2 ms·
Idea: Prosecute such companies for obtaining money under false pretenses. If you only get the thingie which you "bought" for a limited time - that is clearly
by bell-cot 4y ago
Idea: Prosecute such companies for obtaining money under false pretenses. If you only get the thingie which you "bought" for a limited time - that is clearly a rental, not a sale.
- themitigating 4y agoSo if ford stops making spare parts 30 years after a car was discontinued is the car rented?
- belorn 4y agoIf the car has drm in it that refuses alternative third-party parts, then yes, the car was rented. This is why right to repair laws are needed. It fixes this missrepresentation.
- shkkmo 4y agoIf they take steps to prohibit other people from making their own parts, then yes.
- Forge36 4y agoThis is more like if BMW stops supporting their servers so they disable your heated seats.
- LocalH 4y agoBad analogy. There's a difference between that, where the hypothetical car in question has malfunctioned, and a company being able to just decide that a feature that they offered across the board for free is suddenly being discontinued. Imagine that you have a Ford that comes with seat heaters. You've been able to use those seat heaters, at no additional charge, for several years. All of a sudden, Ford decides they want to make existing customers pay for something they've been using for years. The next time you go to the dealer for an unrelated reason, they silently install Ford's new update that restricts you from turning on the seat heaters without paying a monthly subscription to Ford. Even this analogy breaks down, as with the Arlo situation they have to provide server-side storage for the feature, whereas such a seat heater conundrum would not. However, this analogy is closer to the real situation than "manufacturer stops making parts three decades after discontinuation".
- spacephysics 4y agoIt’s tough because what if the company doesn’t want to maintain the software? Are they obligated to keep the software up to date despite the one-time-sale? It’s a similar reason why much of the software moved to a subscription model, the recurring costs. Alternatively, there should be some group of smart individuals who come up with some protocol for various devices where, if a manufacturer decides to EoL the sale (specifically saying not a rental), of a product, then they must switch to that protocol. But after their hands are clean. This issue sucks on many levels, one of which is someone like myself, and many others here, want the convenience of say smart home products. For instance, with Nest, due to their mothership and proprietary API’s, I have to settle for either an inferior product, or spend time setting up a home automation stack. Which is great if it’s a hobby and/or enjoyable, but I just want the features without the hassle. The real open source revolution will come when many of these privacy-first, host-your-own XYZ are truely turn key. I think we’re getting closer but just not their yet
- fsflover 4y ago> Are they obligated to keep the software up to date despite the one-time-sale? No. But they also should have no right to stop others from supporting the software: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34858209 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34858209.
- adrianN 4y agoNo, they don't need to keep the software up to date, they just have to ensure that the device continues working. Almost everything that uses electricity has a bit of software. Most devices don't need any updates. At the very least they need to enable somebody else to keep the devices running, for example by open sourcing the infra needed to do so.
- RobotToaster 4y ago>Are they obligated to keep the software up to date despite the one-time-sale? If it's a security issue, then it was sold defective.
- JohnFen 4y ago> It’s a similar reason why much of the software moved to a subscription model, the recurring costs. That reasoning doesn't make sense for this case, either.