3 ms·
HVDC can be made cheaper by making the voltage higher... As voltage goes up, the thickness of metal needed goes down. The insulator thickness goes up - that e
by londons_explore 4y ago
HVDC can be made cheaper by making the voltage higher...
As voltage goes up, the thickness of metal needed goes down. The insulator thickness goes up - that either means taller towers or thicker plastic.
Conversion from regular AC grid voltages to high voltage DC was previously very expensive, with custom made semiconductors costing millions.
With the advent of electric cars, there are now off the shelf cheap power electronics. They can be stacked, perhaps 20x in package to get to 10kV, and then 100x packages to get to 1 million volts.
That should dramatically reduce the cost of moving large amounts of power long distances.
- nuriaion 4y agoI think that would actually be more expensive as you still have the all the hard problems. Like how do you isolate the power electronics. You can use air which is cheap but needs a lot of space. (i learned that you need 1mm per 1kV) You need a lot of space which has to be very secure. etc Additionally you need to control 5000 converters without getting oscillations etc. (probably over glas) Also they will probably need a lot more space.
- londons_explore 4y agoAt very high voltages, I would expect the whole lot to be sealed in a polymer resin for life. 1 million volts through epoxy resin requires a spacing of just 1 inch (call it two inches for a safety margin). Then your whole converter station can be the size of a shed, and the whole project can fit within existing space on existing utility land.
- scrlk 4y agoHow would you deal with the heat generated by the power electronics if everything is sealed in polymer resin?
- bmicraft 4y agoBuilt in water cooling channels?
- londons_explore 4y agoAt these voltages, water is way too conductive. You can use pumped oil though.
- entropicgravity 4y agoVoltage is just a potential, like gravity. Even at thousands of volts you would still need just 5 volts to operate equipment in the usual way. Communicating between large voltages can be done with fibre optic (i'm guessing) or wifi.
- voxadam 4y ago> As voltage goes up, the thickness of metal needed goes down. The insulator thickness goes up - that either means taller towers or thicker plastic. Why insulate the lines at all? HVAC lines aren't insulated.
- londons_explore 4y agoThey're insulated with air... Thats why the lines have to be so high up. As the voltage gets higher, the lines have to be higher up, and get more expensive to build. The alternative is to bury the lines, and then you use a thick layer of plastic instead. At 1 million volts, you need a layer of plastic multiple inches thick, and that starts to get heavy and expensive.
- jojobas 4y agoNot that simple. High voltage causes corona discharge, air is not perfectly dielectric. Reducing coronas requires spaced wire bundles for larger effective diameter. There is a sweet spot in terms of voltage above which the costs go up.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoThey need to be insulated against earth somehow, not necessarily by wrapping them in plastic - e.g. "taller towers".
- xupybd 4y agoThey did it in NZ without semiconductors. In 1965 they commissioned a 600 MW link with mercury arc valves.