3 ms·
14. A moment for pause. Fourteen incidents of a Tesla slamming into an emergency vehicle stopped on the road. 14 times. And somehow, the Tesla PR machine wants
by ggm 4y ago
14. A moment for pause. Fourteen incidents of a Tesla slamming into an emergency vehicle stopped on the road.
14 times. And somehow, the Tesla PR machine wants to say this is not about FSD.
Can anyone point to some advanced technology which has had similar "oops" in deployment and not been taken back to the drawing board? Did the edsel have a similar failure rare at scale? The f100 truck fuel tank thing? Is that comparable?
- linsomniac 4y agoJust to be clear, the linked page specifically says they are unsure if the car was using FSD or if the driver was intoxicated.
- Jeremy1026 4y agoMight want to wait until it's determined if the driver had FSD/Autopilot enabled at the time before implying it is about FSD. > California Highway Patrol Officer Adam Lane said it was not clear whether the driver may have been intoxicated or whether the Tesla Model S was operating with automation or driving assistance features.
- jacquesm 4y agoWhat is the rate at which non-Tesla vehicles crash into stationary emergency vehicles? Because if the rate is the same on a relative scale then it seems moot, but if it is significantly higher then there would be a good reason to be suspicious.
- ggm 4y agoDrunk drivers in non FSD vehicles can't pretend to be capable in predictable conditions as well. So, to some extent FSD is precisely why drunk drivers in teslas with FSD enabled are possibly more of a risk in unpredictable situations. Ever wondered how many gun related accidents involve alcohol?
- kjksf 4y agoBased on how many times those crashes hit HN home page: 0. Reality: quite a few if you bother to Google it e.g. hhttps://www.google.com/search?q=bwm+crashes+emergency+vehicle https://www.google.com/search?q=bwm+crashes+emergency+vehicl... Obviously there are no statistics for "brand X crashes into fire truck" so unless you have data to the contrary, you can assume that the rates are more or less the same.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- culopatin 4y agoEnough to make it a law to move over one lane if you see an emergency vehicle on the shoulder. And enough to put it on signs on the highway all the time.
- emmelaich 4y agoI would expect far more from Teslas because people trust them too much.
- eyelidlessness 4y ago> California Highway Patrol Officer Adam Lane said it was not clear whether the driver may have been intoxicated How unusually circumspect!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- furyofantares 4y agoRemember a decade ago when the vibe around here was that we were pretty close on technology to being able to save 30,000 lives a year in the US, but we'd likely be held up massively by overreactive outcry and legislation the first time a self-driving car killed someone? Incredible how wrong we collectively were on both counts. That said, if we're gonna focus on the number 14 here, it still needs to be contextualized.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoHow can it be FSD's fault if the responsibility of stopping the vehicle is the one who is driving it?
- pengaru 4y ago> How can it be FSD's fault if the responsibility of stopping the vehicle is the one who is driving it? What's the FSD initialism's expanded form? I'll wait.
- linsomniac 4y agoIf we're going to be pedantic, FSD stands for Full Self Driving, which isn't available in Teslas yet. Full Self Driving Beta, which requires drivers to agree that they will fully supervise the car, is what is available right now. Help me understand something though, and this is an honest question, because this seems to come up a lot... Are you saying that because it's called FSD, the driver in these situations should be absolved of responsibility for the crash (assuming FSD was involved in this)?
- pengaru 4y ago> Help me understand something though, and this is an honest question, because this seems to come up a lot... Are you saying that because it's called FSD, the driver in these situations should be absolved of responsibility for the crash (assuming FSD was involved in this)? My personal opinion on this matter is that the courts will end up having to determine this in the fullness of time. And that will come after too many people are hurt/killed by insufficient automation being negligently marketed into fully-autonomous usage. But it's those losses that will push the matter into the courts' hands.
- linsomniac 4y agoI agree with everything you're saying there. I wonder, and this is largely an academic point rather than disagreeing with you, if the sort of people who would lean too heavily on "FSD" would also lean too heavily on "lane keeping assist", with similar outcomes. But I think that the day in court that you mention above is going to go very badly for Tesla, largely because of the FSD name. Why can't Tesla let go of the FSD name? I'd guess it's entirely the ego at the top. I think everyone agrees that FSD is not at all capable of full self driving. I know Musk wants to get there and thinks they can, but in the interim I don't understand why they don't just start calling it something more in line with the actual capabilities... "Driving assist" or revive the "Mad Max" theme they used for how aggressive the mode is, maybe "Full Tunderdome"? Maaaaybe, nobody wants to tell Elon how bad FSD really is, so they have his cars remotely piloted so nobody gets fired? Honestly, that wouldn't surprise me at this point.
- josephcsible 4y agoHow many times have Toyotas, Mazdas, etc. slammed into emergency vehicles stopped on the road? What evidence was there that FSD was even in use in this case?
- 7e 4y agoToyota has 40x more vehicles in operation in the U.S. than Tesla does, FYI. In case rigor was desired in this line of questioning.
- josephcsible 4y agoDo you think fewer than 560 Toyotas have crashed into emergency vehicles in the same amount of time?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoA moment for pause seems unnecessary, but perhaps some perspective is warranted. Automatic Emergency Braking only has a 30-80 percent success rate, depending on speed and conditions. Sort of irresponsible and unnecessarily inflammatory to call out Tesla when this technology across all manufactures isn’t a panacea. The driver is still ultimately reasonable for the vehicle regardless of safety or driver assist system used as US law stands today. Tesla pushed a software update (feature first seen in version 2021.24.12) that slows the vehicle if emergency vehicle lights are detected by forward facing cameras. Again, no safety system is perfect, and no other auto manufacturer does this. https://insideevs.com/news/534868/tesla-autopilot-update-emergency-vehicles/ https://insideevs.com/news/534868/tesla-autopilot-update-eme... > AAA took a range of modern vehicles equipped with AEB to determine just how well these systems work in practice. The testing concerned T-bone crashes and incidents with cars turning left across traffic, as well as rear-end crashes at 30 and 40 mph. The tests were performed with a selection of popular SUVs, with AAA selecting 2022 models of the Honda CR-V, Ford Explorer, Chevrolet Equinox, and Toyota RAV4 for the project. > At 30 mph, AAA's testing found that AEB was able to avoid a collision entirely 17 times out of 20, an 85 percent success rate. In the other three cases, speed was reduced by 86 percent prior to impact. Performance was worse at 40 mph, with AEB only avoiding a crash six times out of 20 tests, a 30 percent success rate. Impact speed was reduced by 62 percent on average in the 14 tests where a collision did occur. https://www.thedrive.com/news/automatic-emergency-braking-isnt-as-safe-as-you-might-think-aaa https://www.thedrive.com/news/automatic-emergency-braking-is... > The result shows that rear-end frontal collisions were reduced by 27% for cars with AEB, compared to cars without the system [6]. Many existing studies have shown that AEB can reduce rear-end collisions by 25%–50% https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7037779/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7037779/ For comparison, GM killed 124 people with an ignition switch they knew for a decade was not fit for purpose. They recalled 30 million vehicles, and as part of a Deferred Prosecution Agreement, agreed to forfeit $900 million to the United States government. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_ignition_switch_recalls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_ignition_switch...
- ggm 4y agoOther manufacturers are very careful to remind users it's assisting technology. Tesla believers seem to want to promote its autonomously capable, or will be. And there's few people willing to tolerate 40mph speeds on highways, Tesla or otherwise, let alone 30. 14 feels to me like a horrendously large number for one vehicle manufacturer but your point is valid: what's the rate of analogous event for Volvo, or other market leading AEB? The idea this problem is solved by making smart devices smarter at recognising flashing lights suggests they're looking for low cost consequence fixes, much as Boeing wanted for the Max.