4 ms·
Audacity is audio/sample editor¹ that's popular as a My First Editor™ for podcasters, etc. For anyone wondering why the Audacium/Tenacity forks exist: https://w
by CharlesW 4y ago
Audacity is audio/sample editor¹ that's popular as a My First Editor™ for podcasters, etc. For anyone wondering why the Audacium/Tenacity forks exist: https://www.zdnet.com/article/audacity-reverses-course-on-plans-to-add-opt-in-telemetry-after-outcry/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/audacity-reverses-course-on-pl...
Apparently, Audacity telemetry is now restricted to a self-hosted Sentry error reporting service, and to sending version info an IP address (anonymized to the first 3 octets) on update checks.
¹ It's a so-called "destructive" audio editor², and so is different than modern, "non-destructive" audio editors like GarageBand, Reaper, Descript, etc.
² https://projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hks-communications-program/files/ho_2_kgagne-audacity_10_30_17.pdf https://projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/hks-communications-pro...
- andrepd 4y agoAudacity also offers non-destructive editing.
- swyx 4y ago> It's a so-called "destructive" audio editor this is out of date as of Audacity 3.1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xH1CndkiBiU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xH1CndkiBiU
- CharlesW 4y agoWow, that's great news for its users! Non-destructive effects as well! https://support.audacityteam.org/audio-editing/using-realtime-effects https://support.audacityteam.org/audio-editing/using-realtim...
- weinzierl 4y agoIs there anything Audacity can do that the modern, "non-destructive" editors can't. Apart from ease of use and price is there any reason to use Audacity at all?
- CharlesW 4y agoNo, not in my opinion. Here are some alternatives I like to recommend, in alphabetical order: • Adobe Audition is great. Its main drawback is Adobe's rental-only pricing model ($20/month), which kinda stinks unless you need Adobe CC anyway. (macOS/Win) • If you're on a Mac, many incredibly-popular podcasts have been created with good ol' GarageBand. And if you ever outgrow GarageBand, projects can be "upgraded" to use Logic. (macOS) • Hindenburg Journalist is unique, in that it's an audio editor designed especially for spoken-word productions. (macOS/Win) • Presonus Studio One is wonderful and not known about by enough podcasters. There's a free Studio One Prime edition available. (macOS/Win) • Reaper is an inexpensive and well-liked choice. The discounted license is only $60, but you can “try” it for free as long as you like. (macOS/Win)
- 1f60c 4y ago> "destructive" audio editor I clicked your link, but I'm still unsure what that means. Does that mean it operates on the audio file directly? Or that it has no undo functionality? Or something else entirely?
- stonogo 4y agoA "destructive" editor is just an editor. Your text editor is a "destructive" editor. A "non-destructive" editor does no editing, and instead stores (in a separate file) a sequence of patches to apply to the original file, resulting in your desired output. This isn't really editing, but the industry didn't do a good job at naming this stuff.
- jaywalk 4y agoIt's spelled out pretty directly: "if you delete something, save your progress, and close your project, you will never be able to restore what was deleted"
- seba_dos1 4y agoWhat you said may apply to both "non-destructive" and "destructive" editors just as well. A better example would be "if you add reverb to your track, save your progress and close your project, you won't be able to unreverb it". With "non-destructive" editor, all you did was to add a flag that your track should have a reverb added to it, so you can easily disable or adjust parameters of your reverb afterwards without having to rely on undo.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's the difference between making changes to the audio itself, and storing the changes as "now do this to the audio". Similar to photoshop using layers to apply all the changes you've done (so you can undo particular ones easily/turn them on/off) and doing everything in the "flat" image space. Or using git to track a file's changes vs just editing the file directly.
- doodlesdev 4y ago
- Blackthorn 4y ago> ¹ It's a so-called "destructive" audio editor², and so is different than modern, "non-destructive" audio editors like GarageBand, Reaper, Descript, etc. I have to say as someone who recently got into this space, the value that these non-destructive editors provide for their price is absurd. Reaper costs a mere one-time payment of $60 for individual use! That's ridiculous for the value you're getting.
- squarefoot 4y agoActually, Reaper's license expires after 2 major version steps, that is, if you purchase a license when the major version is x (currently it is 6.75) then you're licensed to use it until x+1.99 (now it would be 7.99). Not to detract anything from Reaper's value: its license is one of the best everywhere, the cost is very affordable and the unlicensed product isn't crippled like others around. I have been licensed a while ago, and plan to purchase a new one as soon as I get back to making music. I would love a crowdfunding initiative to buy it from the creators with the purpose of open sourcing it, but the product quality is so high that even if possible it would likely cost a fortune.
- mst 4y agoI think regarding it as a one-time payment for individual use with free upgrades within the current and next major version is a reasonable use of the term 'one-time payment' in that while you can't upgrade any further after that the software still keeps working. It seems to me that 'free upgrades forever' is honestly not a wise idea if you want to develop for your actual users rather than having to constantly try and attract more because any existing user will never pay you again. So while I'm glad you mentioned the specifics, I don't think the 'Actually,' at the start was really deserved. (plus in general the quality of comments on the internet starting with 'Actually,' is terribad and what followed it in your case came as a welcome and pleasant surprise ;)
- Blackthorn 4y ago> It seems to me that 'free upgrades forever' is honestly not a wise idea if you want to develop for your actual users rather than having to constantly try and attract more because any existing user will never pay you again. Funny you should mention that... Another one of those editors, FL Studio, has exactly that business model. It's not as cheap as a Reaper license, but they do advertise "free upgrades forever" and they're somehow in a good enough position that they bought out both Melda and UVI recently (the latter looks like a pretty big player in the software synth space). The C-suite philosophy there is that new people are constantly entering both the hobby and business which is...well, entirely correct really. Honestly I'm glad that it's working out for them because it's an incredibly honest way of doing business, even if I don't use their software myself due to a couple long-standing limitations that hopefully they'll address soon.