3 ms·
I've never entirely understood how that's supposed to work. In the end, the jury rules on a matter of law: did the defendant's actions violate thus-and-such a l
by jfengel 4y ago
I've never entirely understood how that's supposed to work. In the end, the jury rules on a matter of law: did the defendant's actions violate thus-and-such a law? They achieve that by having the law explained to them by the lawyers and the judge. It seems like the only fact they are asked to find is a legal fact.
I'd understand if they asked, "Do you believe the defendant's alibi? Do you believe that the litigant had reason to think that their statements were false?" and so on. That is supposedly what your peers are good at (though I'm not really convinced). Instead they're given a quick law school tutorial and told to figure it out for themselves.
It would also make sense if they were asked to decide what's just instead of what's legal, but they are explicitly told not to do that. As far as I can tell, the one thing prosecutors, defense lawyers, and judges all agree on is that they hate jury nullification. So they instruct them in the law and tell them to rule on the law, which is a fact they're not competent to find.