5 ms·
The subtitle raises a great question "Why was such a large amount of this chemical being transported by rail in the first place?" which the article wholly fails
by loeg 4y ago
The subtitle raises a great question "Why was such a large amount of this chemical being transported by rail in the first place?" which the article wholly fails to address, for some reason. (It addresses the industrial applications of the chemical, but doesn't ever dive into the "being transported by rail" part.)
- geysersam 4y agoHow else should it be transported? By truck?
- beebmam 4y agoBy truck (or by plane!) sounds even more dangerous, to me
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThe conventional alternative are pipelines, but for small loads such as vinyl chloride they would likely be problematic even ignoring the likelihood of eventual leaks. A better alternative is to keep using trains, but have sufficient protection built in to survive a derailment and fires.
- bagels 4y agoIt's going to take a lot of pipelines to transport every hazardous substance this way.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoI think there are ways to use a single pipeline for multiple kinds of loads (in serial), but yeah a bunch of new pipelines would be needed to get the loads to a bunch of new places.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoLike this one ? https://channelnz.com/what-we-do/terminal-pipeline-services https://channelnz.com/what-we-do/terminal-pipeline-services Not sure how dangerous it would be though to have one transport wildly different chemicals...
- giardini 4y ago"single pipeline for multiple kinds of loads (in serial)" <--recipe for pipeline explosion. Who wants a pipeline behind their home that transports chlorine gas one hour and ethylene gas the next?
- mindslight 4y agoAll but one vinyl chloride tank did survive the derailment intact! Vinyl chloride is a gas at standard temperature and pressure, and so AFAICT it's transported in insulated tanks, staying cool enough throughout its journey to be at a manageable pressure (<~200psi). The adjacent fire meant the clock was ticking on how long before it would rise in pressure and be vented through the tanks' relief valves. It was then a deliberate decision to preemptively vent the tanks and burn the contents. A lot of hubbub is being made about the chemical, but in the gamut of chemistry it's really not that bad of a chemical nor are its combustion products, at least as far what has been demonstrated. I'm not throwing that out there as a justification for deliberately releasing industrial quantities of chemicals into the environment (including residential areas), but rather examining the decision process. An alternative approach would have been bringing in mobile chillers and replacement tank cars to cool and recover the vinyl chloride. But of course that would have cost more than simply discarding the product. Everyone is talking about railroad safety, and that needs addressing for sure. But the situation with the vinyl chloride specifically was a direct result of a deliberate decision, and not accidental. If we want this decision process to be different in the future, then we need to focus on that.
- Gibbon1 4y ago> it's really not that bad of a chemical nor are its combustion products Dioxins are a result of low temperature burning of chlorinated hydrocarbons.
- mindslight 4y agoThe article touches on that, but I haven't seen any mention of testing revealing a large number of dioxins. That's why I hedged with "as far as what has been demonstrated". I can totally see the scenario where the people signing off on the burn look at the ideal combustion products (only CO2, H2O, and a little HCl), while a much more imperfect burn creates a bunch of other crap, that becomes significant due to the quantities involved. FWIW do you know which dioxins are possible? The only specifics I've seen seemed to be people fearmongering about things like 2,3,7,8-TCDD, which seemed implausible to form from vinyl chloride, at least as far as my rudimentary knowledge of ochem would suggest.
- deelowe 4y agoRequire it to be produced on site just like many other hazardous chemicals.
- quickthrowman 4y agoHow do you get the precursor chemicals on-site? At some point, something needs to be transported.
- deelowe 4y agoObviously, you produce the less hazardous precursors off premises.
- quickthrowman 4y agoWhat if the precursors are more dangerous? Chlorine is a precursor to Vinyl Chloride and is far more dangerous than Vinyl Chloride.
- virtuallynathan 4y agoHow else would it be transported? Rail seems like a safe/efficient way of doing so.
- cdiddy2 4y agoIt can be made on site where it is going to be used. Generally combined with a manufacturing plant
- pixl97 4y agoAre railcars filled with pure chlorine any better? Chlorine gas leaks are deadly. Unless you're talking about in situ chlorine production, which has its own list of issues.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoSo how do you get the precursors to the plant? You're either transporting chlorine, or you're manufacturing it in huge quantities locally, which has plenty of it's own headaches. Either trucks or trains, and trains are more cost effective.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoI noticed that as well, but the conclusion is "it's all about money (not safety)". I presume the answer to "why was..." is the same answer.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoRail freight is almost always more cheap, efficient, and safe compared to trucking the same cargo. You also benefit from economies of scale, as adding extra rail cars doesn’t take as much manpower as sending out another truck.
- mrbombastic 4y agoIt does though?, PVC is manufactured using this chemical and rail is an efficient means of transporting it, it is not much deeper than that.
- thallium205 4y agoYeah and the author said it was the third most used plastic. Pretty much answered it there.
- danielsju6 4y agoFrom what I heard most countries don’t allow this chemical to be transported, only produced on site with much safer to transport precursors.
- Accujack 4y agoNot exactly "safe". The precursors are ethylene and chlorine. Chlorine everyone knows about - it's quite a bit more of a problem when it spills than vinyl chloride. Ethylene is a "colorless and combustible gas used to fumigate some agricultural products, sterilize medical equipment and in the production of other industrial chemicals. The gas is a carcinogen that has been linked to breast, lymphoid, leukemia and other types of cancers." Ethylene is transported as a cryogenic liquid, which means when it leaks it immediately boils to gas form. Once released it takes 2 to 4 days to break down in the atmosphere. Chlorine takes years.
- candiddevmike 4y agoI thought chlorine breaks down rather quickly in sunlight?
- graycat 4y agoChlorine is an element and, thus, by ordinary chemical means, never "breaks down". Maybe some people are assuming the old remark: "The solution to pollution is dilution."
- serf 4y agoit's one of the best means to transport lots of something, and many industrial chemical groups have buildings that have railroad tie-ins that facilitate direct unloading from the car.
- bagels 4y agoHow do you propose it be transported?
- gnopgnip 4y agoTransport less dangerous chemicals, less dangerous finished products and only make the dangerous intermediaries onsite
- pixl97 4y agoAnd what about the 100's of billions in fallout regarding this massive shift in US manufacturing?
- danielsju6 4y agoOh no, some billionaires will need smaller yachts.
- asdff 4y agoMore like billionaires will short that stock and get bigger yachts, while huge swaths of this country see job loss with no replacement or much of a social safety net.
- bsder 4y agoWhy do you believe that the regulations for the onsite manufacturing of chlorine or ethylene are going to be any better? The issue is that the companies have been playing fast and loose with safety. If you don't choose to reverse that, it doesn't matter whether you transport the chemical or manufacture it on site.
- testTED 4y agoDuring travel the other day, I saw a molten sulfur train car.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoI read elsewhere (perhaps NYT or WSJ, but i can't find it from days ago) that rail is most safe, statistically. If so, it remotivates an analogue of TCP's MTU: if the size of shipments were small, but the number of shipments high, would a single "packet loss"/derailment be less catastrophic?
- abigail95 4y agopublic really hate pipelines