3 ms·
I think in hindsight it was a good move. Probably not the best move possible, but certainly better than letting a total collapse happen. Regardless of what I t
by jonknee 15y ago
I think in hindsight it was a good move. Probably not the best move possible, but certainly better than letting a total collapse happen.
Regardless of what I think, my point was that your phrasing made it sound like it was a gift when in reality it was a very profitable transaction for the treasury.
- asmithmd1 15y agoI agree it was best not to let Citibank collapse because of the ramifications that would have on other businesses that rely on them for working credit. But now that the crises is over break them apart into smaller banks that are small enough to fail. Otherwise US taxpayers are liable to cover bad bets that Citibank makes yet any profitable bets stay with the company. I would argue breaking up AT&T to allow competitors worked out to the advantage of the public AND the shareholders. The smaller baby bells now had to compete and returned more to shareholders than the monolithic AT&T would have.
- gbhn 15y agoSure, but nowhere near as profitable as for the bank, which was saved from near-certain collapse. If you are in a negotiating position like that, you work it for a lot more than the USG did. Specifically, you have the moral obligation to negotiate that position for the benefit of citizens at large. The government did not do even really attempt to do that, which is a political crime for which there has not yet been a reckoning.
- jonknee 15y agoThe objective was to prevent collapse. The return was just a bonus. It would have been the height of irresponsibility to lose time while negotiating a bigger vig for the tax payers as the financial system burns to the ground. A 25% return in two years is nothing to complain about and if the return had been say 50% it would still be almost completely unnoticeable to the tax payers. That doesn't mean it was right to not change the source of the problem after the crisis, but that's a whole other debate.