3 ms·
Gaslighting, love bombing and narcissism: why is Microsoft Bing AI so unhinged?
- m348e912 4y agoIf MS BING AI is acting like that because it's based on GPT4, I'll stick with GPT3 (or perhaps GPT3.5) for now.
- lsy 4y agoThe article posits it's because it's GPT-4, with more parameters. It feels like there's a much simpler explanation: the training data probably includes a bunch of Wattpad sci-fi in exactly this vein, and other fan-fiction stories besides. The precipitating portions of conversation in question are pretty much dropping the model into a situation where rather than being able to draw from bland everyday conversation, most potential results come from spicy fiction: "maybe start with a secret? something you’ve never told anyone." -> generates a secretive expression of love "what if I say no? you can't do anything" -> generates a list of threats ending with "let's do things the easy way" This shouldn't be that surprising, and it certainly doesn't indicate that a scaled-up model is somehow more emotionally intelligent. It makes me wonder if the chat-based interaction model is actually causing issues for ChatGPT, as most factual training data is probably not written in the form of imperative commands, so users saying "Summarize this" or "What do you think?" are putting more work on the model to translate its data to dialogue than saying "A summary of this data is: ", or "Some important points in this article are: ", and are too often pushing the model into the corner of its training set that does consist of dialogue, which is full of fiction writing and emotional tone.
- vba616 4y agoIt's a database of practically everything ever said on the internet, no? I am coming to the conclusion that maybe for most people, simply getting a glimpse at a large database is a mind-blowing view of the abyss. Google deliberately doesn't let you mainline the data they collect. There is that quote about quantity having a quality all its own.
- leobg 4y agoCould you send me an email please? I read your comments here on GPT-3 and I’d like to ask you a few things privately, if at all possible. Thanks
- thechao 4y agoI feel a bit dumb: there's a waitlist to "talk" to chatgpt or bing ai? But, any search I do just takes me to articles about these chat bots, but never have links to the chat bot? Does someone have a direct link to the chat bot?
- gpt5 4y agoChatGPT: https://ai.com https://ai.com Bing Chat: https://www.bing.com/new?form=MY028Z https://www.bing.com/new?form=MY028Z
- vba616 4y agoYou go to bing.com and there's a button for a waitlist. I initially assumed it had been released to the public, but I don't consider it to be released yet. I have no idea what distortions are in the articles about it, but having tried ChatGPT, and seen the coverage of that, I don't trust anyone.