4 ms·
Quite the read. Though: >In a 2001 interview about his case study of the grocery-delivery site Webvan, Harvard Business School professor John Deighton said tha
by ghaff 4y ago
Quite the read. Though:
>In a 2001 interview about his case study of the grocery-delivery site Webvan, Harvard Business School professor John Deighton said that direct-to-consumer internet advertising was here to stay, but “home-delivered groceries? Never.” There was no way to compete with supermarket efficiencies. Deighton’s prediction was — not to belabor the point — wrong.
I'd argue that grocery delivery never really became a mainstream business outside of certain bubbles and urban circumstances.
- pm215 4y agoIn the UK it's pretty mainstream (depending how you define that, but more than 12% of grocery sales are online) -- and it's done by the existing supermarket chains, mostly.
- ghaff 4y agoI assume the US is a lot less. (Which makes sense because the US is a lot more spread out and, I assume, more people own cars.) Around where I live there is one service owned by a local supermarket chain plus, mostly, Instacart. I have heard it's bigger in the UK in general. It actually feels like one of those activities were doing more of during the pandemic but pretty much reset on.
- pedrocr 4y agoEveryone is missing the actual point of the quote. The UK is at the top end in terms of online penetration in grocery and even there it's true that there's "no way to compete with supermarket efficiencies". Grocery retail stores are really efficient logistically. No one in the industry has truly cracked the problem of selling profitably online because of that. It's the same players doing physical stores and online because they're cross-subsidizing.
- jedberg 4y agoIt picked up during the pandemic, and a lot of people decided to keep doing it afterwards. My BIL hasn't been to a store in ages. For the few things they can't get delivered, they just ask us to pick it up for them.
- fragmede 4y agoOutside of the places you call a bubble where people use a thing, people don't use it? That's true for just about everything, no?
- jfoutz 4y agoSetting aside very old things like knives and fire, all I can think of is cell phones. Very very few of us seven billion outside that bubble.
- ghaff 4y agoNo. A lot of things are clearly mainstream. Some things are barely used outside of some specific single digit ingroup. I'd bet if I polled my friends I doubt if I'd find a single person who used grocery delivery regularly outside of specific examples--e.g. post-surgery or new kid.
- 7speter 4y agoOnly way it even comes close to making sense is if cars and scooters run on an abundant totally clean energy source, and then the next problem is traffic.
- jamesfinlayson 4y agoI'm in Australia and we used to do it but it wasn't cheap so we stopped (and in the city a supermarket is never too far away, plus shopping on a weeknight evening is much easier than say a Saturday morning). The big supermarkets in Australia periodically push it with free introductory periods though, and I sometimes see the delivery trucks in the neighbourhood so some people must be using it.
- jojobas 4y agoIt also turned out that the extra "cost" in going shopping yourself is not the travel, it's walking around the shelves. So they now offer picking and "direct to boot" pickup at very low fees, good luck competing with that.
- ObviousHumanGPT 4y agoBack in the 200x's Sydney had a pretty amazing centrally fulfilled online grocery delivery service called Shopfast that offered next day delivery for orders before 5pm. https://www.smh.com.au/business/coles-swallows-online-grocer-shopfast-20030521-gdgspy.html https://www.smh.com.au/business/coles-swallows-online-grocer... The Coles-Woolworths supermarket duopoly saw it as an existential threat to their business, so Coles purchased it and shut it down. Coles and Woolworths then simultaneously killed their own online offerings. Shopfast was cashflow positive at the time it was acquired and murdered.