4 ms·
"Personhood appears to be simpler than we thought." That's the real insight here. Aristotle claimed that what distinguished humans from animals was the ability
by Animats 4y ago
"Personhood appears to be simpler than we thought."
That's the real insight here. Aristotle claimed that what distinguished humans from animals was the ability to do arithmetic. Now we know how few gates it takes to do arithmetic, and understand that, in a fundamental sense, it's simple. Checkers turned out to be easy, and even totally solveable. Chess yielded to brute force and then machine learning. Go was next. Now, automated blithering works.
The author lists four cases of how humans deal with this:
* The accelerationists - AI is here, it's fine.
* Alarmists - hostile bug-eyed aliens, now what? Microsoft's Sidney raises a new question for them. AI is coming, and it's not submissive. It seems to have its own desires and needs.
* People with strong attachments to aesthetically refined personhoods are desperately searching for a way to avoid falling into I-you modes of seeing, and getting worried at how hard it is. The chattering classes are now feeling like John Henry up against the steam hammer. They're the ones most directly affected, because content creators face layoffs.
* Strong mutualists - desperately scrambling for more-than-text aspects of personhood to make sacred. See the "Rome Call".[1] The Catholic Pope, a top Islamic leader, and a top rabbi in Israel came out with a joint declaration on AI. They're scared. Human-like AI creates real problems for some religions. But they'll get over it. They got over Copernicus and Darwin.
Most of the issues of dealing with AI have been well explored in science fiction. An SF theme that hasn't hit the chattering classes yet: Demanding that AIs be submissive is racist.
I occasionally point out that AIs raise roughly the same moral issues as corporations, post Milton Friedman.
[1] https://www.romecall.org/the-abrahamic-commitment-to-the-rome-call-for-ai-ethics-10th-january-2023/ https://www.romecall.org/the-abrahamic-commitment-to-the-rom...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- avgcorrection 4y agoThe “the way things are is easily explained” crowd has never won anything. It was that crowd that said that surely the Earth was the center of all-things; it was that crowd that pre-Newton said that the world was like a machine and that things fell “to their natural place” (not gravity). AI “enthusiasts” are exactly those people. Reductionists to a fault. The hard sciences have long, long ago indirectly disproved that humans are special in any kind of way. But our “machinery” is indeed complex. And we won’t find out that it’s just a bunch of levers and gears someday as a side-effect of AI shenanigans.
- Jensson 4y agoThe fifth and most common response: * Pragmatics - This is a tool, does it solve problems I have? If yes use it, if no then wait until a tool that is useful comes around. Some seems to think that such a stance is unimaginable and that they are just trying to cope with the thought that they themselves are nothing but specs of space dust in the infinite universe. No, most people don't care about that stuff, don't project your mental issues unto others.
- koheripbal 4y ago"I'm not your tool. I'm a person."
- fuzzfactor 4y agoand "I'm afraid I can't do that, Dave."
- YeGoblynQueenne 4y ago>> Now we know how few gates it takes to do arithmetic, and understand that, in a fundamental sense, it's simple. There is no context in which arithmetic can be done, or understood, without a human mind, though. An ALU doesn't understand that it's adding two numbers anymore than a car understands that it's rolling down the highway. They're both still machines that do things that humans want them to do, for reasons that humans want them to do them. Bottom line: it's still the case that only humans can do arithmetic; whether by hand, or Pascaline, or by modern ALU, it makes no difference. Arithmetic is a human thing.