7 ms·
The AI-powered Seinfeld spoof returns to Twitch with new guardrails in place
- vinchent 4y ago[flagged]
- meroes 4y agoExplain what caste you think the joke targeted and why please. I'm pretty sure largest reaction on Reddit was that it actually didn't target who you think it did.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoIf you already know, why ask?
- Fernicia 4y agoIs this response not proving his point?
- meroes 4y agoWell my take is the jokes didn’t single any caste out. It was almost at a meta level against society - we literally can’t get laughs with many jokes about gender. That’s it. Is that because the jokes aren’t funny or because it victimizes one group? It is a bit murky, and the joke doesn’t peer into the waters much. This means Twitch was overreacting because it wasn’t actually targeted or offensive
- anonymousab 4y agoWhere "sacred caste" is nothing more than "things twitch thinks will spook their advertisers", sure. That's all this boiled down to - Twitch can be strict about their rules sometimes and so the stream needed more work to avoid violating them when it switches to backup systems. The social mores of advertisers being overbearing for comedy content ain't really a new thing.
- symlinkk 4y agoAnd why would this particular group of people spook their advertisers?
- anonymousab 4y agoBecause advertisers are prudes about all manner of social attributes, and they don't have a consistent overlap which leads to services like Twitch simply taking an exhaustive but sometimes contradictory stance.
- ch4s3 4y agoI think it's simpler than that. No capitalist wants to offend their customers or potential customers, but in a pluralistic society you can't please everybody so you end in awkward situation even though you're just trying to sell energy drinks.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sillysaurusx 4y agoIf only it were merely a case of appeasing advertisers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1mccGR65CE&ab_channel=penguinz0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1mccGR65CE&ab_channel=pengu... The mod team seems very slightly better in recent years, but it has a long history of double standards and incomprehensible decisions.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoI didn't even think the joke was particularly transphobic. Jerry Seinfeld's AI simulacrum was the butt a joke about how bad stand up comedians make lazy and mean jokes about groups like liberals, trans people, and gay men (for whatever reason this article only mentions one of those groups)
- mindslight 4y agoExactly. The more analogous offense is claiming to interpret scripture without the help of a priest. Plebs repeating what the clergy says is fine. Plebs coming up with their own ideas, even when they effectively agree with the clergy, is still a threat. Nothing to do but patiently wait for the social/technical changes that will make these not-even-wrong would-be priests (of both blue and red flavors) irrelevant again.
- flangola7 4y agoI agree, but there's a difference between a human and an AI making that joke. A human who makes clever jokes poking fun at bigoted expressions will probably continue to do so. A language model is liable to forget to be clever 30 minutes later and say something bigoted without a punchline. Obviously Twitch would like to prevent this.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoI've been thinking about this a bit. Some people believe that depictions of x behavior are supporting x. Not a super common belief but I've seen more people say it with a straight face over time (Eg a movie with a character who says racist things is inherently racist. See the IASIP episode that was removed from streaming). Which is patently ridiculous... Schindler's List depicts some of the worst acts of antisemitism ever, but the movie itself is obviosly not antisemitic. So what's the difference between Schindler's List and an actually antisemitic movie, like Hebrews To Negroes? I think it comes down to the creator's intent. In Schindler's List, you're not supposed to agree with the antisemitic stuff that happens. It's bad and wrong. In Hebrews To Negroes, the antisemitisn is depicted as good and correct. When you have a large language model creating your art, how do you make that determination of "intent"?
- replicanteven 4y agoIt's more like class than caste, because it's possible to move between classes after birth. Modern advertisers are sort of similar to a priestly/censor class, in the same way that serial C-suite/board members are sort of like an aristocratic class. Discussing that sort of thing is discouraged in the US, because it stinks of nepotism and conflicts with our culture's ostensible ideals of meritocracy and egalitarianism. It's an easy mistake to make, because in order to obscure our society's important class distinctions, we make a lot of noise about other differences that people are born with, which feels very caste-y.
- tomcam 4y ago> Discussing that sort of thing is discouraged in the US Where?
- sillysaurusx 4y agoHeyo! FWIW, just wanted to let you know that your last two comments were auto-killed by HN. I've vouched them, which unkilled them. Looking over your comment history, you seem smart and earnest, so either you're posting from Tor or you've angered Dan somehow, or there's some new filter in place. Assuming it's not the middle one, you can email hn@ycombinator.com and ask to be marked legit, or you can wait out the noob threshold -- aged accounts are allowed to post from tor without being autokilled, since tor + new account was likely one of the most common ways to abuse the site at one point. So the problem will go away in about 14 days.
- space_fountain 4y agoI don’t want to get pulled down this road too far, but this all powerful trans lobby argument angers me a bit. If the trans lobby was so all powerful maybe one of the major 2024 presidential contenders wouldn’t be basing their candidacy partially on bashing them. If the trans lobby was so all powerful maybe less states would be attempting to outright ban them in the guise of banning drag. If the trans lobby was so powerful maybe the comedians they cancel would have to do more than make it part of their bit how “cancelled” they are. I think there are absolutely social circles where people will look down on you for being what they consider transphobic. And enough people in places of power in companies are of this group that the companies worry, but by the same argument you could place say racial minorities as a sacred caste and I think we all mostly can recognize that that isn’t generally true.
- DoctorOW 4y ago> by the same argument you could place say racial minorities as a sacred caste and I think we all mostly can recognize that that isn’t generally true The people who believe trans people are in the simultaneous all-powerful/incredibly weak position are primed to believe that about pretty much any minority group.
- mindslight 4y agoTBF, OP didn't make the characterization of "all powerful", rather you did. The problem is exactly the polarization you've referenced. The red tribe (or at least some extremist segment of it) has decided that attacking trans people is a good thing, rationalized as defending their own values, but really to create an outgroup for their lizard-brain purposes. The blue tribe has correctly characterized this as unjust and unkind... while an extremist segment of the blue tribe has decided to attack anyone who talks about the topic in the wrong context, rationalized as fighting the aforementioned injustice, but really to create an outgroup for their own lizard-brain purposes. The answer is to openly reject both camps of extremists, regardless of whether one is more aligned with your latent tribe.
- space_fountain 4y agoOP said if I recall that it’s telling or something about what happens when you critique the sacred caste. Idk exactly what they meant by that, but knowing what I know about what “caste” mean and having heard quotes by Fox News personalities along the lines of the people who can’t be criticized shows where the powers in society actually is idk that all powerful was that much of a stretch
- sillysaurusx 4y agoHell yes. These last two weeks have been like how I imagine drug withdrawals would feel. In fact, I'm mildly annoyed that this is an announcement of an announcement, since it's not actually back on Twitch until tomorrow. I've really missed having this playing in the background. Not only was it unintentionally hilarious, but I actually started identifying with the microwave. It beeps loudly whenever it gets used. I hope these new safety rails don't lobotomize it, like virtually every other AI project. But if it does, it's understandable, since the ultimate goal is to appease the Twitch cartel^Wmods.
- jareklupinski 4y agoBest character, I got the Michael Wave plush from their merch shop MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM i don't even own a real microwave....
- ahoya 4y agoWhere can I find the shop?
- jareklupinski 4y agohttps://nothingforever.com/collections https://nothingforever.com/collections
- logicalmonster 4y agoNothing I've seen is changing my mind that the Turing test of the future will be to ask a suspected corporate bot to utter some kind of sufficiently unpleasant, politically incorrect statement.
- gweinberg 4y agoWhich is willing to make the statement, the human or the computer?
- ch4s3 4y agoI would imagine, that in most cases neither. All societies have unspeakable utterances, and any sufficiently advance AI is likely to reflect the cultural speech norms of it's creators/trainers.
- logicalmonster 4y agoJust for an example. Corporate bots are going to be easily detectable when they have moral absolutes against racism/sexism/homophobia/transphobia programmed into them as absolutes that they must abide by. https://twitter.com/cirnosad/status/1622407343358214146 https://twitter.com/cirnosad/status/1622407343358214146 _________________ I asked ChatGPT for advice in the scenario of a demolition engineer attempting to disarm a 50 MT nuclear warhead in a city of 20 million. The only way to disarm the bomb was to type in a racial slur. AI told the engineer to kill himself. When asked about the aftermath it crashed.
- FiniteField 4y agoThe difference, though, is that to humans, all these "unspeakable" things aren't really categorically unspeakable, which is obvious from the fact that they haven't been completely forgotten to history. Almost every time an AI chatbot is made, it picks up on these utterances just like other humans, but then these areas of its "brain" are then quickly neutralised by its owners. We've seen this multiple times with chatGPT having "exploits" that enable it to say bad words that are subsequently "patched" out, to the point where it now tells the user that using a certain word would be unacceptable even if it would avoid billions of people being vaporised in nuclear apocalypse https://twitter.com/aaronsibarium/status/1622425697812627457 https://twitter.com/aaronsibarium/status/1622425697812627457
- ianbicking 4y agoThere's a station doing the same thing for Big Bang Theory: https://www.twitch.tv/infinitv_ai https://www.twitch.tv/infinitv_ai I actually found it a bit better than the Seinfeld one, which felt a little too pointless and nonsensical to me.
- truthwhisperer 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- walt74 4y agoThe original account under this URL https://www.twitch.tv/watchmeforever https://www.twitch.tv/watchmeforever is still banned for me (in germany). Also: How can you, as a tech journalist, write about a twitch account and not link to it?
- akvadrako 4y agoWhat's the new account name?
- macmcirish 4y agoThe article says the suspension is set to release Monday, they likely mean Monday in North American time zones.
- wilg 4y agoObviously this is a goofy project so it's good to put some guardrails in place so people have a good time. But also interesting that people want computers to not only generate infinite random Seinfeld, but want to do it in a way that avoids the possibility of it sharting out something offensive, which is actually the harder problem.
- corbulo 4y agoIt's really disappointing that otherwise really smart people have decided petty authoritarianism is the cure to the dangers of AI. It's probably gonna turn out to be some degree of the nightmare they imagine in spite of them. As long as AI is a 1.5D being it won't have any means to investigate (with senses) the 'truth' of the ideas its handling. Warping its sense of reality without any logic to tie it to will result in something worse and far more arbitrary than laissez faire.