4 ms·
The idea behind the bet is stronger than the statistics of year shopping: the price of critical ingredients is subject to many changes, what was at stake was th
by ggm 4y ago
The idea behind the bet is stronger than the statistics of year shopping: the price of critical ingredients is subject to many changes, what was at stake was their availability expressed as price: Ehrlich argued for scarcity because of a flawed belief in exhaustion and limits to growth. Simon argued for supply chain dynamics, and had a strong sense the relative abundance of primary inputs was not the limiting factor.
Sure, the specific bet could be lost and won in different windows. But the actual underlying point remains: were not facing exhaustion of resources as a limit to economic growth and development as much as exhaustion of willingness to invest in exploration and development of sources.
"Oh God, there isn't enough cobalt or lithium for all the EV to be sold in the next 5 years" or "there isn't enough lithium for every car to be converted to EV" which are both variants of counterfactuals to actual rate of deployment, replacement of cars in the real world, the replacement of battery technology, new forms of battery chemistry, you name it PLUS extraction of new sources and discovery of new ore beds.
- wnevets 4y ago> Sure, the specific bet could be lost and won in different windows. But the actual underlying point remains: You are free to argue that but that is not why this bet turned out the way it did according to the quotes from the linked wiki. It sounds way more like a coin toss than any rule of the market
- pfdietz 4y agoYour point would be stronger if the bet hadn't allowed Ehrlich to pick the commodities in question.
- culi 4y agoThe selection is a pretty generic selection of metals though. Pretty representative of metals overall
- pfdietz 4y agoNot the point. Ehlich was free to choose the metals, so the fact that this particular choice wasn't in his favor doesn't make him look good. These were presumably the best bet he thought he could make.
- culi 4y ago> The idea behind the bet is stronger than the statistics of year shopping But the fact that this bet could've easily been lost and Simon mostly got lucky is direct evidence against "the idea behind the bet"... In the past 2 decades for example, the inflation-adjusted price of all 5 of these metals have increased.
- jcampbell1 4y agoEvery prediction in “The Population Bomb” turned out to be wildly incorrect. Simon was consistently right that the human standard of living would increase even as population increased. The arguments Erlichman made were like: not everyone can have a telephone because there is not enough copper in the Earth’s crust.
- specialist 4y agoWarning: Dangerous curve ahead. At your speed, you will lose control, jump the guard rail, fail down the chasm, impact, blow up, and ultimately die. Slows down. Safely navigates turn. Ergo, warning was wrong. Stupid warnings. -- There's a name for this phenomenon. Like how identifying ozone depletion beget policies to prevent said depletion. Doesn't mean the initial warning was wrong. Regardless, this is exactly how (we hope) policy making is supposed to work.
- pfdietz 4y agoOr, the warnings were irrelevant to the avoidance of the problem. A fable: http://englishaesop.blogspot.com/2010/07/fly-and-chariot.html http://englishaesop.blogspot.com/2010/07/fly-and-chariot.htm...
- jdminhbg 4y agoYou’re just completely wrong about whether we heeded the warnings in the Population Bomb. We are billions of people over the mark he set for total systemic collapse, and living standards are higher than ever. This isn’t like the ozone hole, where we identified a problem and fixed it. He was just wrong.