3 ms·
Weren't the predictions in the 80s largely accurate? As I recall the only big miss was shale oil [0] and if it follows a bell curve then the sharp initial spike
by roenxi 4y ago
Weren't the predictions in the 80s largely accurate? As I recall the only big miss was shale oil [0] and if it follows a bell curve then the sharp initial spike up is a bad sign for its longevity. I recall that the cost of producing shale oil gave the fields questionable economics too.
We could easily be looking at a huge amount of war and suffering in the near future as global peak oil hits and there are no new horizons being developed. Fringe quacks, like the US Energy Information Administration or Shell [1], have models that say in the worst case we could be hitting the peak right as early as this year if we are unlucky.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:OilProductionTightTotalHubbert-dec2021.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:OilProductionTightTotalHu...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peak_oil#Predictions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peak_oil#Predictions
- ben_w 4y agoI think how accurate it is depends on what exactly you want to know about. On a small scale, each well to each region, it seems to be quite accurate. On a global scale however, it doesn’t seem to account for the changes in technology or the geopolitical pressures caused by oil shortages. So, I used to be worried about it, but now I’m not. The main reason for my optimism here is that solar power seems to be following the best possible curve for replacing oil in energy production, while Elon Musk‘s personal fantasy about going to Mars happens to have a pre-requisite of the development of industrial scale CO2-to-methane conversion, and methane can be converted into longer chains for the other stuff oil is useful for e.g. plastics. However, there will still be global and national political concerns as the transition to renewables radically changes the economies of the world – Russia OPEC, all the oil rig workers (and coal miners because it isn’t just oil), and so on.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoThe commenter above has been very vague about what they meant about these predictions. To take a more specific example, cited in the international energy report as "the pessimistic take" in 1998, the "end of cheap oil" and the start of the decline in production of conventional oil before 2010 has been correctly predicted by peak oil theorists (at that point the price of oil was $15/barrel and still going down) : https://www.resilience.org/stories/1998-02-28/end-cheap-oil/ https://www.resilience.org/stories/1998-02-28/end-cheap-oil/ They might have underestimated the possibility of tight oil providing a temporary relief valve though, not even mentioning it in their discussion of unconventional oil (tar sands and kerogen). (They do mention technical evolution, though maybe not revolution ?) But then, even though the tight oil industry has produced oil, it seems to be more of a kind of fraud, a bubble bolstered by easy Wall Street money, now starting to pop (?), even though collectively supposedly it is still deep in the red, with only a few quarters in the green during more than a decade. And this despite the fact that it has been selling its oil when the global price was much higher than $15/barrel ! And so, one might wonder whether it has not been a net waste of oil too, as building and operating all that machinery is certainly not energy free. (Not to mention the costs of environmental cleanup.) Has the US failed badly at capitalism here ?!?
- kergonath 4y ago> Weren't the predictions in the 80s largely accurate? Yes, they were. There is some uncertainty because of more or less accurate estimates, fields that turned out to have more gas or oil than expected and marginal technology improvements. Also, oil producing countries love to play with supply, which results in fluctuations that obscure the larger trend if you don’t pay attention. But all of this changes the time scale, not the trends. Oil fields inevitably reach their maximum and decline one after the other. As oil and gas are not created over the time scales we need, there also has to be a global maximum. After that, decline can be longer or shorter, and well managed or not, but it is unavoidable.
- pirate787 4y agoThis comment is profoundly wrong. There are far more global oil reserves today than there were in 1980-- in the US alone known oil reserves have nearly DOUBLED. The reason is primarily new technology extending older fields and opening up deeper water sources of oil.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lazyasciiart 4y agoUnless you are arguing that we are building known oil reserves faster than we are using oil, you are nitpicking details of the comment.
- roenxi 4y agoThe price in real terms is much higher than it was in the 1950-2000 era (used to average ~$40/barrel, nowadays it is more like $80/barrel). If every time we double the real price we double reserves, then that just means we're running out. There'll be these huge things called "reserves" that aren't going to be useful to us. To draw an extreme analogy: We could say that Hong Kong has vast amounts of open real estate because someone could buy sea floor and dredge it up to the surface somehow with modern technology - in theory, yes that is so. In practice, it is not so. Hong Kong has not much free real estate, even though more can be made available at very high prices. There is always going to be oil available at some price - probably huge amounts in theory. It isn't going to be useful and nearly no-one will be able to use it. Certainly not to sustain what we would currently call a comfortable existence.