7 ms·
Cows Destroyed an Entire Marine Ecosystem in California
- mistrial9 4y agovery clever detective work! being able to date fossils accurately is definitely changing the science game.. can't help but mention a different SoCal ecosystem problem however.. a few tens of thousands of fifty gallon barrels of DDT. keyword search "dilution is the solution to pollution" .. (not kidding, wish I were)
- Retric 4y agoDilution is still commonly used: https://www.elgalabwater.com/blog/solution-pollution-not-always-dilution https://www.elgalabwater.com/blog/solution-pollution-not-alw...
- kornhole 4y agoYes it is hard to blame the destruction of the marine ecosystems all on cows. Industrial agriculture in general caused all kinds of nasty runoff including animal effluent and the many chemicals dumped on fields. Water treatment plants for industrial and residential sewage evolved and surely discharged plenty of other stuff too.
- readthenotes1 4y agoSeems like it's a flash of intuition to blame cows for the change in sedimentation 150 years ago and to discount it for the present.
- nashashmi 4y agoThen there is the line that says there are very few cows now but still the same conditions persist. Meaning it could be a different source and cause of the excess sediments to flow into the ocean. I am going to take a complete negative view when someone mentions overgrazing as the cause of vegetation decline. In South Africa, there is a person who predicted for the British that by removing 30,000 elephants we can restore the land and vegetation. He later went down to regret that and realize it became a lot worse than it was before. The elephants were helping.
- myshpa 4y agoYes, that elephant story is well known, and sad, but there is a difference. Elephants won't stay in one place long enough to overgraze, they tend to migrate and eat something here and there, spread seads from one place to another and make place for new growth in forests by making new paths through the forests, etc. They are helping the ecosystems. We can't say the same of herds of cows, who will happily stay in one place until they eat every little green blade of grass, pull out every last root and trample in the rest, so nothing more than mud remains. In this days it can't be overgrazing that's the problem. Now the animal ag hides the animals, as there are not even enough pastures for all the cows we have. How many farm animals have you seen in the last month, considering that in US alone 19000 land animals is killed every minute (IIRC)? Almost all farm animals are hidden in windowless buildings, out of sight, out of mind. So not freely grazing animals - more likely the problem is runoff from farms (via rivers) now, I presume.
- dgacmu 4y agoThat's not true at all. Almost all cattle are raised on pasture for the first (roughly) half of their life. Then some are raised the rest of the way on pasture (grass-finished) and substantially more are moved to a feedlot, a large outdoor pen where they're fed on a mix of grains, soy, and whatever feedstock is nutritionally sufficient and available cheaply. If you're not seeing them it's because you're not going where they are. Land in places like the bay area is WAY too expensive to use for grazing. C'mon over to Pennsylvania, I can show you thousands of cows within an hour or two of Pittsburgh. (I run an agtech startup that specializes in helping cattle ranchers optimize their grazing operations to reduce the need for buying supplementaln grain and sequester more carbon via improved pasture management.) Overgrazing can absolutely be a problem, as can run-off from feedlots. It's really important to hit the right stocking rate (the number of head of animals per acre) in order to operate regeneratively instead of destructively. (Disclaimer: that's part of what we help ranchers do, so I'm a little biased here! :)
- myshpa 4y ago> https://extension.sdstate.edu/grass-fed-beef-market-share-grass-fed-beef https://extension.sdstate.edu/grass-fed-beef-market-share-gr... (updated June 28, 2021) "About 4% of U.S. beef retail and food service sales is comprised by grass-fed beef with a value of roughly $4 billion. .. There were about 92 million head of cattle in the United States at the end of 2015, with roughly 30 million head slaughtered that year. For perspective, the grass-fed industry currently slaughters about 230,000 head, or less than 1% of the total conventional slaughter." > https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2019/08/13/746576239/is-grass-fed-beef-really-better-for-the-planet-heres-the-science https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2019/08/13/746576239/is... "About 75% to 80% of grass-fed beef sold in the U.S. is grown abroad, from Australia, New Zealand and parts of South America ..." At least we know where the Amazon beef goes to.
- myshpa 4y agoCows or animal husbandry? Let's blame cows ... people are innocent here.
- threatofrain 4y agoThis seems like a bizarre conversation. Blaming people is about the divvying of moral burden. Blaming cows is about causal understanding, unless somehow you thought that discussing the moral responsiblities of cows was on the table.
- myshpa 4y agoI assume that most people on the internet don't read. Maybe the title, first paragraph, skim the rest, look into the discussion, move on. Are you sure that 100% o people who seen this title will know that the article is talking in fact about humans, about our preferences eating cows and dairy, about our mega farms conveniently hidden of our sight, and not some wild creatures bringing havoc to the coastal areas? I'm not so sure.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThis article is more talking about some semi-wild creatures bringing havoc to a coastal area than mega farms conveniently out of site. The Spanish imported livestock, left them out to graze, their population exploded leading to overgrazing that caused erosion. Yeah, humans are ultimately responsible, but not really for the reasons you listed.
- myshpa 4y agoThere may have been semi-wild creatures 150 years ago. That btw doesn't mean they were not farmed, or does it? Are there cow herds running free still there? If not, why is not the marine ecosystem regenerating? If the problem persists, what's the problem now? Maybe those mega farms and associated runoff?
- 4y ago
- calvinmorrison 4y agos/Cows/Humans/
- JoshTko 4y agoMass farming destroyed this ecosystem not cows. We need regulations that enables swift, painful liability for any ecosystem altering industries. CO2, PFAS, BPA, antibiotic resistance, heavy metal contamination, seems like we are barreling towards a uninhabitable hellscape within in our lifetimes.
- benatkin 4y agoI blame Costco. They're at the forefront of making overconsumption fashionable.
- nocsi 4y agoHow do they do that exactly? It’s not like they advertise or fearmonger. It’s consumers devolving down to their survival instincts.
- bhargav 4y agoWalmart is almost 3x sales than Costco [1] 1: https://images.app.goo.gl/ZzusMw52oLywXopP6 https://images.app.goo.gl/ZzusMw52oLywXopP6
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWalmart is most famous for shrink-flation per unit sold. Costco sells bulk units. IME, from a household perspective Costco incentivizes getting more than you need and Walmart on getting the least you're willing to accept. Both are trying to maximize profits, yet by taking different tacts.
- strulovich 4y agoDo you have a family? Costco sizes makes perfect sense for many people. There’s nothing weird about buying 3lb of chicken at once or a 4 pack of butter. It might even be better by minimizing amount of trips and packaging material.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- seltzered_ 4y agoWhile this article is more about Southern California, for Northern California (Marin county) worth also mentioning this article co-authored by Gabriel Rosenberg (@bearistotle) about cattle on Point Reyes , California - "the myth of regenerative ranching" - https://newrepublic.com/article/163735/myth-regenerative-ranching https://newrepublic.com/article/163735/myth-regenerative-ran... "the Harvard Animal Law and Policy Clinic, on behalf of the Animal Legal Defense Fund and a number of individual plaintiffs, filed suit against the Department of the Interior and the National Park Service, which manages Point Reyes National Park, alleging that cattle ranching is endangering the iconic tule elk.* It’s not the first such lawsuit that has been filed over the past decade against the NPS to stop alleged environmental damage from Point Reyes cows."
- jonstewart 4y agoI immediately thought of Point Reyes when I started reading this article — it's such a cool, extreme ecosystem, and then you wonder, "what is that SMELL?" and you turn your head, and there are the cattle herds and tons of cow shit. I'm from the Midwest, grew up on a farm, and I wish California would get out of the livestock business. I've driven by all sorts of CAFOs, but Point Reyes and Harris Ranch take disgusting to a new level. The Midwest has significant water quality issues stemming from big ag that need to be solved, for sure, but California's ecosystems are varied and amazing, and they're being ruined by types of agriculture that's not well-suited to the land.
- mythrwy 4y agoAgreed. I also grew up around cattle and eat beef regularly. No objection to cattle farming at all on my part. But I lived in Arizona and worked with native vegetation for a long time and saw the vast amount of damage cattle did the desert ecosystem. No animal that size lives there natively. Much of the ground was BLM and leased for very nominal fees. Tearing up a desert ecosystem that takes a long time to regenerate for the tiny amount of money produced by skinny parched cows at a subsidy makes no sense at all. I vote we keep the cows, but where they belong and not where they don't belong.
- Lammy 4y agoI would rather have cows than clams and worms though.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoAlternate headline: Milankovitch cycle destroyed an entire coastline with seawater.
- neverrroot 4y agoCows wouldn’t have been able to ever to that on their own. An unhealthy level of human greed likely had something to do with it too.
- BurnGpuBurn 4y ago> Then the lightbulb went off for Kidwell. “The only thing it could have been was cows,” It seems the authors still have to learn the correlation vs causation thing. Concluding it must be cows because you cannot think of another alternative is a really bad way of doing science.
- mattpallissard 4y agoAccording to the author the cows caused this _before_ there were a lot of people. So they were old abandoned ones from the Spaniards? Which were there for 100 years (1770's as stated by author) without causing a problem until the mid 1800's? Which is when LA was incorporated? I dunno man, that looks like a lot of yarn when something like more easily explains it. > He believes that factors such as urban runoff and sewage discharge, which are ongoing, help to explain the higher overall rate of sedimentation. Yeah overgrazing is bad we get it. But whats more disuptive to an area? LA, one of the largest, most rapid, urban developments ever or cows?
- rurban 4y agoUnlikely. Sheep destroy the grass roots, cows not. Destroyed grass roots may leed to sand taking over, which impacts the resistance against the ocean.