5 ms·
Words ‘created the internet.’ Now the Supreme Court may be coming for them
- afinlayson 4y agoMaybe we need people who use the internet to make rules for the internet. Stop electing people who want to turn back the clock.
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoFor a country that claims to uphold free speech as a core value, both Republicans and Democrats seem to only want a society where viewpoints that have been approved by some kind of authority are allowed. However, sadly, this isn't unexpected — governments all around the world are trying to restrict UGC or only allow it when the identity of the poster is verified. Can't let the serfs think out loud, lest it put the elite in jeopardy.
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoHere's the difference though: If the algorithms weren't politically biased... - The conservatives would be happy - The liberals would be unhappy Conservatives' whole argument isn't "bad things I don't like on the internet" (that's the liberal argument), their argument is "the rules are rigged against my views". The conservative position is free speech. The Twitter execs were just getting grilled in congress last week and all the conservative questions were "why were you rigging the rules against conservatives ie "trans ideology" written into the rules, emails where you suppressed content in accordance with FBI requests, etc Meanwhile the liberals questions were: "why didn't you ban this conservative account? or this other conservative account? or this other one?". Only 1 side here wants to ban accounts for their political views. The other just wants LESS restrictions on speech.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoWell this is a thought-terminating comment if I've ever seen one... Remind me, again, who is banning books? Both parties in the US are awfully selective about when they will and won't support "free speech" as you seem to define it. How about we focus on the actual issues rather than devolving to US team sport politics? Edit: and incidentally the original comment was equally thought-terminating. But, why have a substantive discussion when you can go for easy polemics.
- kevviiinn 4y agoWhat's funny is thinking about the logical endpoint of this argument: >Conservatives' whole argument isn't "bad things I don't like on the internet" (that's the liberal argument), their argument is "the rules are rigged against my views". If the liberal rules are "no bad things on the internet" and the rules are rigged against conservative opinions. What does that make conservative opinions?
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoIt makes them things that liberals think are bad. Likewise, conservatives think liberal opinions are bad. The problem is exactly your comment: liberal opinions are not the same thing as the truth. So just because some liberal doesn't like your opinion (thinks its bad) doesn't mean you deserve to be deplatformed. There's no gotcha there with the logical endpoint.
- kevviiinn 4y agoWhat about when the message encourages radical violence? Messages from ISIS et al. get deplatformed but not those who encourage right wing US domestic terrorism such as Ben Shapiro or Steven Crowder? Also no, there aren't any left wing domestic terrorist organizations similar to the proud boys or boogaloo boys. There also haven't been left wing mass shooters as far as I'm aware. There may be one or two but it's far from the majority. Numerous shooters have cited far right political ideology in their writings. Seems suspicious to me, I don't think right wing voices are actually getting silenced. The opposite in fact. >In six out of seven countries — all but Germany — Tweets posted by accounts from the political right receive more algorithmic amplification than the political left when studied as a group. https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2021/rml-politicalcontent https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2021/rml-polit... https://www.theverge.com/2021/10/22/22740703/twitter-algorithm-right-wing-amplification-study https://www.theverge.com/2021/10/22/22740703/twitter-algorit... So what does this all say about which ideas are more harmful? What does it say about who is actually getting silenced? The right wing media seems to love playing the victim.
- edmundsauto 4y agoFree speech has always been a red herring, as the US (in its more religious days) had laws against heresy, lewdness, and anything that didn't reflect the puritanical values of the time. Pornography is a great example, but it's not just about sex - in the 1990s, there was a push to amend the Constitution to ban burning the flag. Like all things, the pros and cons have to be balanced. Speech impacts people, whether turning them into modern Nazis or perverted fornicators.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoThere is a legitimately important debate in one specific area of section 230: the treatment of algorithms. Section 230 is predicated on the idea that sites like HN have no editorial function and therefore have no liability over posted content. This safe harbor is extremely important and needs to be protected. Unfortunately algorithmic recommendation makes that line very grey. As a compromise I'd push for algorithmic transparency: show me how you're ranking content. This would both clarify whether companies are engaging in deliberate editorial activities via algorithm (and therefore should be held liable for the content they promote) while also improving both user privacy (we'd be able to see how our data is being used) and online trust.
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoHN has multiple algorithms to prevent sink controversial topics and the like, and the removal of "How", "X ways" etc. could also be seen as editorialization. I honestly don't see a way to balance the two interests, unless a voluntary opt-out to the algorithm (such as HN's /new) also suffices to comply with the new law.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoYou missed my point: show me the algorithm. You just described how you think HN works but unless you work there you can't have first hand knowledge. I know I don't. So show me the algorithm. Let's have an open conversation based on facts instead of speculation. As an aside, I also think the lines are easier drawn than you think. For example: is the algorithm based purely on overt signals from the userbase (votes, flags, etc)? Or is it based on an analysis of the content itself, which is then used to fuel a recommendation engine? If the latter, are the recommendations based purely on analyzing past expressed preference? Or is there some other baked in weighting? Algorithms aren't dark mysterious things. They're entirely explainable, and if opened up you could have a real discussion about what is and isn't editorial promotion of content.
- judahmeek 4y agoA lot of content moderation / censorship isn't by algorithm. Recommendations, sure, but not the removal of content.