5 ms·

It's not fair to assume that's what this teacher asks of their students. Word minimums may be useful for children as a crude deterrent against laziness, but any

by bloppe 4y ago

It's not fair to assume that's what this teacher asks of their students. Word minimums may be useful for children as a crude deterrent against laziness, but any serious student or teacher would recognize a good essay when they see one, no matter the length (though fitting a good and interesting essay on the back of a napkin would be almost unthinkably prolific). "I have made this letter longer than usual, only because I have not had the time to make it shorter." - Blaise Pascal

izacus 4y ago
There's nothing to assume because he describes what he asks of his students towards the last part of the essay. But people who think ChatGPT is great usually aren't capable of reading that far :P
acatnamedjoe 4y ago
A word count is also a signal to the student of what level of depth the teacher is hoping for. For most interesting questions you could write anything between a few sentences and a full book, depending on how much you develop and defend your arguments, evaluate other possible answers, etc. The word count is a signal on where on that spectrum you should be aiming.
firatsarlar 4y ago
If we see Pascal's quote as a pretext, it could be used to justify writing longer texts, even when brevity is possible and appropriate. However, by interpreting the quote as a genuine apology for the length of his letter, we can recognize the importance of clarity and conciseness in communication, and strive to make our own messages as clear and concise as possible. This highlights the importance of interpreting someone's words in the right context, and not using them to justify behaviors or attitudes that are not aligned with the speaker's true intentions. By being mindful of how we interpret others' words, we can avoid misunderstandings and communicate more effectively.
- BlueTemplar 4y ago
  Sorry for the potential insult, but your paragraph feels very ChatGPT-like to me. Did I get that right?

by bloppe 4y ago

izacus 4y ago

There's nothing to assume because he describes what he asks of his students towards the last part of the essay. But people who think ChatGPT is great usually aren't capable of reading that far :P

acatnamedjoe 4y ago

A word count is also a signal to the student of what level of depth the teacher is hoping for. For most interesting questions you could write anything between a few sentences and a full book, depending on how much you develop and defend your arguments, evaluate other possible answers, etc. The word count is a signal on where on that spectrum you should be aiming.

firatsarlar 4y ago

If we see Pascal's quote as a pretext, it could be used to justify writing longer texts, even when brevity is possible and appropriate. However, by interpreting the quote as a genuine apology for the length of his letter, we can recognize the importance of clarity and conciseness in communication, and strive to make our own messages as clear and concise as possible. This highlights the importance of interpreting someone's words in the right context, and not using them to justify behaviors or attitudes that are not aligned with the speaker's true intentions. By being mindful of how we interpret others' words, we can avoid misunderstandings and communicate more effectively.

BlueTemplar 4y ago
Sorry for the potential insult, but your paragraph feels very ChatGPT-like to me. Did I get that right?