6 ms·
This article makes it sound like White Castle was collecting "biometric data" to invade employees' privacy, as if it were using it to track their movement or co
by crazygringo 4y ago
This article makes it sound like White Castle was collecting "biometric data" to invade employees' privacy, as if it were using it to track their movement or connect them to potential crimes.
The reality is "use of workers' fingerprints to access pay stubs and company computers". So it set up a fingerprint reader much like the one I use to unlock my MacBook, or sign in at my doctor's office, or open the turnstile at my gym.
I understand that according to Illinois state law this is illegal without consent, and so legally they missed having employees sign a form. But morally/ethically is there really any problem with this? This is just how iPhones and MacBooks work, for example. Really seems like perhaps Illionis state law needs to be updated to reflect the widespread use of fingerprint readers for authentication on computers, tablets and phones.
- zitterbewegung 4y agoWhen you unlock your MacBook you are opting in to unlock the MacBook and you don't need to use it. Also, it is protected by a Secure Enclave and the actual fingerprint isn't stored. Reading the bill it even points this out. Biometrics are unlike other unique identifiers that are used to access finances or other sensitive information. For example, social security numbers, when compromised, can be changed. Biometrics, however, are biologically unique to the individual; therefore, once compromised, the individual has no recourse, is at heightened risk for identity theft, and is likely to withdraw from biometric-facilitated transactions.
- crazygringo 4y agoPresumably whatever fingerprint reader White Castle used for logins also stored a hash, similar to MacBooks. I don't know of any general-purpose fingerprint readers for authentication that store the original image. Also I don't see how compromising that hash is a problem in practice, if that ever happened. If it's salted it's worthless, but even if not, I don't know how you'd reasonably physically use it to hack into another fingerprint reader anyways.
- fragmede 4y agoThat is a huge presumption and, as GP pointed out, the problem is if your fingerprint gets leaked, it's rather difficult to change it. Apple did a great job with TouchID but security experts went all over it trying to poke holes. Most other fingerprint systems don't get anywhere near the same amount of scrutiny. So in an unfortunate turn of fate, Apple's awesome implementation of fingerprint authentication on the iPhone resulted inthe general public being comfortable with fingerprint auth in other places, when they really shouldn't be.
- loeg 4y agoYou leak your fingerprints everywhere you go on every surface you touch. Fingerprints are highly convenient but they have never been an especially secure mechanism for locking devices.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoBut, and here is the important part, those 'leaked fingerprints' in the wild are not digitally preserved. It would actually take some effort to preserve on a scene. The comparison is not apt.
- pixl97 4y agoWhat form must a malicious fingerprint scanner take by law? When it comes to fingerprints you must assume that the attacker has the ability to control the scene and the ability to retry until successful.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoIs it not an argument against using fingerprints as a basis for id verification to begin with?
- libraryatnight 4y ago
- batch12 4y agoI may have missed this. Were they storing hashes of images or points of images- or were they storing the original image? Any platform worth its salt would hash and salt the fingerprint data and it'd be worthless elsewhere as other systems would have different hashes.
- gruez 4y ago>is at heightened risk for identity theft This feels like pearl clutching to me. While it's probably technically true that having your fingerprint leaked increases your risk of identity theft by some non-zero amount, in the overwhelming majority of the cases it's effectively zero, because for the overwhelming majority of people the only place they have their fingerprints enrolled is on their phones. In the event you somehow acquire stolen fingerprint image data, it will be very difficult to use those to perform identity theft at mass scale, because you need physical access to phones. >and is likely to withdraw from biometric-facilitated transactions. What "biometric-facilitated transactions" are these? Aside from fingerprint unlock on phones, I'm struggling to come up with cases where fingerprints are used to secure sensitive information.
- boppo1 4y agoI mean, you could leave someone's fingerprints at the scene of a crime.
- brookst 4y agoYou could also write a confession in their name and leave it at the crime scene. I don’t think this happens a lot.
- gruez 4y agoIf you're out to frame someone for a crime, I have a feeling that you're not going to stop just because you can't buy the victim's fingerprint on darknet markets. You can follow the person around and lift fingerprints off objects that he touched, for instance.
- mandmandam 4y agoPost a hi-res scan of your fingerprints with your name and address, and see what happens - it might be a learning experience for you... Note: I don't actually recommend you do this - it opens you up to the very real dangers which you're claiming don't exist.
- 4y ago
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoThere are multiple problems: 1. Biometrics can't be revoked, so if your gym leaks your fingerprint images (linked to your name), that's a mistake that in practice simply cannot be fixed. You just can't use that finger for sensitive biometrics ever again. People should not be forced to take the risk. 2. It's hard to distinguish between biometric surveillance and "good" uses of biometrics, and they can fluently blend into each other. The law draws a rather clear line and has to enforce it. Should a company be allowed to use biometrics to make sure you don't let your brother sub in for you? Preventing fraud like that is a noble goal, but how far do we want to allow pervasive biometric surveillance to go? Should stadium owners be allowed to ban people? Should they be allowed to ban all employees of a law firm they don't like? Should they be allowed to surveil everyone's faces with a biometric system for this purpose? The lines between "perfectly reasonable" to "Black Mirror dystopia" are fluent, and the way there consists of many steps that individually seem reasonable (preventing crime is good, right?) and yet the outcome is something we don't want. This is why the law exists, this is why it also hits some "legitimate" uses, and this is why consent (if implemented meaningfully, in the voluntary, GDPR style sense, not in the "you have to sign here or you will be excluded from normal life" sense) is such a powerful tool: It generally lets the harmless stuff happen and prevents the dystopia.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> Biometrics can't be revoked, so if your gym leaks your fingerprint images (linked to your name), that's a mistake that in practice simply cannot be fixed. You just can't use that finger for sensitive biometrics ever again. People should not be forced to take the risk. Fingerprint scanner systems don’t store photos of your fingerprint. They store information that can be used to match against your fingerprint within their own system, but they can’t be used to reconstruct your fingerprint.
- greedo 4y agoIn a perfect world, this would be the case. Just as in a perfect world, no one would store un-hashed passwords.
- kube-system 4y ago
- reaperducer 4y agoThis is just how iPhones and MacBooks work It's optional on the devices you mention. It's not a requirement. In the court case, there was no way for an employee to opt out, short of quitting. My company (about 2,000 employees) issues iPhones to its employees. You are given a choice of face scanning or fingerprint scanning device. You do not have to use either method: you can choose a suitably long PIN, instead. If you choose to use biometric access, HR send your a 15-page document to sign, and you have to take an online course about biometric privacy. I think if more companies did that, society wouldn't be so casual with giving away their biometric data.
- astrange 4y agoThat's silly since there are no biometric privacy risks to enrolling in Touch ID (it doesn't save images or let anyone view them). Otherwise you'd have to take a class after buying a phone.
- indymike 4y ago> If you choose to use biometric access, HR send your a 15-page document to sign, Sounds like legal has experience with this issue.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoWe are incredibly casual about giving away our biometric data - most societies don't constantly wear face masks (with obvious exceptions for women in the middle east), the past few years excepted. Gloves aren't that common either. You leave your face and your fingerprints everywhere, if anyone is looking. They're just not, typically, because it doesn't matter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoI don't work in tech. Yet it has always seemed obvious to me that, since biometrics cannot be changed, they are a "username" at best, not a "password". So why are they treated like the reverse so often?
- geoduck14 4y agoYour password is just to prove that you are using your username. You really don't need a password, if you have perfectly honest users or a fool proof way of preventing people from using usernames that aren't theirs.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoI doubt either of those will ever exist which is why passwords and other MFA techniques will always be necessary. But I don't think that addresses that biometrics are more suited to identification rather than authentication...
- jareklupinski 4y agoyup, see every action scene where the hero subdues the guard standing in front of a biometrically secured door, then uses the knocked-out guard's hand to open the door
- GauntletWizard 4y agoThere are plenty of places where quick and easy authentication is important, and some amount of hard to fake is desirable, but it's not important enough for a strong password. Fingerprint readers are harder to fool than a 4-digit pin and unique enough that a mid-large group of people won't have any confusion. Fast food sign-in is the perfect low-stakes use of fingerprints. There's some real baggage from when they were harder to gather and how they're used in law enforcement as to why they're considered sensitive, but they're really not. Getting the law and society to agree will take some time, though, and there's a ton of reactionary forces trying to hype up the threat.
- astrange 4y ago
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoWell, my current job required my fingerprints for security check ( which in this case was reasonable; I have too much access to crap as is ), but, not completely unlike non-competes, I am not sure this is a reasonable request to ask of your burger flippers. It is a little extra bad, because this group is even less likely to complain, because 1: they are young and don't know any better 2: they are likely to be paid peanuts 3: their need of a job overrides any other consideration All three indicates a type of person that should be protected from random idiocy of an employer. It is not often that I praise IL for anything, but the biometric law is one of those few instances.
- duxup 4y agoI’m working on an app for a company who doesn’t think much of the user’s ability to use apps (I find this misguided). They constantly tell me to simply things because “these guys aren’t very smart”. To the point that (on top of other problems) they’re creating foolishly simple logins… I thought about finger print reading but the legal questions make me second guess it.
- brasic 4y agoThe architecture of this system, in which fingerprints are captured at a local terminal and transmitted to a third party vendor over the network, is explicitly a source of added liability due to how the law is written, where disclosure to a third party is its own separate offense.
- twobitshifter 4y agoit didn’t make sense to me that every swipe is considered a collection by the court, only enrollment is collecting the fingerprint, the other swipes are making comparisons, not collecting new data.
- more_corn 4y ago“Transmit”
- barbazoo 4y ago> sign in at my doctor's office, or open the turnstile at my gym. I see how it's convenient but personally I wouldn't use biometrics here, sounds like an obvious avenue to get your biometrics leaked. MacOS unlocking is different like others have pointed out already.