13 ms·
Big Tech lobbyist language made it verbatim into NY’s hedged repair bill
- jmyeet 4y agoThis is neither unsurprising nor uncommon. Here's how this works: billionaires and large companies pour billions into "think tanks", either directly or indirectly. Those think tanks represent a particular set of interests that align with the donors. Part of the job of those think tanks is quite literally to write legislation. There have been cases of certainly state legislation where the legislator introducing the bill has forgotten to take off the think tank's logos. We are in the era of money = political speech thanks almost entirely to 5 justices who voted for the opinion in Citizens United v. FEC [1]. The damage this has done and will continue to do is almost incalculable. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC
- garbagecoder 4y agoLook up your state's legislature and see how many people are employed as staff and analysts and then look at how many bills are proposed every session. Most bills are not written by the legislators or even their staffs, whether or not it's big business, activists groups, or whatever. As for some of the over the top bloviating in this thread, that kind of nonsense just makes opposition useless because it's just not persuasive. "Democracy is a sham" whether or not you believe it in whole or in part or not at all won't help you get anything done and I'm willing to bet that the person saying that doesn't even know how to find what bills are pending in their state, let alone care except when a news headline makes them outraged. If you care that much do something, don't write revolutionary fan fiction. Most laws don't affect you. If they do, support the people who vote how you want. It's not that hard and I'd be willing to bet that for the majority of people here the system is working out just fine for you.
- colinrand 4y agoCouldn't even be bothered to run it through ChatGPT first?
- archi42 4y agoAt least we know it. In the future, it will be "AI, rephrase that bill to resonate better with my voters" and no proofreading.
- karaterobot 4y agoYou get the politicians you vote for. If you hate this, vote for the other candidate next time you get a chance. People voting in corrupt, captured incumbents because they don't want to 'waste their vote', or because they only vote along party lines, is the reason this stuff keeps happening. You could count on the courts, but ultimately you have a responsibility as a voter and can only pass the buck for so long.
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>If you hate this, vote for the other candidate next time you get a chance. More like if you hate this, run for office yourself or get heavily involved in local politics and make sure someone worthwhile is running in the primaries for your chosen political party. Unfortunately without heavy local involvement by citizens who understand and care about the issues the process gets taken over by political machines and corporate money, just like Congress. Then you end up with a choice between (aside from mostly inconsequential culture war issues) two mostly indistinguishable establishment stooges to choose between in the general election.
- calibas 4y agoWhat the word for a government system where large businesses write the laws?
- properGander 4y agoIt’s still a person. Stop buying into euphemisms for person like “employee” and groups of people like “company”. Very militaristic, simplistic fake world with hierarchy. Not a shock many winners in the post-world war economy were also fighters in world wars and our job memes echo the structure they had foisted upon them. How were they to make sense of their business if they weren’t at the top of the hierarchy with a rigid chain of command? Society still has plenty of embedded post-war shell shock and Cold War paranoia in its collective limbic system given all the folks running the world the last few decades were kids in those eras. Just like with religion before, a lot of effort is put to validation and preservation memory of the elders. Prior to world wars 90% of workers were self employed. Many economic truisms are driven by contemporary nostalgia. Whole lot of sunk cost fallacy backing why we organize as we do.
- hayst4ck 4y agoFrankly, I don't see lobbyist language making it into bills as a problem, but which lobbyists language get into the bills. Should you make a law without being informed? No, you would want to have a lot of information and understanding of a problem to make a law, preferably informed by history of attempts at reform and comparison to other countries attempts with critical assessments. Do our political offices have the institutions in place to deeply understand problems and create potential solutions? I doubt we have the time or the resources at our politicians command to do that. Would you be happy if the ACLU, EFF, or whatever political organization you donate to wrote the laws that eventually congress voted on? I think the EFF probably has a better grasp on tech issues than our representatives and I think they could write a better law than our senile stone age dinosaur politicians could. This headline breeds cynicism and completely focuses on the wrong thing. It's not that "a Big Tech lobbyist got language into a bill", but that "Apple, Google, and Samsung corrupted our legal process to benefit themselves over the public."
- kwhitefoot 4y agoIs anyone surprised?
- jessaustin 4y agoOne doubts anyone can muster the energy even to pretend to surprise in this case. It's worth keeping details like this in mind, however, when discussing society-destroying disasters like stupid wars in other hemispheres or insurance-firm-directed health care. We hear lots of arguments that boil down to: "don't criticize democracy; if the'merican people wanted something else they would vote differently!" As we see more clearly in simpler cases like this, in USA we don't have representative government; rather we have an increasingly less convincing simulation of representative government.
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoAnd if the elites only pretend to be democratic, why should the populous accept that quietly and not just rise up?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- voakbasda 4y agoBread and circuses[0] keep the population fed and entertained, and people will put up with a lot of bullshit from their government when those basic needs are met. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bread_and_circuses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bread_and_circuses
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- GeekyBear 4y agoWe're living in the second Gilded Age. >Political corruption was rampant, as business leaders spent significant amounts of money ensuring that government did not regulate the activities of big business—and they more often than not got what they wanted. Such corruption was so commonplace that in 1868 the New York state legislature legalized such bribery. Historian Howard Zinn argues that the U.S. government was acting exactly as Karl Marx described capitalist states: "pretending neutrality to maintain order, but serving the interests of the rich". Historian Mark Wahlgren Summers calls it, "The Era of Good Stealings," noting how machine politicians used "padded expenses, lucrative contracts, outright embezzlements, and illegal bond issues. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilded_Age https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilded_Age
- rom-antics 4y agoSo last time this story made the rounds, the legislature had passed the bill. Then the mayor signed it into law - but not before adding some legalese that roughly amounted to "just kidding lol". Afaik nobody could explain why it was legal for the mayor to add arbitrary language without legislative oversight. Has anyone dove in to figure out how that happened?
- rdedev 4y agohttps://youtu.be/pEZcRR61Bqg https://youtu.be/pEZcRR61Bqg Louis Rossmanns video on what happened. Basically amounts to adding a provision at the last minute when almost everyone in the house is on vacation
- lando2319 4y agoMy understanding is the governor's signed it with an understanding that the legislator would immediately water it down. Which is what happened
- delecti 4y agoHow can they make changes after he signed it though?
- paulette449 4y agoShe [1] [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathy_Hochul https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathy_Hochul
- user3939382 4y agoI’ll remind everyone of the Princeton study that proved our democracy is a sham. Policy outcomes are almost exclusively the product of the preferences of economic elites, not of the People. If you do get a legislative outcome you wanted it’s a coincidence that some big power’s agenda accidentally aligned with your own.
- 0110101001 4y agoThe authors of that study started by filtering down a giant list of survey responses to those where there's a significant difference in responses between the "donor class" and everyone else. I forget exactly how often that happened, but it's a small number. So, just in the premise the study, by needing to throw away almost all the survey responses where everyone agrees and get the policies what they want, actually goes a far way to debunking the populist premise that "economic elites" and "the People" are opposing factions with inherently different political opinions. Further, the study considered the group as "disagreeing" if the margin in survey answers was at least 10%. So if 90% of one group wanted something and 80% of the other, that was considered as them disagreeing. When a follow-up study further filtered responses to questions where more that margin spans the 5% mark, i.e. most people in each group disagree, then the effect completely disappears and it's more or less a coin toss which way policy goes.
- tines 4y ago> The authors of that study started by filtering down a giant list of survey responses to those where there's a significant difference in responses between the "donor class" and everyone else. I forget exactly how often that happened, but it's a small number. > So, just in the premise the study, by needing to throw away almost all the survey responses where everyone agrees and get the policies what they want, actually goes a far way to debunking the populist premise that "economic elites" and "the People" are opposing factions with inherently different political opinions. Help me understand, it sounds like you're saying that "when the poor people agree with the rich people, everyone gets what they want and democracy is proved to be healthy, nevermind that when they disagree, the rich people get what they want anyway." > When a follow-up study further filtered responses to questions where more that margin spans the 5% mark, i.e. most people in each group disagree, then the effect completely disappears and it's more or less a coin toss which way policy goes. So you're saying that when like, 90% of the rich people wanted A and 90% of the poor people wanted B, then it was a coin toss? That would make a good argument if so. Can you link to the study? EDIT: Actually now that I think about it, it doesn't really make a good argument, because the donor class is so much smaller than the non- that if 90% of donors want A and 90% of the poor want B, B should prevail easily. So if it's a coin toss, that's extremely biased, no?
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThe linked article is a report on the original Grist article, https://grist.org/technology/right-to-repair-new-york-hochul-big-tech-lobbying-law/ https://grist.org/technology/right-to-repair-new-york-hochul...
- rqtwteye 4y agoThat’s pretty normal. My ex worked at congress and she said that most bills are reviewed and changed by lobbyists before they are submitted. And a lot of their changes get adopted almost verbatim. Same happens with regulations.
- stcroixx 4y agoIt was my impression lobbyists usually write the bills themselves. I don't know if this is how it's always done, but my company recently worked with lobbyists and a senators assistant and the lobbyists wrote a paragraph that, once approved by this assistant, went straight into the appropriations bill. Perfect example of pay to play.
- GeekyBear 4y ago> It was my impression lobbyists usually write the bills themselves Here's a fairly recent example: > When the legislation that became known as "Obamacare" was first drafted, the key legislator was the Democratic Chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, Max Baucus, whose committee took the lead in drafting the legislation. As Baucus himself repeatedly boasted, the architect of that legislation was Elizabeth Folwer, his chief health policy counsel; indeed, as Marcy Wheeler discovered, it was Fowler who actually drafted it. What was most amazing about all of that was that, before joining Baucus' office as the point person for the health care bill, Fowler was the Vice President for Public Policy and External Affairs (i.e. informal lobbying) at WellPoint, the nation's largest health insurance provider ...as Wheeler wrote at the time: "to the extent that Liz Fowler is the author of this document, we might as well consider WellPoint its author as well." To add insult to injury, the same lobbyist was later put in charge of drawing up the rules to implement the law. >More amazingly still, when the Obama White House needed someone to oversee implementation of Obamacare after the bill passed, it chose . . . Liz Fowler. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/dec/05/obamacare-fowler-lobbyist-industry1 https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/dec/05/obamac... Once the implementation rules were set, she returned to lobbying for the health care industry, this time at Johnson and Johnson. Liberal icon Bill Moyers did a segment on this for his PBS show and it was as close to being openly pissed off on air as I'd ever seen him. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZ5tj4cN9Jk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZ5tj4cN9Jk
- boomboomsubban 4y agoIn the scope of the changes made, it seems fairly innocuous, but does anyone have an idea why they may have cut the $10 minimum? It seems bizarre for the lobbyists to have removed it for no reason, but I can't think of one except something like making cheap watches more expensive could make an Apple watch more appealing. Things that don't seem like realistic goals of the lobbyists.
- college_physics 4y agoWe can blame big tech (or economic elites more generally) for prioritising their financial gain (hence what they can claim from the rest of society) over e.g., ther sustainability and welfare of the very same society on which they lay these claims. We can blame captured politicians for listening to powerful yet minority interests over the interests of the very people who appointed them to these roles. We can blame citizens for making politics (literally) somebody else's business by either abstaining or re-electing people who are unfit for office. We can also blame (some of) them for eagerly contracting with said "big tech" and thus enabling it to have that oversized influence on society in the first place. We can blame soft culture, formal educational systems and journalism for not educating, informing and enabling citizens to play the role that they need to play if the system is to function as it is supposed to. There is plenty of blame to pass around. But there are also some people who cared enough to track and surface this [0],[1] and many other people in other walks of life that care enough to raise a voice, take a stance, or otherwise inconvenience themselves when facing similar malignancy elsewhere. Its a state of mind and it can be flipped. [0] https://themarkup.org/news/2023/02/08/how-big-tech-rewrote-the-nations-first-cellphone-repair-law https://themarkup.org/news/2023/02/08/how-big-tech-rewrote-t... [1] https://grist.org/technology/right-to-repair-new-york-hochul-big-tech-lobbying-law/ https://grist.org/technology/right-to-repair-new-york-hochul...
- rr808 4y agoMost of the readers on HN are big tech.
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoWe can blame HN for providing social engineering tools to make this status permanent, even in a society in decline?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoWe can, but it does not seem like a useful thing to do. Do we blame hammer makers for making better hammers?
- indymike 4y agoLaws are written in the US by the people who have time to write them: interns or lobbyists. Being a legislator is a crappy job where you have little time between fundraising and voting to read the laws you vote on, let alone write them. If you want to make a change, show up and meet in person with state and federal legislators. And if you think, "there outght to be a law" get one written with the help of a few lawyers (who will do this usually for fun and for free) and give it to the the legislator's legislative director.
- jmugan 4y agoMy understanding is that you can't "show and meet with" them unless you are already a significant donor.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y agoThat's not entirely true. It's more like if you are a significant donor your name is always going first on the schedule of meetings for that day. Local constituents will usually get scheduled over and over again until some random 15-min block that the politician usually just glazes over for. They will meet with you if whatever your issues is directly affects their ability to fundraise though.
- indymike 4y ago> local constituents will usually get scheduled over and over again I've had four US different congresspersons from both parties make a lobbyist wait when they found out it was four constituents. All of them said this: "I get so few visitors from home, and I already know what ______ is going to say." I've even ended up at lunch with senators because they are sick of talking to the same people over and over. (I go to DC as a citizen every other year to advocate for things I care deeply about)
- indymike 4y ago> My understanding is that you can't "show and meet with" them unless you are already a significant donor. Very untrue. Very few US legislators will refuse a meeting with a constituent - even if you are a known donor to someone running for their seat! Most legislators have office hours in their home districts (one of my favorite Indiana senators does it at a Starbucks), and at the capitol when the legislature is in session. It may be hard (especially at the US Congress) level to travel to meet. Where most people go wrong is trying to have an adversarial meeting where you have a big debate on some issue. Far better to get a meeting (even better if you invite friends who want to discuss an issue) to discuss how an issue is affecting you, or something you need help with. You may get pushed to a staffer and get a quick meet & greet with the legislator... A lot of people get insulted that the staffer is an intern. Remember, interns are one of two parties that write laws and interns are literally the bulk of most legislator's staff! Also, come armed with real stories, and real people who would like to talk to the rep about the same issue. You'll be amazed how approachable most congresspeople are on most issues.
- no_wizard 4y agoThis sort of thing accelerated in the 80s[0] as businesses in the 70s saught to make lobbying gains as they have seen public interest groups achieve in the 60s an 70s. Another shift, is that it was culturally considered bad practice to become a lobbyist[1] quote: >In 1975 the rare hiring of a former member of Congress as a lobbyist made eyebrows rise When you combine the two, along with the ever decreasing capacity of being a congress member, lobbying effectively supplants the duty of "law making" to a large degree, and thats how we end up with bills that are almost entirely written by lobbyists in the first place. Of course, this opens up the revolving door practice by lobbyist firms to retain their advantage by hiring former congress people, which deepens the entrenched nature of the power of lobbying. [0]: https://web.archive.org/web/20150805124750/https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/04/how-corporate-lobbyists-conquered-american-democracy/390822/# https://web.archive.org/web/20150805124750/https://www.theat... [1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20120524031659/http://blog.washingtonpost.com/citizen-k-street/chapters/introduction/ https://web.archive.org/web/20120524031659/http://blog.washi...
- euroderf 4y agoAny American business knows that the best ROI comes from political donations. No contest.
- mistrial9 4y agothis happened exactly in California under the personal signature of Senator Byron Sher from Palo Alto
- none_to_remain 4y agoI guess the repair chains should have hired better lobbyists
- nimbius 4y agoso i see a lot of posts about the nomenclature of democracy and its machinations of change in favour of elites but i think theres something people are missing here. the amended text is blind and harmful not to the end user in the near term, but to the corporate entity itself in the longterm. as technologies like 3d printing and machining advance, and as the end users equipment becomes evermore cumbersome to engage and repair, it is a foregone conclusion that hackers can and will circumvent, override, and make obsolete the arbitrary controls and restrictions that forbid reasonable owners from performing repair and maintenance outside the confines of a rent-seeker. The sheer volume of people and groups this inconveniences makes this inevitable. manufacturers had their chance to meet on common ground, to re-evaluate their profit strategies and predatory practices, and in the end they fell back on the simplest laurels and chose to poison the legislative assuming this was an absolute control. You cannot stop hackers by doubling down on the very policies they seek to amend, you can only slow them for a time and in the process discourage and infuriate your paying customers. Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo could give a doctoral lecture on this, if agricultural farm equipment manufacturers cared to listen.
- spaced-out 4y ago> You cannot stop hackers by doubling down on the very policies they seek to amend, You're assuming their goal is to "stop" every hacker, it's not. It's to secure this revenue stream for ag tech farm manufacturers, which they've done. They don't care if a handful of hackers fix a few tractors; if any get too big the boot comes down hard and they're ruined by fines and jail time. These changes are meant to block serious competition, by ensuring the vast majority of farmers will need to get their stuff repaired in official shops, which they still will. >Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo could give a doctoral lecture on this On what? How to make tons of money all over the world for decades? Those are some of the most powerful and successful companies in history.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 4y agoWhen government corruption is legalized in the form of "campaign contribution", such kind of issues are inevitable.