4 ms·
What Maddox doesn't seem to understand is that "raising awareness" is the only way you win these battles long term in a democracy. For example, gay marriage is
by guelo 15y ago
What Maddox doesn't seem to understand is that "raising awareness" is the only way you win these battles long term in a democracy. For example, gay marriage is slowly becoming a reality because over the last 20 years gays have opened people's eyes to their plight. Once a cause becomes a moral issue for most Americans it wins. But most people have no idea what us tech geeks are bitching about so we have to educate them about our causes. And that is exactly what yesterday was about.
- irishcoffee 15y agoThis may upset people, but in my humble opinion, gay marriage has been a pawn used by DC for political gain. Raising awareness worked because DC figured out a way to twist it into a campaign talking point. Makes me sick.
- elmindreda 15y agoThat's true of every issue that has succeeded without the backing of a powerful lobby. The same thing can happen here.
- dhimes 15y agoHonestly, on that issue I don't think it happened that way. They were doing great with stem cell research and abortion- especially late-term. In fact, I frankly think gay marriage took DC by surprise. At first it was, "Oh, that's just Massachusetts. I'm surprised California doesn't have it." And then they realized it was a "serious" issue. My personal perspective, having lived in the DC area most of my life and moving to MA shortly after (or was it just before? I don't remember), is that yeah, I was a little worried about how to explain it to my young kids. Turned out not to matter. I personally don't think the government should give a rat's ass who you love.
- tluyben2 15y agoExplain what to your young kids? People loving eachother should be allowed together or why your government is sometimes quite insane? I would think the second one is more of a worry to explain to your young kids... But dad, why do we live here if you think 'those morons cannot do anything right'? :)
- DannoHung 15y agoI think the issue is actually harder to explain when homosexuality is seen as wrong. I mean, if any two given people are allowed to be married, then you just explain it as something that two people do when they love each other very much. If same sex couples aren't allowed to marry normally, then you have to get into the why of the issue, which eventually would boil down to some people not being okay with what same sex couples do with each other in bed.
- dhimes 15y agoFortunately, I was not encumbered by any feelings of "wrongness" or "immorality" or any fear that my kids would "catch it." That's why it totally turned out to be a non-issue. In fact the kids probably ended up explaining it to each other, in the very few cases where it occurred that somebody in a class had same-sex parents.
- tluyben2 15y agoYes, unfortunately that's a truth. I'm from the Netherlands and here it's kind of weird if someone is against it anyway, so I don't encounter the issue very often. I was half-kidding with my above remark, but thinking about it; I could not live in a country where that would be the case. I would think that even if big parts of a country work like that, in 'well educated' parts of the country, your kids would've seen some amount (edited) of gay people together already which means there is nothing to explain (it being already natural). If that would not be the case, it means there is some kind of suppressing force at hand which I would not be able to live with (I'm not gay, but i'm very much against the ignorance which disallows / restricts people while there is no solid or even non-shaky argument against it). Also, it is not known what population of a country is in fact gay. I read somewhere between 2 and 15% depending on a lot of factors. The issue is ofcourse that in most countries most gays did not (and maybe will never) come out, so it's hard to analyze anything based on that. But if 2%, it's still 2 out of 100, so in your neighborhood there will be always a few around and they ofcourse find partners from all over.
- icebraining 15y ago
- tommorris 15y agoHere's how you explain it to your kids: "Mummy and Daddy love one another very much, and so do lots of other people. Men love women, some men love other men, some women love other women. And when they love each other enough, they commit to being with that person for the rest of their lives and get married." I'm not totally sure how a conversation like that means - as some same-sex marriage opponents seem to think - that one has to start describing the intricacies of sex, anal or otherwise. I do think it's utterly disappointing that the primary reason people seem to think that denying same-sex partners from getting married is because they are too much of a pussy to explain to their kids that gay people exist and can love one another.
- sethg 15y agoI'm not totally sure how a conversation like that means - as some same-sex marriage opponents seem to think - that one has to start describing the intricacies of sex, anal or otherwise. Because some same-sex marriage opponents are obsessed with the intricacies of anal sex (whereas the typical preadolescent child really doesn’t care about the intricacies of any kind of sex). Heck, some of them are probably more obsessed with this topic than the gay men who do it.
- rmc 15y agohow to explain it to my young kids You should explain it to your kids, since one of your kids might be LGBT and it would be good for them to know that their parents will accept them. For more detail read "I want to expose your children to homoseuxality" http://seldo.com/weblog/2011/08/11/i_want_to_expose_your_children_to_homosexuality http://seldo.com/weblog/2011/08/11/i_want_to_expose_your_chi...
- dhimes 15y agoyeah, when it came up, I did. And it wasn't a big deal. It just doesn't come up often, there are gay people around, and nobody cares. It's actually exactly the way you would hope it would be. In fact, I may be the only male in the house that uses 'gay' as a reference to homosexuality. I think to the kids gay = wimp and FWIW fag = asshole. I think. It's hard to figure it out sometimes. I just caution them that there are plenty of people who find certain terms hurtful still and they should be mindful of who is within earshot. But that's how I've always treated profanity.
- Xurinos 15y agoWait... why can't we make Internet communication a talking point? The tech community has been wrestling with censorship, net neutrality, and the like for a long time now. Can't we frame this into a simple, non-extremist message and start asking candidates about their stance on it? It is a talking point, and if we are persistent in asking these candidates their stance on the issue, it will end up on the evening news. But first we have to form a consistent and clear stance.
- nextparadigms 15y agoI think we should. I just worry that if one sides with "Internet Freedom", there will be others who will get votes for siding with "Internet censorship" (of child pornography, piracy, etc). So at least we should send a strong signal that we ALL want Internet Freedom.
- irishcoffee 15y agoRight, that what I trying to say. Gay marriage has become a polarizing topic for a candidate to pick a side on. This is not how it should be, and it’s absurd. The same for any other politically polarizing issue. I very much do NOT WANT this SOPA and any possible legislation after it to become a polarizing talking point in a speech. It’s a twisted bastardization of a real issue, which is how I feel the gay marriage dabate has become.
- mike-cardwell 15y agoI don't know why you're connecting these two completely different issues together. Just because you can "demonstrate" that raising awareness helped one problem, doesn't mean it will help another entirely different problem.
- gm 15y ago... Unless raising awareness in one problem makes people start giving a shit, in which case caring about orphaned baby seals in Chile, does help recycling efforts in Omaha.
- dhimes 15y agoI agree. To counter his point, we laid low for the Patriot Act and the masses didn't suddenly awaken.
- joshuahedlund 15y agoOr the NDAA. Etc. Etc. Etc. Saying "We need a really shitty piece of legislation like SOPA in this country to be the spark that ignites the lazy, idle tinders of protest" ignores all the other "shitty pieces of legislation" that have been passed over the years without igniting the "lazy, idle tinders of protest." I (perhaps naively but hopefully) feel like SOPA could become the turning of that tide...
- cookiecaper 15y agoSOPA would only work if it interrupted the things that normal people care about. If Facebook was taken down for an extended period there would be a major rise in discontent. However, the censors know doing something like that would be suicidal, so they will let the entrenched players like Facebook go and kill every Facebook Jr. as soon as someone posts a link to a Daily Show clip from YouTube instead of comedycentral.com.
- akg 15y agoAgreed. The problem is that the proposed changes are really big changes considering the size of the infrastructure you are trying to change. Like most things, change requires time to cultivate and raising awareness is just as important as taking active action. There is after all strength in numbers. One person vehemently protesting is not better than thousands of slacktivists. It more or less comes down to a numbers game. Not everyone will proactively go out of their way to take action (or will only do the very minimum, like changing their profile picture). To expect everyone to be proactive is unrealistic. The advantage that awareness gives is that it reaches out to the masses potentially hitting those who have the aptitude and attitude to take firm action. You reach enough of those people and over time influence starts to propagate upward throughout the entire structure -- but again, that takes time. People and the structures they live within are not changed over night.
- realschool 15y agoThe problem with an awareness campaign is that everyone who the awareness is being spread to already knows about the issue.
- rmc 15y ago"Raising awareness"? What about all the LGBT people who were disowned by family? What about people who were beaten up and sometimes killed? What about the decades of marches (and initially, riots) for this. What about people who risked their jobs, their home, their family, their neighbourhood or violence from the police all for their cause? The LGBT rights movement was hardly slacktivist 'awareness raising'. It was real struggle with real costs which is generating real results.
- jacquesm 15y agoAnd that's very far from a solved problem even today, depending on your locality.
- rmc 15y agoThe struggle isn't over yet. But over the last 50 years things have gotten better. To give an example, the UK has gone from "Homosexuality should be illegal" to a conversative tory prime minister saying "I support same sex marriage because it makes marriage stronger"
- batista 15y agoThose are different problems. SOPA is a business/political problem, and the gay marriage is a societal norms problem. Politicians are paid by lobbyists or have their own monetary interests to pass SOPA, and massive businesses support such a bill. On the other hand, no one* in Washington really cares about "gay marriage". They just pretend to because there is opposition to it by their voters. So, they can give you "gay marriage" rights, because it doesn't affect any economic or power interest. In the large scheme of things, gay marriage is an insignificant novelty, while SOPA is part of Washington's and corporate America's vision of the future. [*] Well, some conservative republican politicians might care, but those are in the minority, many more are just putting on an act (like those that are all about christian family values, and then they are busted with some prostitute.