4 ms·
US cancer patient developed 'uncontrollable' Irish accent
- raincom 4y agoSpeech is controlled by muscles, which in turn is effected by signals from brain (through nervous system). So, in his case, cancer could be affecting the nervous system.
- Iris2645 4y agoTl;Dr not to waste your time He had brain metastases
- maxbaines 4y agoI have a friend who had a head injury whilst playing rugby, following it he developed a South African accent, took a lot of time and effort to overcome it.
- Mad_as_a_hatter 4y agoReminds me of this short movie! https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cH-yDRPnbOM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cH-yDRPnbOM
- captainmuon 4y agoMakes me wonder if accents are not just random assortments of pronunciation rules, but if there is a biological basis. Linguistic features map to neurological features. E.g. if you grow up speaking a certain dialect with a rolling r, there is a little circuit for that that gets excercised. And if you don't distinguish between certain vowels, your hardware for that remains underdeveloped. That would explain why accents are consistent: There are rhotic and non rhotic accents but AFAIK none where half of the words are like this and the other half like that. Now that I think about it, it is almost certainly true. But it's probably controversial because different dialects are valued differently, and in a way you would be saying ha your funny "dialect X" is just "dialect Y" with a deficit here and an overtraining there. E.g. for the Germans, if a German speaker suddenly had trouble with final consonants, r, and mumbled sh tones they would sound like a speaker from Hesse (no offense :-P). I wonder what features you'd have to loose / gain to turn an English accent into Irish?
- gxt 4y agoAbsolutely not. Talk with second generation immigrants.
- snowpid 4y agowhat is absolutely not?
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThat: "Makes me wonder if accents are not just random assortments of pronunciation rules, but if there is a biological basis." It’s clearly wrong as second generation immigrants don’t share their parents accent.
- anthk 4y agoPeople downvoting you has no idea. I've heard 2nd gen Latinoamerican kids grown in Spain with no overseas traits at all. Not even slang, they spoke native Iberian Spanish from their region.
- poisonarena 4y agoInteresting you mention that, I have noticed that in Spain as well, as well as in Israel(2nd generation immigrants from argentina), and never an accent. But in the USA 2nd and even sometimes 3rd generation kids from whose parents are from Mexico, will have a distinct accent, and I always found it very curious.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThat’s because plenty of kids from 2nd generation immigrants from Mexico actually grow up mostly speaking and hearing Mexican Spanish and very little English because that’s doable in the US. Your accent is entirely depend on your ability to distinguish and form sounds something which kids naturally pick from their environment but become harder as you lose plasticity.
- plpbs 4y agoI knew the whole IRA cease-of-arms thing was bullshit...