths that go through r2 (and indeed this seems to be the case in a lot of cases with regards to old reddit), a lot of newer code uses services. (note: their engineering blog (/r/RedditEng) calls a lot of their stuff microservices and indeed they may be using that for some things but a lot of their stuff have been described as using more of a SOA vs a microservices.) someone like /u/ketralnis may have more information as well?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nextos 4y agoAs a counterexample, Clojure is pretty popular in some niches. I have received offers this year to join well-funded startups using Clojure. Datomic is great for some usecases. Clojure often leads the Stack Overflow survey in terms of salary.
- signa11 4y agoClojure often leads the Stack Overflow survey in terms of salary. wouldn't that also imply the classic demand and supply thingy ? the one that is alluded too in pg's articles...
- Hermitian909 4y agoMy impression is that the high salary is because Clojure it is primarily used for small-ish, fairly senior, highly technical teams writing high impact standalone services e.g. it's my understanding that a Walmart's route planning teams writes their service in Clojure. This actually meshes well with what you'd expect from a lisp being used well. Lisp's power and its downfall is that it lets you express abstraction at whatever skill level you're at with no built-in mechanisms to keep style consistent across large teams. This works really well for small teams of high powered developers.
- signa11 4y ago> This works really well for small teams of high powered developers. this is exactly right. i guess, a large part of the puzzle is to build one, and then leave them be...
- packetlost 4y agoLisp as a great tool for learning FP paradigms for application in other languages. IMO, in practice, the metaprogramming that Lisp encourages isn't very good good for the understandability of a codebase, which is IMO one of if not the most important factors for building an applications in a company.
- kazinator 4y agoThe objective test for whether Lisp metaprogramming contributes to or detracts from the readability of a codebase is to take a sample of the code base and expand the macros, to see whether that is more or less readable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- todd8 4y agoMacros provide abstractions that often make programs easier to understand. I myself have dozens of the usepackage macro in my Emacs configuration, they hide and standardize the boilerplate that I could use instead. Nevertheless, I have serious reservations about macros in programming. Taking a code base and expanding the macros to see whether that is more or less readable is a bit like expanding a C++ class hierarchy into assembly language and concluding that this program’s object oriented design is great because it is more readable than the resulting assembly language. The real question is whether or not there are better alternatives than macros or metaprogramming in the first place. Functions, especially as found in modern languages[1], have proven to be very useful abstraction mechanisms and can often mitigate the lack of fancy macros. I don’t want macros banned from Lisp, but I don’t miss them in other programming languages. Over exuberant use of fancy macros in Knuth’s brilliant TeX, in my opinion, contributes to the glacial pace of LaTeX development. [1] By this I mean functions with circumscribed access to non local variables, provisions for choices of ownership of parameters, static scoping, first class functions, closures, and recursion.
- packetlost 4y ago